Live data from Hacker News

The Amazon Whisperer (2013)

fastcompany.com

21–30 of 87 posts

Re: The Amazon Whisperer (2013)

#21

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Jews stick together. One of reasons for their resilience and business success. Unsurprising he brought a lot of his own in on the business. They do that in upper-ranks in my area, too. Now, you probably won't see the media report on racist hiring practices in Jewish companies as quickly as they do anti-Semitism. ;)

I don't think it's a racist hiring practice, it's religious nepotism. Mormons and scientologists often stick together in the same way (and really probably any small group of people very closely connected; immigrants often initially do the same thing in a new country as well).

It's still technically illegal if they turn down qualified applicants for jobs that were not the same religion/sect/cult.

Re: The Amazon Whisperer (2013)

#22
post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

au contraire: http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00TQ5TDLC

Does it bother anyone else that the three customer reviews on the product page all give five stars, and all three reviewers received the product for free in exchange for an 'unbiased' review? (And that fact is only visible if you click each 'see more' link at the end of the truncated review). I just have a hard time believing this practice doesn't create bias, even if unintentional. I'm finding I have to work harder…

Amazon has begun firing off lawsuits against review stacking companies specifically to fight this type of problem.

http://money.cnn.com/2015/10/18/technology/amazon-lawsuit-fa...

Re: The Amazon Whisperer (2013)

#23
post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

au contraire: http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00TQ5TDLC

Note that the most helpful review is someone who did not buy one. Same with the second. And the third. > Sample provided for review. > Got this at no cost for unbiased review. > *I received a sample product from Ivation. Reviews are much more scattered if you filter by "Verified purchase only". It's interesting that this drops the number of reviews from 165 to 104 for a product which is designed for and presumably so…

This type of review has ruined any tentative faith I used to have in Amazon reviews.

Re: The Amazon Whisperer (2013)

#24
post #15

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Does it bother anyone else that the three customer reviews on the product page all give five stars, and all three reviewers received the product for free in exchange for an 'unbiased' review? (And that fact is only visible if you click each 'see more' link at the end of the truncated review). I just have a hard time believing this practice doesn't create bias, even if unintentional. I'm finding I have to work harder…

Completely ignore amazon reviews. They are mostly bogus these days. Unless you can find 3 star reviews, I usually read those.

If you think a review is bogus you could always click the "no" button to indicate that the review is not helpful.

You can also report the review and tell Amazon that you think the review is bogus.

Do you have any data to back up the claim that most of the recent reviews are bogus?

Re: The Amazon Whisperer (2013)

#25
post #21

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don't think it's a racist hiring practice, it's religious nepotism. Mormons and scientologists often stick together in the same way (and really probably any small group of people very closely connected; immigrants often initially do the same thing in a new country as well).

It's still technically illegal if they turn down qualified applicants for jobs that were not the same religion/sect/cult.

Just guessing, but they probably just post Yiddish only job ads in the local Jewish paper (there are plenty in North Jersey and NYC).

Re: The Amazon Whisperer (2013)

#26
Its interesting to think about why this enterprise succeeds and yet Quirky, for example stumbled: this one starts with a known selling product and iterates on it based on market demand, rather than just coming up with cool ideas, perhaps. (I'm actually a fan of Quirky so this isn't really intended as a dis, but one of these two has "nine-figure" (really?) sales, and one doesn't)

Re: The Amazon Whisperer (2013)

#27

> Before us are rows of cubicles, almost entirely inhabited by bearded, yarmulke-wearing men in crisp white shirts. These are Pikarski's buyers. (About half of C&A Marketing's 150-person staff is Orthodox, though the buyers division is more homogenous. "The buyer that does all the storage products, he's the only guy I let work out of home," Pikarski says. "He's Italian.") Did that bother anyone else?

[deleted]

Re: The Amazon Whisperer (2013)

#28
post #24
post #15

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Completely ignore amazon reviews. They are mostly bogus these days. Unless you can find 3 star reviews, I usually read those.

If you think a review is bogus you could always click the "no" button to indicate that the review is not helpful. You can also report the review and tell Amazon that you think the review is bogus. Do you have any data to back up the claim that most of the recent reviews are bogus?

Yeah, all the ones that start with "I received the complimentary product" in some form.

That's a bogus review, it's paid. You might argue free product is not payment but the IRS would then like to have a word with you (ask the people who got "free" cars from Oprah).

Re: The Amazon Whisperer (2013)

#29

> Before us are rows of cubicles, almost entirely inhabited by bearded, yarmulke-wearing men in crisp white shirts. These are Pikarski's buyers. (About half of C&A Marketing's 150-person staff is Orthodox, though the buyers division is more homogenous. "The buyer that does all the storage products, he's the only guy I let work out of home," Pikarski says. "He's Italian.") Did that bother anyone else?

[deleted]
Post reply on HN