Live data from Hacker News

Whither philosophy?

aeon.co

191–192 of 192 posts

Re: Whither philosophy?

#191

Earlier quoted context omitted.

>The elementary tenet of effective altruism - that privileged Westerners could be doing considerably more good in the world than most of us do Unironically privileged Westerners could be doing considerably more good in the world by protecting their freedoms in their own lives, egoism would be much more effective there.

Hogwash. Egoism isn't what's in short supply. EMPATHY is what's in short supply.

It's the case when good intentions pave the road to hell. Intentions are fine, but what's really in short supply are good outcomes.

Re: Whither philosophy?

#192

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What's an example of a philosophical notion that did pay off?

Human rights. It's a metaphysical spook with no grounding in the natural world, but the idea catching on is a net positive.

> Human rights. It's a metaphysical spook with no grounding in the natural world

human rights has no grounding anywhere but the natural world

And its grounding is quite solid. It's been talked about for many millennia. And for example, saying that slaves or serfs have no rights is itself an acknowledgement of human rights, an indication that it makes sense to consider that humans might be worthy of rights. There isn't really any definition of the word "rights" except that it starts with human rights.

Post reply on HN