Live data from Hacker News

Amazon imposes limit on reviews

bbc.com

21–30 of 51 posts

Re: Amazon imposes limit on reviews

#21

Contrary to a lot of comments I've seen lately I haven't had any issues with Amazon (is this wrong to say?). Maybe I've just not been purchasing the right (er, wrong) things but I've never had an issue with their customer service or item quality. One time I received an item a day late, got a full refund and a second item was shipped out to me next day. I've been a prime member for the past 6 years or so and I think p…

> "Interesting that this doesn't apply to books. Is that market just vastly different?" Maybe people don't return books when they aren't happy with them? They don't care about fake book reviews anyways. I noticed a "Top 100" book reviewer was just writing the same exact review for every book they reviewed. Reported that and just got their standard "We're sorry you didn't like the review" response.

I was really pissed once when I got a Steve Alten book, it was terrible, then when I looked at the glowing 5-star reviews they were transparently written by him or a delegate. I've never returned a book before, but that time I wanted to do it out of principle.

Re: Amazon imposes limit on reviews

#22
post #18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I recently moved from being twenty miles from a distribution center to the middle of nowhere. After eventually getting annoyed enough to contact Amazon, it was explained that Release Date Delivery and Prime 2-Day Shipping aren't actually guarantees. And that mostly lines up. When I lived next door they were super fast to refund instantly. Now that I don't, they are a lot less likely. A proper return and refund is the…

There is a bit of compensation available. If an item doesn't arrive in 2 days you can request a free month of Prime: https://www.amazon.com/gp/help/customer/display.html?nodeId=... "If you received free shipping through Amazon Prime, you may be eligible for a free one-month extension when the promised delivery date isn't met. Prime Extensions are limited to one per free trial and 12 for an annual membership. Free Ama…

Huh, interesting. I (and my wife) have contacted Amazon a number of times about shipping estimates being off/wrong and have only ever received the same form response (even when we respond to the form response, CS reps just mail back the same form response again). I'll keep this in the pocket for the next time it happens.

Re: Amazon imposes limit on reviews

#23
post #5
post #2

Great, but doesn't come close to solving the actual problem: Amazon's retail catalog is flooded with fakes, drop shippers, bots and low quality products with fake reviews. I almost entirely avoid using them for purchasing home goods at this point, the risk is too great and the customer service is too poor. For things that Amazon itself sells, the cost is often not competitive. For everything else, I can get it cheape…

I haven't had this experience at all. Prime ships in two days almost always. Same day prime does was it says. I've had refunds without having to ship back products, and when I did have to ship back a product (shoes) I got the refund right away and free return shipping like they advertised. I'm also in a major US metro area. Prices don't seem too bad. My latest purchase was head and shoulders. Looked up the price at W…

I pretty much only get two day shipping if I go into the chat and ask for it. Been a Prime member for years; I just went to look at some more baby stuff being sold by Amazon - overnight is guaranteed by Tuesday, 2 Day Prime Shipping is Thursday. Amazon is pretty good about "making an exception" if I open a chat with a rep and call them on their bullshit. I make four or five Prime purchases a week, and rarely do my goods get a guaranteed date of 2 days. (They often show up in two days, but that's not the same thing.)

Re: Amazon imposes limit on reviews

#24
post #2

Great, but doesn't come close to solving the actual problem: Amazon's retail catalog is flooded with fakes, drop shippers, bots and low quality products with fake reviews. I almost entirely avoid using them for purchasing home goods at this point, the risk is too great and the customer service is too poor. For things that Amazon itself sells, the cost is often not competitive. For everything else, I can get it cheape…

Yes, much too little too late for myself and several colleagues.

I seldom use Amazon now except as an ISBN-lookup and general book review facility and even then they often mix together reviews of different but similarly-titled ( non-fiction ) books, despite discrete ISBNs. Their subsidiary ABEBooks is much better for actually buying second-hand books.

What a sad state when I have been shopping on Amazon since 1999 but now find eBay a better experience. I haven't even written an Amazon review in a couple of years, just don't have the motivation anymore.

Re: Amazon imposes limit on reviews

#25
IMO, Amazon should consider hiring a team of professional reviewers to generate curated reviews for select products. I understand they couldn't/wouldn't review everything, but given the stakes of public perception, it appears it might be a good investment.

Re: Amazon imposes limit on reviews

#27
post #2

Great, but doesn't come close to solving the actual problem: Amazon's retail catalog is flooded with fakes, drop shippers, bots and low quality products with fake reviews. I almost entirely avoid using them for purchasing home goods at this point, the risk is too great and the customer service is too poor. For things that Amazon itself sells, the cost is often not competitive. For everything else, I can get it cheape…

I can't stand the "incentivized" reviews, and found this chrome plugin to be really helpful, it basically goes through and tries to remove the fake reviews for you and give you a new, more correct score without them - https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/reviewmetacom-revi...

Re: Amazon imposes limit on reviews

#28
post #25

IMO, Amazon should consider hiring a team of professional reviewers to generate curated reviews for select products. I understand they couldn't/wouldn't review everything, but given the stakes of public perception, it appears it might be a good investment.

you are right - they have done one such acquisition with DPreview - https://www.dpreview.com/articles/1690663587/amazonacquiresd...

Re: Amazon imposes limit on reviews

#29
post #22
post #18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

There is a bit of compensation available. If an item doesn't arrive in 2 days you can request a free month of Prime: https://www.amazon.com/gp/help/customer/display.html?nodeId=... "If you received free shipping through Amazon Prime, you may be eligible for a free one-month extension when the promised delivery date isn't met. Prime Extensions are limited to one per free trial and 12 for an annual membership. Free Ama…

Huh, interesting. I (and my wife) have contacted Amazon a number of times about shipping estimates being off/wrong and have only ever received the same form response (even when we respond to the form response, CS reps just mail back the same form response again). I'll keep this in the pocket for the next time it happens.

I'm not positive, but I think you specifically have to ask for it. Before I found that the best I ever got was a shipping refund if I paid for the 1-day upgrade.

Now I just quote that line and paste the link and it's always approved. They usually act like it's only done as a customer retention move and at the discretion of the support rep.

Re: Amazon imposes limit on reviews

#30
post #26

Good start but it should be zero right?

Why? I bought a book direct from the author, and I liked it enough that I wanted to leave a review. The only place I could think of was Amazon. That was an "unverified purchase", but it was still legit.

Because letting you post your one legitimate review opens the door to spam reviewers who each post five fake reviews a day.

If Amazon can get a sufficient number of verified purchase reviewers, why do we need your review, especially if it opens the doors to abuse?

Post reply on HN