Live data from Hacker News

Why Spotify’s Discover Weekly is getting really boring?

thenextweb.com

21–30 of 53 posts

Re: Why Spotify’s Discover Weekly is getting really boring?

#21

I use Spotify's discover weekly and I'm consistently impressed by the new music that the app shares with me. Bands I've never heard of before that all fit beautifully within the type of music I enjoy. I totally disagree with the author's point.

I am always looking for Mondays because of that playlist. So definitely disagreeing with the author.

[deleted]

Re: Why Spotify’s Discover Weekly is getting really boring?

#22
post #13
post #3

Despite Spotify's vastly superior user interface and a much quicker Android app, I've found myself switching to Apple music for the singular reason that their curated playlists are much, much better than Spotify's. I don't have the hours and hours to spend online on music blogs downloading obscure MP3s like I did while I was at university, trawling through to find stuff I like. So now finding new music is more of a c…

If you used to like finding new music through blogs, Hype machine does a pretty awesome job of taking the pain out of trawling for new stuff. They aggregate everything for you on their site so you just see and stream a playlist of music from all of the blogs you follow.

Good tip, thanks! i just found the Hype Machine "profile" on spotify and now I'm following their playlists.

Re: Why Spotify’s Discover Weekly is getting really boring?

#24

Discover Weekly in this article is a microcosm of the problems with Spotify generally. Spotify (especially on desktop) has a LOT of issues. From poorly implemented shuffle play to random removal of features (notifications to ctrl-f to playlist organization), and a complicated by a total lack of dev communication on any platform. I think the issue with Spotify is not that their core is bad, it's that they never manage…

The Spotify desktop client randomly consuming 100% of a CPU core (sending the fan crazy) was what actually pushed me onto Apple Music.

Re: Why Spotify’s Discover Weekly is getting really boring?

#25

I definitely disagree with the premise of the article. I have a playlist where I pull in my favorites from Discover Weekly, and it just turned one year old. I still consistently get great new songs to add to the playlist. I've also gleaned some insight into my general disposition over the least year from the playlist. I can tell exactly when I was in a "mood" or a rut... When I was listening to lots of angry music, t…

>I have a playlist where I pull in my favorites from Discover Weekly

Do you do this manually, or use the API?

Re: Why Spotify’s Discover Weekly is getting really boring?

#26
Having talked with people that have close insight into Discover Weekly it actually only checks your last few thousand songs though (weighting them accordingly) and checks if those songs are on other peoples playlists, then choosing the songs on their playlists that are not on yours. This means that you have a pretty big pool of songs to start with (people with similar taste) that is getting smaller and smaller. The fact that those people also use discover weekly could lead to a bit of a feedback loop.

I found a friend who during a party came up and said "I listen to this song all the time, it's amazing!" and then the next and the next and the next song the same happened. We had been listening to the same (semi-obscure) music for the majority of the past year. It was only later that we discovered that we had both found the songs from discover weekly and were not at all as obscure and knowledgable about music, but hey: we had the same taste in music.

Re: Why Spotify’s Discover Weekly is getting really boring?

#27

Discover Weekly in this article is a microcosm of the problems with Spotify generally. Spotify (especially on desktop) has a LOT of issues. From poorly implemented shuffle play to random removal of features (notifications to ctrl-f to playlist organization), and a complicated by a total lack of dev communication on any platform. I think the issue with Spotify is not that their core is bad, it's that they never manage…

Regarding their desktop client; totally true. I recently discovered that keeping the Spotify App idle over 2 days, it had written 50 GB to my SSD. Not worth killing my disk over this service.

Recommend this thread, where I became aware of the problem https://www.reddit.com/r/apple/comments/56auoi/huge_amount_o...

Re: Why Spotify’s Discover Weekly is getting really boring?

#28
My guess: take jazz fans on one hand, and Justin Bieber groupies on the other hand. The jazz fans would in general appreciate way more the DW service than the Justin Bieber ones. Why so? Because the 'vector' that describes a jazz fan's playlist is probably much more specific and 'unique' than the vector of an heavily standardised MTV-based playlist. Everyone gets the recommendations they deserve...

Re: Why Spotify’s Discover Weekly is getting really boring?

#29
post #26

Having talked with people that have close insight into Discover Weekly it actually only checks your last few thousand songs though (weighting them accordingly) and checks if those songs are on other peoples playlists, then choosing the songs on their playlists that are not on yours. This means that you have a pretty big pool of songs to start with (people with similar taste) that is getting smaller and smaller. The f…

Please don't reveal intellectual property secrets on HN. It sounds like you got that information from a privileged source.

(EDIT: I was wrong; this algorithm is public knowledge.)

Post reply on HN