Live data from Hacker News

Do Not Disclose Your Salary to Recruiters

jacquesmattheij.com

21–30 of 77 posts

Re: Do Not Disclose Your Salary to Recruiters

#21
post #5

Ignoring the recruiter problem for a second, should I ever feel obligated to disclose salary information? I have had potential employers straight up ask me what my current salary is, should I just tell them I'm not going to answer that question?

In general, it's in your best interest not to disclose it.

Re: Do Not Disclose Your Salary to Recruiters

#22
post #6
post #5

Ignoring the recruiter problem for a second, should I ever feel obligated to disclose salary information? I have had potential employers straight up ask me what my current salary is, should I just tell them I'm not going to answer that question?

Just tell them it's confidential.

[deleted]

Re: Do Not Disclose Your Salary to Recruiters

#23
post #4

Recruiters are often paid x% of one year's base salary. In this case, your interests are aligned with the interest of the recruiter. In my experience, recruiters are 'box checkers'. They have little to no knowledge of your skill set or the skills required for the job outside of buzz words that can be printed on a resume. The reason recruiters ask for your salary is not to engage in price fixing but to ensure that the…

Actually not. 50-50 chances of getting 10% of $70,000 is 50% chance of getting $7,000

20-80 chances of $80,000 is 20% chance of getting $8,000

it's actually in the recruiter's interest to force you into accepting a low offer right away rather than possibly getting another offer by your current employer or another offer through an acquaintance

Re: Do Not Disclose Your Salary to Recruiters

#24
Eh, obviously. Now imagine my surprise when I came to Hong Kong and started to see candidates' current salary on their CVs without even being asked for it.

Not to mention that many companies do 'require' it. Next time I should claim it's confidential. Just to see how they react to a novel situation.

Re: Do Not Disclose Your Salary to Recruiters

#26
post #12
post #5

Ignoring the recruiter problem for a second, should I ever feel obligated to disclose salary information? I have had potential employers straight up ask me what my current salary is, should I just tell them I'm not going to answer that question?

You're generally not even allowed to discuss your salary with your colleagues after (if) you're hired by one of those potential employers. If it's confidential after that, it should be confidential before, too.

Only if you sign those rights away.

Re: Do Not Disclose Your Salary to Recruiters

#28
post #4

Recruiters are often paid x% of one year's base salary. In this case, your interests are aligned with the interest of the recruiter. In my experience, recruiters are 'box checkers'. They have little to no knowledge of your skill set or the skills required for the job outside of buzz words that can be printed on a resume. The reason recruiters ask for your salary is not to engage in price fixing but to ensure that the…

Recruiter's priority is to get you to sign a contract so he can take his cut.

This may not align with your best interests as he can make you a lower offer than you aim for, if you reveal your past salary information.

Re: Do Not Disclose Your Salary to Recruiters

#29
post #4

Recruiters are often paid x% of one year's base salary. In this case, your interests are aligned with the interest of the recruiter. In my experience, recruiters are 'box checkers'. They have little to no knowledge of your skill set or the skills required for the job outside of buzz words that can be printed on a resume. The reason recruiters ask for your salary is not to engage in price fixing but to ensure that the…

Independent recruiters. Not FTEs. This is a huge and crucial distinction.

Re: Do Not Disclose Your Salary to Recruiters

#30
post #12
post #5

Ignoring the recruiter problem for a second, should I ever feel obligated to disclose salary information? I have had potential employers straight up ask me what my current salary is, should I just tell them I'm not going to answer that question?

You're generally not even allowed to discuss your salary with your colleagues after (if) you're hired by one of those potential employers. If it's confidential after that, it should be confidential before, too.

In the US, if your employer tells you that you are not allowed to discuss your salary with your colleagues, they are breaking federal law.
Post reply on HN