Live data from Hacker News

DeepExcel – Deep learning in Excel

deepexcel.net

21–30 of 35 posts

Re: DeepExcel – Deep learning in Excel

#21

Oh boy. I'm the second author. The official announcement will be in April 1st at the SIGBOVIK conference ( http://sigbovik.org/2016 ), but I guess someone broke the press embargo! By the way: It works, try it ;)

Very funny. A ton of people, I suspect, will take this seriously.

If I may, let me suggest you add a note about your future plans to add backpropagation using Excel/Libreoffice macros, which "might allow users to train large-scale models from scratch within their lifetime."

Re: DeepExcel – Deep learning in Excel

#24
post #21

Oh boy. I'm the second author. The official announcement will be in April 1st at the SIGBOVIK conference ( http://sigbovik.org/2016 ), but I guess someone broke the press embargo! By the way: It works, try it ;)

Very funny. A ton of people, I suspect, will take this seriously. If I may, let me suggest you add a note about your future plans to add backpropagation using Excel/Libreoffice macros, which "might allow users to train large-scale models from scratch within their lifetime."

I think it's feasible, even without macros! Just have to make our case to our advisors for it.

Re: DeepExcel – Deep learning in Excel

#25
post #2

Don't want to be an asshole but it really can't be called Deep Learning if it doesn't do backprob. Deep inference, at best. The paper reads like a bad joke.

Backprop may be added in the future. Meanwhile you can just adjust the weights directly! (They're in the "layer*" sheets).

Re: DeepExcel – Deep learning in Excel

#26
post #14

You guys laugh, people in the business world would take this seriously and check with their IT department if the Company has bought copies yet

It makes me wonder though: could excel formulas be sped up using the GPU?

Yes https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n0P3Y8_2Dfo

Re: DeepExcel – Deep learning in Excel

#29
post #21

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Very funny. A ton of people, I suspect, will take this seriously. If I may, let me suggest you add a note about your future plans to add backpropagation using Excel/Libreoffice macros, which "might allow users to train large-scale models from scratch within their lifetime."

I think it's feasible, even without macros! Just have to make our case to our advisors for it.

What about a distributed version built in Google docs?

Re: DeepExcel – Deep learning in Excel

#30
Would people who understand deep learning enough to apply it properly every use Excel?

Every time I've used Excel for a complex problem I've regretted it. Even simple things like joins using VLOOKUPs are incredibly clunky and error prone.

Post reply on HN