Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Would you go to Iraq for a year and be paid $200k?

news.ycombinator.com

21–30 of 91 posts

Re: Ask HN: Would you go to Iraq for a year and be paid $200k?

#21
If there's a 3% chance of a mortar landing near you, is that worth it? Honest question. A lot of folks would risk their life for a 3% chance at any significant amount of money. Personally, I wouldn't- I would rather keep my 'risks of dying' to things like mugging (.05%/day), bus crashes (.005%/day), and dying in a nuclear holocaust (.00005%/day).

Just a matter of how much risk you're cool with.

Re: Ask HN: Would you go to Iraq for a year and be paid $200k?

#22
post #14

Allow me to be the dissenter. If you're doing this for the military or the government, I would urge you to consider if your work is contributing to all of the wrong reasons why we (as a country) are there, or if it's going to contribute to helping correct the mistakes that got us there. Is war really something you want to experience? Things are calm there now, relative to a few years ago, but - imho - still is a pret…

I'm pretty sure these gigs are tax free for the first $80k.

Re: Ask HN: Would you go to Iraq for a year and be paid $200k?

#25

If there's a 3% chance of a mortar landing near you, is that worth it? Honest question. A lot of folks would risk their life for a 3% chance at any significant amount of money. Personally, I wouldn't- I would rather keep my 'risks of dying' to things like mugging (.05%/day), bus crashes (.005%/day), and dying in a nuclear holocaust (.00005%/day). Just a matter of how much risk you're cool with.

strange how first hand stories, speak of 3 shells coming into a gym where people are training, along a straight line, luckily my brother, leaped behind sandbags and just prayed that the fourth one didn't come down on top of him.

it didn't come in, but people died.

3% chance, more like 3 shells at a go.

Re: Ask HN: Would you go to Iraq for a year and be paid $200k?

#26
Yes. Very solid yes.

You don't see much of this in the media, but Iraq is a stunningly beautiful country. There's a lot that you can learn from the people there (and certainly much they could learn from you), and the Arabic language is nothing short of remarkable.

Diving head-first into another culture is one of the few educations that the Internet and college cannot fully convey via text. You won't regret it.

Re: Ask HN: Would you go to Iraq for a year and be paid $200k?

#27
post #10
post #6

sounds like an interesting decision. best of luck. one thing to keep in mind is that 200k probably means more like 100k after taxes. that only leaves you about 20k overhead after you pay your student loans. just something to think about.

Usually the first $80k is tax-free for travels to Iraq/Afghanistan, after that you get taxed at the "normal" rate.

A friend of mine did this kind of work. He worked for KBR as some kind of contractor (in the green zone, out of the field). He said he grossed 216k in one year, 80k tax free. He also said that because he was always in the same location and working 12/hrs day, meals free, room free, he spent very little of what he earned. This was 2007, and he was ex-military, so mmv.

Re: Ask HN: Would you go to Iraq for a year and be paid $200k?

#28

As long as it'd be safe, I'd go for it without hesitation. New place, fun work, big accomplishment, lots of money and free time? I'm not sure what down side you see, but it would need to be huge to turn this down.

my mind says yes, but my body says stay the fuck away, I dont wanna die. So the question still remains and I definitely am looking for advice.

One thing to consider is whether or not you are rationally evaluating the safety of the situation. We are not privy to the details, but you should keep in mind the fact that most of the new you will get about that particular location is "news" because it is basically bad news. Like airline travel, you don't hear the "person gets on plane, has boring trip, gets off plane" stories but instead only notice the events that end up killing people. I would suggest you try to get as much information as you can about the reality of your potential situation over there and then compare it to the violent crime rate in your current location. Once you have established some baseline facts you will be in a much better position to decide if the experience/money is worth any additional risk that might be involved.

Re: Ask HN: Would you go to Iraq for a year and be paid $200k?

#30

Pretend the salary is the same in both places, and judge the decision just on the experience factor. (I say this because for a variety of reasons, you could make that much money in the States as a reasonably curious, skilled person. You read Hacker News after all :D You know all about salary ranges, entrepreneurship, affiliate programs, Parrot Books, and Adsense. I'm not saying we all make 200K, we just all know abou…

"Pretend the salary is the same in both places, and judge the decision just on the experience factor. I say this because for a variety of reasons, you could make that much money in the States as a reasonably curious, skilled person."

200K for one year in Iraq might actually be significantly more than 200K for one year in California, for instance, depending on cost of living. I can't imagine actually buying anything in Iraq would cost much (or be that compelling of an option), so if room and board is either cheap or included with the job, you might save a lot of the 200K.

Post reply on HN