Live data from Hacker News

GitHub is once again down

githubstatus.com

191–200 of 214 posts

Re: GitHub is once again down

#191
post #42

Took a full 8 years for a Microsoft acquisition to go to shit, which is probably a record. Kudos to the Github team for holding out this long.

I’m still baffled that Minecraft is doing so well, despite the whole Bedrock thing. At this point I think Microsoft just forgot that they bought Mojang.

They've made it borderline impossible to log in, especially for children.

I just use an offline server, so I wouldn't notice if they had GitHub levels of availability.

Re: GitHub is once again down

#192

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I’m still baffled that Minecraft is doing so well, despite the whole Bedrock thing. At this point I think Microsoft just forgot that they bought Mojang.

They don’t enforce or even default to 2fa to change the account email. In addition, they have no process to get a human to reverse account takeovers. Just a web form that tells you to call a number that redirects you back to a web form

On the other hand, they aggressively log out legitimate users, and require the master Microsoft account password to log back in (because your kids need access to your one drive settings, etc).

Re: GitHub is once again down

#193
post #3

Every day more Microsofty...they should rename to "Your Repository Needs To Restart To Apply Updates"

"It looks like you're trying to develop some software. Would you like help? - Get help with developing the software - Just develop the software without help [ ] Don't show me this tip again"

If only their UI were that good!

Re: GitHub is once again down

#195
post #161

Why don't companies with chronic outages mimic their stack from top to bottom (i.e. starting with a new domain), then before making a change, make the change on the duplicate stack and blast it with mock requests. Might catch 90% of problems before they make it into the real stack? E.g. every step of GitHub's migration to Azure could be mimicked on the duplicate stack before it's implemented on the primary stack. Is…

Downvotes are probably because that is what companies without chronic outages do.

If you'd ever worked on a codebase as terrible as I imagine GH's internals are and looked at the git history, you'd find two things:

1) fixing it would require rolling back 100's-1000's of engineer-years of idiocy that make things like testing or refactoring untenable

2) many prior engineers got part of the way through such improvements before leaving or being kicked out. Their efforts mostly just made it worse, because now you never know what sort of terribleness to expect when you open an unfamiliar file.

Re: GitHub is once again down

#196
post #3

Every day more Microsofty...they should rename to "Your Repository Needs To Restart To Apply Updates"

"It looks like you're trying to develop some software. Would you like help? - Get help with developing the software - Just develop the software without help [ ] Don't show me this tip again"

The second and only other option not being "Maybe later"? Let me into the dream you're living in :)

Re: GitHub is once again down

#197
post #14

Earlier quoted context omitted.

9% ? /s (though To be honest I genuinely wouldn't be surprised if things go down so bad too at this point either)

Unironically, I think 9% uptime would be "one-tenth of a nine".

Reliability where N is the number of nines:

1 - 10 ^ -N (multiply by 100 for percent)

So 9% is 0.09 for the calc

1 - 10 ^ -N = 0.09

So

10 ^ -N = 0.91

So

N = -log10 0.91

So 0.09 (9%) reliability is 0.0409586077 of a nine.

And running it thru... a tenth of a nine is 0.2056717653 or about 20.57% reliability

Re: GitHub is once again down

#198
post #71

It's starting to really look like the AI effect. It might be coincidence but I've noticed a lot more downtime and bad software lately. The last Nvidia drivers gave me a blue screen (last week or so), and speaking about Windows, I froze updates last year because it was clear they were introducing a bunch of issues with every update (not to mention unwanted features). I like AI but actually not for coding because code…

The nvidia thing makes sense. If you get AI to write code for a platform you no longer really have an incentive to care that much about (windows) for a purpose you increasingly don't care about (actually drawing things to a screen), you're probably not going to test it as thoroughly as you used to

Re: GitHub is once again down

#199
post #42

Took a full 8 years for a Microsoft acquisition to go to shit, which is probably a record. Kudos to the Github team for holding out this long.

I’m still baffled that Minecraft is doing so well, despite the whole Bedrock thing. At this point I think Microsoft just forgot that they bought Mojang.

I think they largely let mojang do its own thing, occasionally forcing them to make some dumb change that usually stays exclusive to their "bedrock edition". The mojang people capitulate since the original version and the one they actually develop for is largely untouched by microsofts decision making since the backlash for dumb decisions would lose infinitely more money than if they just let it continue to be a cash cow
Post reply on HN