Live data from Hacker News

The iPad Literally Breaks Every Use Case I Had For It

layeredbyte.com

21–30 of 69 posts

Re: The iPad Literally Breaks Every Use Case I Had For It

#21

You can't convince fanboys that lack of features will eventually lead to pain for the users.

To be fair, Apple might buckle on some of these issues in the future, but you're still making a gamble on that if you get the iPad thinking that those features will come later.

Re: The iPad Literally Breaks Every Use Case I Had For It

#22
post #9

"Even past the fact that the iPad does not have a camera, it cannot run two applications at the same time. Meaning: talking to my girlfriend, I could not look up a train time while we talked. Result: have to use my iPhone while we video chat. All that in a device that commands a price premium." How do you video chat using an iPhone, which has a camera on the back? "Again, we run into a software problem. From what I h…

> There are many casual games in the App Store, including many tower defence games (my favourite is Star Defence, but there are plenty of good free ones, if 99c is too dear). This is only going to increase with Flash CS5.

Why make people pay when there's FREE games out there online if only flash were supported. Flash support means opening up to a whole world of preexisting games, rich internet applications, and porn sites.

But not allowing flash creates an artificial monopoly that is the app store.

Re: The iPad Literally Breaks Every Use Case I Had For It

#24

You can't convince fanboys that lack of features will eventually lead to pain for the users.

You also can't convince nerds that excessive degrees of freedom are a serious usability problem.

After all, doing six things at once while remembering the state of a bunch of invisible stateful objects -- tabs, background apps, file hierarchies -- is the nerd core skill.

Meanwhile, I would note that Apple has apparently sold about 35 million iPod Touches:

http://theappleblog.com/2010/01/28/ipod-touch-now-outselling...

... which exhibit the exact same set of "missing features" as the iPad.

Re: The iPad Literally Breaks Every Use Case I Had For It

#25
post #17

iPad is really good at doing what it's designed to do, and really bad otherwise. It's not a satisfy all device, as we've seen in the response to it so far.

Really? What the fuck was it supposed to be really good at doing? Running the iphone OS?

I'm sure Steve wasn't an idiot. He definitely designed this product for a specific type of user and it's probably really good at doing that. I just don't know what that is. But I'm certain he didn't slap on a bunch of random features that didn't go well together.

Re: The iPad Literally Breaks Every Use Case I Had For It

#26

I don't really get why everyone is talking about Flash and its relation to porn. If the the number of non-Flash playing devices grows, couldn't these porn sites just go to HTML5?(this applies to all other video sites, actually)

Well, he could also be talking about no flash memory card slot. If you were to watch non-streaming porn on the device, I doubt that you would want it to be in the same place on the device as your regular movies (lest you hand the iPad to someone else that stumbles across them). You would probably want to have your porn on a memory card that you could remove when you are no longer using it.

Re: The iPad Literally Breaks Every Use Case I Had For It

#27

I don't really get why everyone is talking about Flash and its relation to porn. If the the number of non-Flash playing devices grows, couldn't these porn sites just go to HTML5?(this applies to all other video sites, actually)

I'm pretty sure porn sites will adapt pretty fast. Nobody wants to be the last porn site not supported on the iPad.

Re: The iPad Literally Breaks Every Use Case I Had For It

#28
post #18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I've always envisioned watching TV on a TV while I have the iPad on the couch doing other stuff.

That may be, but in the Keynote they did push the 'you can watch 10 hours of video on a single charge' so they are pushing this as a device to watch video on. If it fails at video, then it's a failure of the device if that is one of its goals.

They also pushed YouTube on the iPhone and video on the iPhone. Both features have been unpractical for me (converting videos, tiny screen, battery drain with 3G video) and the Youtube feature just seems to have been a selling point tacked on.

Re: The iPad Literally Breaks Every Use Case I Had For It

#30
post #5

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It allows for multiple windows, which is somewhat similar.

I didn't understand his objection here. Is it the inconvenience of hitting the "windows" button? With the iphone's touch interface this is painless and I can't imagine it'll be any worse for the ipad.

Well, for starters, any inconvenience sucks. Glad I got that out of the way =]

His example of having (AT LEAST) 8 tabs open is not the same as eight windows. Searching through all of them can be quite the inconvenience. I, for example, currently have 14 tabs open, and six applications running. I do not want to search through all of those to get to what should be "another tab." I understand what he's talking about...

Post reply on HN