Live data from Hacker News

Boston mayor announces residential conversion program for office buildings

bostonplans.org

191–200 of 413 posts

Re: Boston mayor announces residential conversion program for office buildings

#191

There was a cool OddLots episode recently where they talked to a guy who does Office to Residential work and some of the complexity. One thing he talked about, which I didn't know anyone did, was to actually cut through the ceiling/floorplate of buildings to basically "donut" them. This is necessary because many office floorplans are huge with modern HVAC and when converted into residential you end up with either und…

Undesirable apartments sound like code for low income/affordable housing to me...

Add a few light pipes out to the outside walls and you can even get a bit of outside light inside!

Re: Boston mayor announces residential conversion program for office buildings

#192

I'm confused. Why is this program necessary? If building owners are sitting on vacant space because the demand for office space has dropped, while the demand for housing continues to rise, aren't they already incentivized to convert to residential space just based on the market conditions? Not sure why the city has to subsidize the property owners.

Most office buildings are not architecturally feasible to convert to residential. In fact, because of zoning laws, many/most can't even be converted. Would you live in an apartment 15 feet wide and 50 feet deep? No. That's why most office buildings dont work You have to redo all the mechanical, plumbing, electric, and then entirely refinish the building. Its literally cheaper to build new than deal with the nightmare…

> Would you live in an apartment 15 feet wide and 50 feet deep?

In a nice part of Boston? Under 500K? Over 1K sqft? With some nice building community amenities? Hell. Yes.

Re: Boston mayor announces residential conversion program for office buildings

#193

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yes. Left wing politicians need to remember a rising tide lifts all boats. We need to stop treating things like zero sum games and that we need to take things away or redistribute finite goods. Subsidizing things like education, housing, and healthcare.. without corresponding encouraging increases in SUPPLY.. just gives more dollars to the demand side to chase the same stuff. Yes, typically the market responds, but i…

Yeah, it's a good thing we have a famously right-wing bastion like Boston to lead the way with good old fashioned conservative policies like more housing and less commercial real estate. /s

Boston is leading the way, from the left. Try not to be so defensive.

Re: Boston mayor announces residential conversion program for office buildings

#194
post #84
post #75

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Because that would convert space really badly. If you're making 10'x10' rooms out of a 100'x100' space, it's 74% dead space. If a floor is more than 10,000 sq feet, maybe 40,000 sq feet, it goes up to to 90%. I mean, numbers are made up, but the point holds.

I’d be interested to see people get really creative with it. Throw a gym in on one floor. Cinema room on another. Storage units in a few more. Probably difficult to structurally support a pool on a floor not already designed for one but sure, let’s throw one in there too. A kids playroom is maybe a little depressing with no natural light but it could work. Hell: keep the middle commercial space and put a grocery stor…

Another use for interior rooms could be meeting/ conference rooms/ teleconference/ coworking spaces. Some premium apartment landlords currently have these in their clubhouses, usually reservable by the hour, residents usually get so many free credits a month.

Is this a thing, in planned conversions? If the pricing varied by day and time, or was dynamic, it could work very well. With secure lockers adjacent. (Would that require mixed-use zoning?)

A teleconference room (/remote classroom) by day could be time-multiplexed into a cinema room off-peak (with some compromise in seating plans), leasing company just needs to handle cleaning deposits and video surveillance at start and end to check users keep it clean.

Re: Boston mayor announces residential conversion program for office buildings

#195

There was a cool OddLots episode recently where they talked to a guy who does Office to Residential work and some of the complexity. One thing he talked about, which I didn't know anyone did, was to actually cut through the ceiling/floorplate of buildings to basically "donut" them. This is necessary because many office floorplans are huge with modern HVAC and when converted into residential you end up with either und…

Undesirable apartments sound like code for low income/affordable housing to me... Add a few light pipes out to the outside walls and you can even get a bit of outside light inside!

Yes my point is that cutting the donut hole in is necessary to make them legal & desirable.

Re: Boston mayor announces residential conversion program for office buildings

#196
post #183

There was a cool OddLots episode recently where they talked to a guy who does Office to Residential work and some of the complexity. One thing he talked about, which I didn't know anyone did, was to actually cut through the ceiling/floorplate of buildings to basically "donut" them. This is necessary because many office floorplans are huge with modern HVAC and when converted into residential you end up with either und…

The main advantage of living in a converted factory (there are a lot of these in the rust belt) is that you end up with an absolutely enormous space made out of cool materials. I was finding it hard to imagine that there are inner-city office buildings (high rises) that have floors so large that they couldn't be cut into, say 1/4'ths, with four residences on each floor, and each unit having 50% windows along its peri…

I doubt that people in the market for a downtown apartment share the same priorities for selecting a home as people who would buy a McMansion. I also don’t think you can equate 10,000 sq ft over multiple floors with the same area on a single floor. I don’t know how that space would be designed in any practical manner that wouldn’t turn it into a labyrinth. I guess if someone wants a ballroom or a basketball court in their apartment?

Re: Boston mayor announces residential conversion program for office buildings

#197
post #115
post #71

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's legal, in most cases, to omit an egress window in bedrooms in high-rise buildings—but only because the building includes fire-safety features (for example, sprinklers, fire alarm systems, and egress stairways) https://www.greenbuildingadvisor.com/article/bedrooms-withou...

Two different rules Bedrooms have egress requirements Apartments have window requirements (eg natural light)

Nah a whole bunch of jurisdictions made it so that with appropriate firewalls and other features there need be zero egress aside from the singular entrance/exit door.

Windows can be unopenable etc.,

It's literally because of hi rises and the issues with it being pointless to jump from 10+ stories (you'll also suffer less, as the smoke will make you pass out long before you're actually being burned).

Re: Boston mayor announces residential conversion program for office buildings

#198
post #102

Earlier quoted context omitted.

There are so many cities (I'd say it's the majority in the world), with mixed use zoning which work wonderfully. Lower floors are offices or businesses and upper floors are apartments. Why is this so difficult?

I swear, it's impossible to please people. People are complaining that mixed use zoning on Taraval street in SF is wasting space because the street-level floors are wasted and they should be converted into apartments (many business have shuttered and ground floors remain empty in some mixed use buildings).

People are complaining about mixed use zoning? Geez, there's already a fair amount of mixed use along Taraval anyways. A real common narrative was that the folks in the Parkside don't want to turn their neighborhood into Manhattan (lol). The other one was the staunchly anti-transit narrative pushed by the guy that owns Great Wall Hardware on 28th, Albert Chow. That guy publicly fought tooth and nail against putting boarding islands up along Taraval (the Examiner got some choice quotes).

Anyways, it's been a hot moment since I've paid attention, but years ago the guy that owned the hardware store on 44th Ave tried to convert into a mixed use building. I don't remember a lot of objection, but then the real estate market tanked and he went out of business. The apartments got built at least…

Re: Boston mayor announces residential conversion program for office buildings

#199

Downtown LA had a bunch of (textile?) factories and warehouses back in the day that got repurposed as residential lofts. They're quirky and somewhat charming big buildings to live in, but you can tell they weren't really meant for humans to live in to begin with. I'm thinking of all of the SB lofts. For example if you're on the first few floors and you don't have an outside-facing window, your only source of light mi…

There's also no green space nearby and skid row is only a few blocks away.

Re: Boston mayor announces residential conversion program for office buildings

#200
post #71

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Depending on local laws.. windowless apartments are illegal. windowless bedrooms are illegal. etc.

It's legal, in most cases, to omit an egress window in bedrooms in high-rise buildings—but only because the building includes fire-safety features (for example, sprinklers, fire alarm systems, and egress stairways) https://www.greenbuildingadvisor.com/article/bedrooms-withou...

No it is not legal in NYC.

There's been a whole discussion of the code though as modern mid/high rises have - concrete, "fireproof" (in terms of adjacent unit to unit) construction - sprinkler systems - internal hallway leading to 2 stairways

All of which are lacking in wood frame homes which make up a higher amount of home fire deaths. So there has been an argument that you could build housing much cheaper if you could rely on the concrete & sprinklers, and could lighten the rules around multiple stairs / windows / etc.

An interesting debate, with of course, tradeoffs.

Post reply on HN