Live data from Hacker News

The German reference letter system

englishjobs.de

21–30 of 57 posts

Re: The German reference letter system

#23

If you're interested in hiring German developers on your team, leading with the fact you're not looking for someone with Doctor Professor in their title, you don't need apostilled copies of every certificate since kindergarten, and you don't need codified reference letters for every job will expand your market considerably. I've placed several Germans in London development positions now, many of whom were surprised w…

> someone with Doctor Professor in their title

Or Doctor Doctor Professor

Re: The German reference letter system

#24

This is just nasty, because it's asymmetrical. It enables bad employers to dis disgruntled employees who might be right in their disappointment.

Not really. The letters have to be truthful, not just "positive". You can sue former employers who are being dishonest despite using "positive" language.

Re: The German reference letter system

#25
The reference letter system is bullshit.

Besides, most of them are written by the employee himself upon the request of the employer (too busy, can you write it yourself and I sign it?). My advice would be: If in doubt, fake it. The chance the the company will call your previous employer are not zero but close to zero. Even if they call they would just asked if you worked there and not if the letter of recommendation is genuine.

Side Story: I remember when I applied to a (non IT) job closely related to field of expertise at BASF. I upload a shitload of documents into their nightmarish SAP application interface. A few days later I get an email: Thank you for your application but please also upload the letters or reference. I wrote back, that since I was living in the US the last years, I don't have such letters since such letters are not common there but I would be happy to provide references (from MAJOR names by the way).

They wrote back: If you don't have reference letters then we don't need you. We deleted your application from the system (an application that too a tremendous time to create thanks to the SAP application interface bullshit).

So, the bottom line:

1. Letters of reference are bullshit in most cases. If you really need them, FAKE them. No kidding! 2. Don't take this German nonsense in any way as a good example. A phone call is a better thing. In IT I assume you rarely need it. A friend told me: "If I hire somebody I don't need his resume. I just want to have a look at hit git account." 3. If you ever hear on of the Bozos from BASF or Evionik speaking in public of "not enough supply of skilled people" then you know in which category to put them.

Re: The German reference letter system

#26
post #24

This is just nasty, because it's asymmetrical. It enables bad employers to dis disgruntled employees who might be right in their disappointment.

Not really. The letters have to be truthful, not just "positive". You can sue former employers who are being dishonest despite using "positive" language.

Sure, but you can't equally review your employers, so whatever they say will sound more authoritative than it should.

With this system, "not so good review" means "bad employee" and "good review" means "good employee".

If it was possible to equally comment on the employer, a "not so good review" from an unreliable employer would be less important than a "not so good review" from a reliable employer.

Re: The German reference letter system

#27
I got offered a job in Switzerland last year. It was the weirdest experience ever.

What I suspect happened was I'd written "scrum certified" on my cv, and the job had "scrum manager" in the title, so the poor people were bound by the law of stupid to interview only people with this string in their cv.

They never asked me anything relevant. I code a bunch of languages, I can manage people, yada yada, they didn't care. I don't know why on earth they wanted to hire me after chatting briefly about my experience and doing some silly think-out-of-the-box exercise. The HR lady then proceeded to tell me about the great benefits of working for them (they pay your mortgage, not bad eh?). One of the strangest things about the interview was that the HR person was there at all, and leading it. She presented the manager, who politely said hello, and then sat there as she asked me every inane and cliche question you've ever heard.

So then it got to the documentation stage. They asked for this reference letter, which I had, but I warned them my previous employer was... Me! So obviously they shouldn't be surprised if it was a bit flattering and signed by some partner of mine. Didn't matter. Just give us the letter!

And then they also wanted my graduation certificate. Now for years I've not needed this document, I actually did not know what certificate from my school looked like. At Oxford you have to sign up for a weird Latin ceremony, which I didn't do because I'd started work the week after finishing uni. So this lady insisted on getting a signed cert from the university office. I reminded her is was over a decade ago, but no help. Luckily I was passing through anyway.

I also hinted quite strongly that it might not be the right kind of work for me, and that I might want some sort of term limited contract. Didn't seem to matter.

Re: The German reference letter system

#28
At my company (London based startup) we always call references to get a verbal reference and ask specific questions (what were their main weaknesses, what's the best way to manage them to get the best out of them, etc.) rather than asking for a generic reference.

For more senior hires we get backdoor references through our own network (with the candidates permission) to ensure the candidate isn't just giving us their friends, etc.

Re: The German reference letter system

#29
post #3

In my trade, people usually only resign after they have another job offer (as in contract in their hands). I guess if I was in Germany it would circumvent this reference system at least for the current employer?

As others have noted, there are interim letters that you can request without reason at any time. But, there are also events that allow you to request them due to that event. For example if your team lead switches jobs, you can request an interim letter due to that, and it will be noted that this is the reason for writing it.

Those do not tip your hand and you requesting them is considered absolutely reasonable - how would your new boss of 3 months write that letter for your entire employment? These are what you use while still employed.

Re: The German reference letter system

#30
If you look beyond the grading via weird reference letter language, these letters contain usually one important thing: what you actually did. Not what your job description said, but your actual daily doings and responsibilities.

That is the part I like about them, especially if you answer a job ad that requests prior experience with FOO.

And while it is true that you can sometimes get your grade bumped up as part of some deal (and everybody knows it); I have never heard of a company that signs off on this list containing stuff you did in fact not do.

Post reply on HN