Live data from Hacker News

Bitwarden SDK relicensed from proprietary to GPLv3

github.com

191–200 of 381 posts

Re: Bitwarden SDK relicensed from proprietary to GPLv3

#191
post #50

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Firefox password sync just works. It's one of those things I never think about. Watching friends and family struggle with bespoke, poorly integrated password managers makes me cringe and is one of the big reasons I enjoy the seamless experience of the built-in Firefox password manager.

Can Firefox password manager work in other apps on Android?

yes and it's perfect. firefox (with ublock) are really the best experience on android.

Re: Bitwarden SDK relicensed from proprietary to GPLv3

#194

Thank you to Bitwarden for relicensing a thing to Free/Open License! Unfortunately, I no longer recommend Bitwarden for normal people because the built-in password manager in Firefox is too good. But for anyone with more advance needs (or who doesn't trust a password manager built into a web browser, I always recommend Bitwarden because KeepassXC + syncing is way too difficult for normal people.

> because the built-in password manager in Firefox is too good

If only they could add labels to the name/password combination. I have several accounts stored for a website, with generated gibberish logins that I cannot change and sometimes it takes me multiple tries to get to the correct account.

Also, sometimes a site has two password fields - two secret codes - and for this usecase the password manager doesn't work very well either and remembers only one field.

Other than that, I love how it just works, you add a password on one device and have it seamlessly available on the other with a very little setup. It's a nice experience.

Re: Bitwarden SDK relicensed from proprietary to GPLv3

#196
post #194

Thank you to Bitwarden for relicensing a thing to Free/Open License! Unfortunately, I no longer recommend Bitwarden for normal people because the built-in password manager in Firefox is too good. But for anyone with more advance needs (or who doesn't trust a password manager built into a web browser, I always recommend Bitwarden because KeepassXC + syncing is way too difficult for normal people.

> because the built-in password manager in Firefox is too good If only they could add labels to the name/password combination. I have several accounts stored for a website, with generated gibberish logins that I cannot change and sometimes it takes me multiple tries to get to the correct account. Also, sometimes a site has two password fields - two secret codes - and for this usecase the password manager doesn't work…

> have several accounts stored for a website

Another usecase for named logins are those multiple routers that you administer for your friends and family that all have http://192.168.1.1

Re: Bitwarden SDK relicensed from proprietary to GPLv3

#198
post #174

Thank you Bitwarden for listening. This kind of stuff gives me hope for the business model of Open Source.

[flagged]

How would you explain that[1]?

1. https://github.com/bitwarden/sdk/issues/898#issuecomment-222...

Re: Bitwarden SDK relicensed from proprietary to GPLv3

#199
post #174

Thank you Bitwarden for listening. This kind of stuff gives me hope for the business model of Open Source.

[flagged]

They still handled the situation in a serious and responsible manner, clearly communicating what had happened and why. They then followed up later when the problem was fixed. To me it seems clear that they understood the seriousness of the situation, and why people were initially pissed.

I think this is the correct way of handling a rugpull scare, bug or not.

Re: Bitwarden SDK relicensed from proprietary to GPLv3

#200

Thank you to Bitwarden for relicensing a thing to Free/Open License! Unfortunately, I no longer recommend Bitwarden for normal people because the built-in password manager in Firefox is too good. But for anyone with more advance needs (or who doesn't trust a password manager built into a web browser, I always recommend Bitwarden because KeepassXC + syncing is way too difficult for normal people.

> Unfortunately, I no longer recommend Bitwarden for normal people because the built-in password manager in Firefox is too good.

I don't doubt the quality of Firefox's password manager, or your honesty.

But normal people just don't use Firefox.

Post reply on HN