Live data from Hacker News

Beekeepers halt honey awards over fraud in global supply chain

theguardian.com

191–200 of 241 posts

Re: Beekeepers halt honey awards over fraud in global supply chain

#191

Here's a very straightforward guide to buying honey. If you see honey at a supermarket, no you don't, that's sugar syrup. If you see honey online, no you don't, that's sugar syrup. If you find an old dude with a small stand and a bunch of (most likely unlabelled) jars who only accepts cash, that's where you get real honey.

The supermarkets around here sell local honey. Same product as at the farmers' market, but more convenient.

Re: Beekeepers halt honey awards over fraud in global supply chain

#192

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Note this also happens with olive oil https://www.europol.europa.eu/media-press/newsroom/news/11-o... https://www.oliveoiltimes.com/business/europe/top-italian-po...

To a first approximation it's accurate to assume any imported olive oil on a grocery store shelf in the US is fraudulent. The only kind I buy now is 100% grown in California and certified by the California Olive Oil Council. And it is very expensive.

Absolutely. Avoid any blends outside the U.S.

Re: Beekeepers halt honey awards over fraud in global supply chain

#193

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The "down to earth local grower" is a form of marketing that appeals to you. It's not a guarantee of quality, and probably more variable. Many vendors at farmer's markets just buy and relabel stuff, because producing goods efficiently enough to make a profit is actually hard.

I'm pretty sure my own father is not masquerading as a beekeeper to market his honey to me. You're right though that it alone doesn't pay the bills, but it does definitely help.

same experience. Bee keeping is a fairly accessible hobby, actually, and the honey is very good, although you wind up with far too much of it

I do prefer my dad's to buying "local" stuff at the supermarket but I'm not sure I believe all the uncited claims in this thread about everything on the shelf there being fake

Re: Beekeepers halt honey awards over fraud in global supply chain

#194
post #74

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Do you have evidence of that? Things do change, and sometimes for the worse. PE squeezing hospitals, nursing homes, and rent is a new thing. Look at rents - the inflation of them is not something that happened in the past.

The original claim that Michelangelo11 made is that society in the past was higher trust. That's the claim that needs evidence. The person who disagrees with the initial claim is not the one who needs to initially provide evidence.

I generally agree, but someone making another claim in response also needs evidence. If the response was, 'what is the evidence?', that would be different.

Re: Beekeepers halt honey awards over fraud in global supply chain

#195
post #175
post #79

Earlier quoted context omitted.

But all the honey labels say the only ingredient is honey. We've always been able to assume that with things like jams, or any other food, when manufacturers adulterate it with things like corn syrup, or even mild poisons, they proudly say so on the label. To not do so is fraud. How can people just claim that an entire industry is committing fraud??? Even this article doesn't mention anything about proof, just suspic…

Wait til you hear about maple syrup... That aside, yeah, this is a real problem with honey (and maple syrup) in the US. Food manufacturers will go to insane lengths to get around any laws that protect product purity and honest labeling because the profits are far greater than the fine for breaking the rules. As we all know, if the punishment is a fine, it's only illegal for companies that cannot afford to pay...like…

I have never heard of maple syrup fraud in the US nor can I find any articles on it.

Unless one is talking about imitation maple syrups, but those are labeled properly.

Re: Beekeepers halt honey awards over fraud in global supply chain

#196
post #179

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> However, pick up a high value product and it’s likely to be some effectively identical fake while still being sold by the company it says on the box. What is this supposed to mean? Every high value product I purchase is definitely unique to the company that makes it. My laptop, GPU, car, and phone are definitely not some rebranded items.

It’s hard to sell a counterfeit car or GPU without someone noticing a difference. Clothes, chargers, cables, etc are counterfeit because it isn’t nearly as obvious. Name brand foods often come with significant markups and would be fairly easy to counterfeit premium bottled water etc. Except as the article mentions food substitutes generally happen earlier in the supply chain not at the grocery store.

The reverse also happens, knock-offs being as high quality as the name-brand because it's cheaper on the production side to use existing factories/machinery.

Re: Beekeepers halt honey awards over fraud in global supply chain

#197
post #28

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Honey supply chains are opaque and global, plus the incentives to cheat are clearly there and it's hard to definitively prove a batch was not adulterated. I'd say it's fair to be suspicious. That said, this old article seems to think its not as common a problem as you would expect: https://www.npr.org/sections/thesalt/2011/11/25/142659547/re...

> "Consumers don't tend to like crystallized honey," says Jill Clark, vice president for sales and marketing at Dutch Gold. "It's very funny. In Canada, there's a lot of creamed honey sold, and people are very accustomed to honey crystallizing. Same in Europe. But the U.S. consumer is very used to a liquid product, and as soon as they see those first granules of crystallization, we get the phone calls: 'Something's w…

I’m so confused by people not liking crystallized honey. It’s so much more convenient to use, it doesn’t drip anywhere it’s practically like thick peanut butter consistency. Great for yogurt, toast or tea. Why would anyone want it to be runny?

Re: Beekeepers halt honey awards over fraud in global supply chain

#198

Earlier quoted context omitted.

An uncited statement in a review article! If I'm rich in time and money enough to routinely take the time to wander down to my friendly beekeeper and buy their small-batch artisanal honey, for so many reasons I will live longer than someone who isn't. Someone should randomize people to honey vs fake-honey-sugar-mix and settle the issue.

You mean, something like this? > Forty-eight articles published in 42 different journals were analyzed, with a total of 3655 subjects with 29.51 ± 21.51 years of age, of whom 1990 consumed or were treated with honey. Of the 3655 subjects, at least 1803 were women (two studies did not specify). The studies included different population groups (healthy subjects, overweight or obese subjects, diabetic subjects, subjects…

There is no assertion that those individuals were randomized, simply "treated".

Re: Beekeepers halt honey awards over fraud in global supply chain

#199

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This isn’t true at all in the United States at least. Sugar syrup or even honey adulterated with sugar syrup behaves differently. I’ve had some cheap generic brand bottles that flowed too easily, dissolved too quickly, and never crystallized. Probably sugar syrup. But I haven’t seen this once since over a decade ago in my college days when I shopped at some questionable neighborhood supermarkets. Everything I’ve boug…

My brother in law owns bees and gifts us honey. One is strong, thick, crystallised easily. One is thin and flows very easily, very see through. These things aren’t good indicators of adulteration at all

Is it like a bloom filter? Crystallizes easily means real? Doesn’t crystallize easily means unknown?

Re: Beekeepers halt honey awards over fraud in global supply chain

#200

Here's a very straightforward guide to buying honey. If you see honey at a supermarket, no you don't, that's sugar syrup. If you see honey online, no you don't, that's sugar syrup. If you find an old dude with a small stand and a bunch of (most likely unlabelled) jars who only accepts cash, that's where you get real honey.

This isn’t true at all in the United States at least. Sugar syrup or even honey adulterated with sugar syrup behaves differently. I’ve had some cheap generic brand bottles that flowed too easily, dissolved too quickly, and never crystallized. Probably sugar syrup. But I haven’t seen this once since over a decade ago in my college days when I shopped at some questionable neighborhood supermarkets. Everything I’ve boug…

[dead]
Post reply on HN