Live data from Hacker News

US – Iran negotiations end with no deal reached

nytimes.com

191–192 of 192 posts

Re: US – Iran negotiations end with no deal reached

#191
post #133

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> It's true not every single IRGC member or leader can be bombed out of existence. But many can. In the last half century, we tried that in Vietnam, Iraq, Afghanistan, and now Iran. When is it going to start working? The problem is that blowing stuff up creates enemies, not friends, so each time you kill one senior leader you create incentives for the other people those bombs killed to decide you’re worse than the ta…

In 2024, a survey by GAMAAN estimated that "A significant majority of Iranians (around 70%) oppose the continuation of the Islamic Republic." Then the government of Iran murdered thousands to crush protests and retain power. Why would the people of Iran still be upset at the death of senior government leaders? (Apart from the minority who already supported the regime, continued to support them even as they killed pro…

Yes, I’m aware. I have no love for the Iranian regime and would cheer their collapse if it lead to something better. However, bombing civilians will not make friends in general and in this case doing so on behalf of Israel is a gift to the IRGC because it supports decades of regime propaganda. Anyone who was inclined to say America cared for the Iranian people in February now has a mountain of bodies and rubble to make them reconsider.
Post reply on HN