Live data from Hacker News

In China, Your Credit Score Is Affected by Your Political Opinions

privateinternetaccess.com

21–30 of 89 posts

Re: In China, Your Credit Score Is Affected by Your Political Opinions

#21

"Such people will also be barred from serving in certain high-status and influential positions, like government official, reporter, CEO, statistician, and similar." For all practical purposes, I don't think this would be so different from what we already have in the West for people like CEOs, government officials, reporters etc. These people seem to be kicked out as soon as they do something politically incorrect. Th…

Not "majority mob" -- more like "vocab minority mob"

Re: In China, Your Credit Score Is Affected by Your Political Opinions

#22

"Such people will also be barred from serving in certain high-status and influential positions, like government official, reporter, CEO, statistician, and similar." For all practical purposes, I don't think this would be so different from what we already have in the West for people like CEOs, government officials, reporters etc. These people seem to be kicked out as soon as they do something politically incorrect. Th…

But "These people seem to be kicked out as soon as they do something politically incorrect." in the West depends on the country/state/company/current political side of the gov etc what is considered 'politically (in)correct' and they would generally actually have to DO it, not only say something. I hear CEO's/reporters/etc 'in the west' making weird too right or too left-ish remarks and no-one cares. In China that seems all quite clear ; they would be out while here it really very much depends what they say/do, where they are and in what capacity.

Re: In China, Your Credit Score Is Affected by Your Political Opinions

#23

"Such people will also be barred from serving in certain high-status and influential positions, like government official, reporter, CEO, statistician, and similar." For all practical purposes, I don't think this would be so different from what we already have in the West for people like CEOs, government officials, reporters etc. These people seem to be kicked out as soon as they do something politically incorrect. Th…

These poor, starving CEOs constantly kick people out of jobs for simply annoying them — it's called "firing". Tyranny of the corporate mob bosses.

Re: In China, Your Credit Score Is Affected by Your Political Opinions

#24

"Such people will also be barred from serving in certain high-status and influential positions, like government official, reporter, CEO, statistician, and similar." For all practical purposes, I don't think this would be so different from what we already have in the West for people like CEOs, government officials, reporters etc. These people seem to be kicked out as soon as they do something politically incorrect. Th…

[deleted]

Re: In China, Your Credit Score Is Affected by Your Political Opinions

#25

"Such people will also be barred from serving in certain high-status and influential positions, like government official, reporter, CEO, statistician, and similar." For all practical purposes, I don't think this would be so different from what we already have in the West for people like CEOs, government officials, reporters etc. These people seem to be kicked out as soon as they do something politically incorrect. Th…

The CEO of the world's biggest company by market cap. was revealed gay by accident on TV and nothing happened.

Re: In China, Your Credit Score Is Affected by Your Political Opinions

#26
post #14

This seems to be Alibaba coming up with a credit scoring system for people who don't have banking relationships. Here's more info.[1] The People's Bank of China already has a more traditional credit rating system. But most people in China don't have a credit rating in any form.[2] This seems to be a scheme to get the rest of the population plugged into the system. There's a Government policy document on this "social…

Eww ewww ewww! I never realized it was this bad. You have a funny idea of "worked". This seems like pure evil oppression. Long live freedom of speech. That being said we have a similar thing in the west, like clearance that you need for some government jobs(checks your connections to enemy states, drug use, general untrustworthy behavior). Fortunately, such government jobs isn't too big part of the economy. Ideally we'll keep it that way.

Re: In China, Your Credit Score Is Affected by Your Political Opinions

#27

"Such people will also be barred from serving in certain high-status and influential positions, like government official, reporter, CEO, statistician, and similar." For all practical purposes, I don't think this would be so different from what we already have in the West for people like CEOs, government officials, reporters etc. These people seem to be kicked out as soon as they do something politically incorrect. Th…

There is a huge difference between social pressure to quit for believing some humans are worth less than others, and the Government forcing you to quit because you made a minor comment on the stock exchange crash.

Do you think that it would somehow be better if the beliefs of people with power were not questioned?

Re: In China, Your Credit Score Is Affected by Your Political Opinions

#28
post #13

I am curious to see how that is calculated and what percentage it is of the 950 score. An absurd decision if you ask me.

This is a perfectly rational decision, you just need to look at it from the value system making the decision. The Party's #1 goal is to remain in power. Pretty much everything they do is with that in mind. They also seem to assume that revolution is always knocking at the door. [1] Communism has had a long history of ideological coercion (it's pretty much a founding principle), so this sort of thing should come as no…

China always expecting revolution makes sense. It was founded by revolution.

Re: In China, Your Credit Score Is Affected by Your Political Opinions

#30

In France there's no such thing as the credit score. Of course banks probably (certainly) have something to rate their customers, but it's not public. And from what I can read about the credit score, I don't think we're missing much.

So, how do banks decide how much to loan you, if you want a loan, or at what interest rate?

My history of being responsible with debt enables me to borrow large amounts of money while putting a small percentage down, and paying a small percentage interest (3.375%) on the principal. Banks can compete to offer better rates or terms on a loan like that (home mortgage, USA).

Some notion of a credit score, or a person's general creditworthiness is necessary for there to be competition in the loan market. Otherwise how would it work - banks are equally willing to loan to all people, despite their income, savings, and history of paying back loans reliably?

It can be abused but it generally seems to promote an efficient marketplace for loans.

Post reply on HN