Live data from Hacker News

10 Mph Moving Sidewalks Could Make Crosstown Buses Obsolete

nymag.com

21–30 of 64 posts

Re: 10 Mph Moving Sidewalks Could Make Crosstown Buses Obsolete

#21
post #16

Waaaay too many moving parts if you ask me. I have an alternative idea: Electric monowheels(or kick scooters): -Not fixed-route. -Barely any maintenance. -Even the non-exploding ones cost as much as (subsidized) public transport over their lifetime. -Same speed as this moving sidewalk and bicycles - could potentially share the bike lanes with the latter. Two major disadvantages though are weight and usability in bad…

It's called a Segway.

Re: 10 Mph Moving Sidewalks Could Make Crosstown Buses Obsolete

#22

I visit Toronto quite often. They have a moving sidewalk (conveyor system) in Terminal 3 when you arrive and disembark from your plane. The video of the moving sidewalk they link looks to be the one I'm referring to and if you look at the date it's from 2009. That's probably the last year it was in operation. In the last 2-3 years (and I'm there at least once a month) the moving sidewalks have maintenance signs on th…

The moving walkway pictured in the article is the same one, and it worked two years ago. It was a rush to glide past even the regular moving walkways. A futuristic treat after a long flight and grouchy border guards.

Re: 10 Mph Moving Sidewalks Could Make Crosstown Buses Obsolete

#25
post #20

There was a fast (10 kph) moving sidewalk in the Paris metro station "Montparnasse" for 12 years or so. It never worked out. You can't easily step on it; for years they had to have employees helping people stepping on the fast lane without falling down. And the thing broke down all the time, it was barely available half the time. Finally they replaced it with a good old fashioned 4 kph moving sidewalk. Faster isn't a…

This article is about a walkway that moves slower at the ends, like a ski lift.

Re: 10 Mph Moving Sidewalks Could Make Crosstown Buses Obsolete

#26

Robert A. Heinlein wrote a short story in 1940, "The Roads Must Roll", featuring long-distance, high-speed moving roads, not just sidewalks. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Roads_Must_Roll

Right, and Heinlein's solution to "whizzing past the bakery" was that there would be food service traveling along the road with you. In NYC, maybe very skinny food carts?

Re: 10 Mph Moving Sidewalks Could Make Crosstown Buses Obsolete

#30

And that's because buses are THE WORST form of transportation imaginable. Anything is better than a bus. Buses have never been the opposite of obsolete. They were always a step backwards. Trolleys with dedicated lanes make sense. When travelling distances of less than 30 miles, buses are for people who hate themselves.

A trolley is a bus with an overhead electricity supply.
Post reply on HN