Live data from Hacker News

Google Earth Redesigned

google.com

21–30 of 292 posts

Re: Google Earth Redesigned

#21
post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Because it uses PNaCl

AKA Google ActiveX. This was a bad idea when Microsoft did it and it's still a horrible idea now.

It's ActiveX, but completely secure and open source. Sounds like a good idea.

Regardless, it's pretty much already been killed. Too bad it's taken 8 years for a web standard (WebAssembly) to match it.

Re: Google Earth Redesigned

#24
post #12

Why the hard requirement on Google Chrome?

Maybe they made it so it can run on ChromeOS also ? It's not so different than downloading a Windows application that requires JVM or some .NET distributable, or a Linux package with additional dependencies, IMHO.

I respectfully disagree. [P]NaCl is bad for the web just like ActiveX was.

They have a Google Earth desktop client if you want a desktop application. As this is sitting on the open web it should use open standards.

Re: Google Earth Redesigned

#25
post #15

"Google Chrome is required to run the new Google Earth. Please try this link in Chrome." Get fucked. Embrace, extend, and extinguish. It's ActiveX all over again. PS: I have a 4 Ghz, quad core, i7-6700K CPU, 64GB RAM, 250Mbps internet and this is both poorly working to the point of being impossible to use, and bringing my computer to a halt.

Amen: "Aw snap! The new Google Earth isn't supported by your browser yet".

No. _You_ didn't support my browser. The web is not "Just Chrome" any more than the web was "Just Internet Explorer". Same game, different player.

Re: Google Earth Redesigned

#27
post #21

Earlier quoted context omitted.

AKA Google ActiveX. This was a bad idea when Microsoft did it and it's still a horrible idea now.

It's ActiveX, but completely secure and open source. Sounds like a good idea. Regardless, it's pretty much already been killed. Too bad it's taken 8 years for a web standard (WebAssembly) to match it.

> completely secure

Yeah, there has never been a case of software breaking out of a sandbox or VM.

Fact is it allows running native x86 code downloaded from the internet, it's orders of magnitude more dangerous than e.g. Javascript running inside a sandboxed runtime.

Re: Google Earth Redesigned

#30
post #21

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's ActiveX, but completely secure and open source. Sounds like a good idea. Regardless, it's pretty much already been killed. Too bad it's taken 8 years for a web standard (WebAssembly) to match it.

> completely secure Yeah, there has never been a case of software breaking out of a sandbox or VM. Fact is it allows running native x86 code downloaded from the internet, it's orders of magnitude more dangerous than e.g. Javascript running inside a sandboxed runtime.

Why do you think that? There's been way more bugs in V8 over the years than the NaCl core sandbox.
Post reply on HN