Live data from Hacker News

Entrepreneurs are redesigning the basic building block of capitalism

economist.com

21–30 of 31 posts

Re: Entrepreneurs are redesigning the basic building block of capitalism

#21
post #20

Someone commented this but deleted it because they were getting downvoted: Land ownership, intellectual property and limited liability ownership of companies by individuals are the basic building blocks of capitalism. I.e., property forms guaranteed by the government. Which one of these are being challenged by unicorn startups, again? I think this is spot on and deserves repeating. Unicorn startups are changing the w…

Some people argue that Uber and AirBNB are not actually changing the way we use capital on a fundamental economic level, but are instead using new channels in a way, and with a magnitude, never used before. IMHO I tend not to agree with the hole "Sharing Economy is The Next Capitalist Revolution" thesis.

I'd be curious if it's really an unprecedented magnitude (not impossible that it is, but I haven't seen numbers). For lodging, for example, it'd be interesting if someone could estimate at least approximate numbers for what proportion of the paid travel-lodging market was served by formal hotels vs. informal lodging arrangements in various cities over the decades. From what I've read of New York City (but no numbers), there has been a pretty wide array of lodging besides "proper" hotels in various periods, ranging from families running a few spare rooms as a boarding-house business, to large-scale "flophouse" operations. And, like today, it has been a political issue and led to debate over regulations periodically.

Re: Entrepreneurs are redesigning the basic building block of capitalism

#22
post #20

Someone commented this but deleted it because they were getting downvoted: Land ownership, intellectual property and limited liability ownership of companies by individuals are the basic building blocks of capitalism. I.e., property forms guaranteed by the government. Which one of these are being challenged by unicorn startups, again? I think this is spot on and deserves repeating. Unicorn startups are changing the w…

Some people argue that Uber and AirBNB are not actually changing the way we use capital on a fundamental economic level, but are instead using new channels in a way, and with a magnitude, never used before. IMHO I tend not to agree with the hole "Sharing Economy is The Next Capitalist Revolution" thesis.

Uber and AirBnb are simply reducing the friction and reducing barriers to entry.

Re: Entrepreneurs are redesigning the basic building block of capitalism

#23
post #20

Someone commented this but deleted it because they were getting downvoted: Land ownership, intellectual property and limited liability ownership of companies by individuals are the basic building blocks of capitalism. I.e., property forms guaranteed by the government. Which one of these are being challenged by unicorn startups, again? I think this is spot on and deserves repeating. Unicorn startups are changing the w…

Some people argue that Uber and AirBNB are not actually changing the way we use capital on a fundamental economic level, but are instead using new channels in a way, and with a magnitude, never used before. IMHO I tend not to agree with the hole "Sharing Economy is The Next Capitalist Revolution" thesis.

I think the "sharing economy" represents a significant change, and things like AirBNB or Zipcar constitute major parts of that change. I don't, however, see why Uber gets lumped into that. Uber is not a "ride sharing" service; it's a transportation service to connect professional drivers to people getting driven.

Re: Entrepreneurs are redesigning the basic building block of capitalism

#24
post #22
post #20

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Some people argue that Uber and AirBNB are not actually changing the way we use capital on a fundamental economic level, but are instead using new channels in a way, and with a magnitude, never used before. IMHO I tend not to agree with the hole "Sharing Economy is The Next Capitalist Revolution" thesis.

Uber and AirBnb are simply reducing the friction and reducing barriers to entry.

Or are they eroding laws and customs built up and evolved over time to manage complicated situations without clear-cut solutions in order that they can extract wealth and feed off society without contributing value? Frankly, I see both of those companies as parasites.

Re: Entrepreneurs are redesigning the basic building block of capitalism

#25

Someone commented this but deleted it because they were getting downvoted: Land ownership, intellectual property and limited liability ownership of companies by individuals are the basic building blocks of capitalism. I.e., property forms guaranteed by the government. Which one of these are being challenged by unicorn startups, again? I think this is spot on and deserves repeating. Unicorn startups are changing the w…

If anyone is changing the fundamental fabric of capitalism then it's the Chinese. They are ignoring intellectual property, the government prints its own money and hands it directly to the the banks that operate as partially privatized central planning with heavy political control.

Re: Entrepreneurs are redesigning the basic building block of capitalism

#26

Someone commented this but deleted it because they were getting downvoted: Land ownership, intellectual property and limited liability ownership of companies by individuals are the basic building blocks of capitalism. I.e., property forms guaranteed by the government. Which one of these are being challenged by unicorn startups, again? I think this is spot on and deserves repeating. Unicorn startups are changing the w…

Nor are they addressing the reproduction of the classes shown by historical materialism to be just as fundamental a building block as the legalistic ones.

Re: Entrepreneurs are redesigning the basic building block of capitalism

#27
post #6

Not a great article, and I think it misses the one big thing that is genuinely revolutionary about the Silicon Valley form of entrepreneurship. And that's that venture-backed entrepreneurial companies are, by and large, the new Research & Development Departments. Acquihires can in fact be great deals for VCs, founders, employees, and acquirers. Many companies are curtailing their own research agendas and relying upon…

I generally agree with your statement but personally I'd pull back on calling start-ups as R&D replacements. There are certainly a few start-ups taking big R&D-type gambles, but I think most people are working in some sort of technology-applied-to-old-industry role.

Therefore I'd liken start-ups to product team replacements or consulting + validation as seen from a big company's perspective.

Re: Entrepreneurs are redesigning the basic building block of capitalism

#28

Someone commented this but deleted it because they were getting downvoted: Land ownership, intellectual property and limited liability ownership of companies by individuals are the basic building blocks of capitalism. I.e., property forms guaranteed by the government. Which one of these are being challenged by unicorn startups, again? I think this is spot on and deserves repeating. Unicorn startups are changing the w…

If anyone is changing the fundamental fabric of capitalism then it's the Chinese. They are ignoring intellectual property, the government prints its own money and hands it directly to the the banks that operate as partially privatized central planning with heavy political control.

[deleted]

Re: Entrepreneurs are redesigning the basic building block of capitalism

#29
post #20

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Some people argue that Uber and AirBNB are not actually changing the way we use capital on a fundamental economic level, but are instead using new channels in a way, and with a magnitude, never used before. IMHO I tend not to agree with the hole "Sharing Economy is The Next Capitalist Revolution" thesis.

I think the "sharing economy" represents a significant change, and things like AirBNB or Zipcar constitute major parts of that change. I don't, however, see why Uber gets lumped into that. Uber is not a "ride sharing" service; it's a transportation service to connect professional drivers to people getting driven.

> it's a transportation service to connect professional drivers to people getting driven.

It looks more like a "service" that destroys a job in which people can support their family and replaces it with another hand-to-mouth subsistence job.

Re: Entrepreneurs are redesigning the basic building block of capitalism

#30
post #22

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Uber and AirBnb are simply reducing the friction and reducing barriers to entry.

Or are they eroding laws and customs built up and evolved over time to manage complicated situations without clear-cut solutions in order that they can extract wealth and feed off society without contributing value? Frankly, I see both of those companies as parasites.

If they really didn't contribute any value we wouldn't be talking about them, they'd have died a long time ago.
Post reply on HN