Live data from Hacker News

Royal Navy says quantum navigation test a success

thequantuminsider.com

191–200 of 279 posts

Re: Royal Navy says quantum navigation test a success

#191
post #38
post #30

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You're probably surprised that you don't see it, because it's top secret. Here's an example of something you don't hear about: AI Assisted Battlefield Tactics. While I've never heard of it (certainly not in the press), I simply assume that they're doing research on it. I base this assumption on the AlphaStar AI from DeepMind that would completely pawn Grand Masters in the game of StarCraft 2. While AlphaStar is obvio…

AlphaStar hardly pawned GMs in any meaningful way. It mainly won on mechanics, even when Deepmind tried to nerf its mechanics. Probably the most important thing is that the “200 APM limit” is way higher than any human can do, because it made use of each one of its actions. Humans can reach 400+ APM by spamming, but their EPM will stay much lower than 200. The result is that it had god-tier micro that changed the game…

[flagged]

Re: Royal Navy says quantum navigation test a success

#192
post #180

This is the most obvious practical application of my PhD topic. A Bose Einstein Condensate is an extremely sensitive detector of gravity- a nuclear submarine could use it to make an ultra-accurate map of the world based on variations in the gravitational constant g. This would remove one of the primary reasons subs need to surface , in order to GPS lock. It’s a naval chart that would not require surfacing. A French p…

> This would remove one of the primary reasons subs need to surface , in order to GPS lock. Huh? Wouldn't it be enough to send some small thing connected by thin wires or wirelessly to the submarine (lasers, ultrasound, whatever) that could aquire location and communicate it? Given military budgets it could probably even be disposable. Leaving beacons in areas of interest also seems like a good idea. With good encryp…

You don't want to send out beacons like that from your nuclear sub. Your adversaries can detect those, which negates the purpose of having a nuclear sub in the first place.

Additionally if they communicate through radio, you're back to the same problem because it's the thousand feet of water that blocks most radio waves. If they communicate via ultrasound you've just tied your sub to a nearby active sonar source. If they communicate via laser you have to be very close otherwise the power of the laser creates sonar detectable variations in the water near the sub.

Re: Royal Navy says quantum navigation test a success

#193
post #6

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The article links to a better article, https://news.sky.com/story/royal-navys-experimental-ship-car... , which calls the device an accelerometer. I think the article linked here got literally all its information from that other article. Apparently it's a small number of rubidium atoms, cooled to near-absolute zero, under which conditions they can apparently measure gravitational effects and make deductions from that…

》measure gravitational effects and make deductions from that ("measure extremely accurately the influence of gravity on their system Aha! So it might be able to detect other submarines, even if they use some stealth tech.

Not even close.

Re: Royal Navy says quantum navigation test a success

#194
post #68

The Imperial College researcher who builds these things describes his research here: https://www.imperial.ac.uk/centre-for-cold-matter/research/q... The page claims that this device attempts to measure acceleration accurately enough that position can be determined (by integrating over time, twice).

It's off topic however on the people page[0] of the above link, I enjoyed going through to try and spot the photoshopped in ones! [0] https://www.imperial.ac.uk/centre-for-cold-matter/people/

That was fun. That whole left side has a lot of suspicious lighting, doesn't it?!

Re: Royal Navy says quantum navigation test a success

#195
post #180

This is the most obvious practical application of my PhD topic. A Bose Einstein Condensate is an extremely sensitive detector of gravity- a nuclear submarine could use it to make an ultra-accurate map of the world based on variations in the gravitational constant g. This would remove one of the primary reasons subs need to surface , in order to GPS lock. It’s a naval chart that would not require surfacing. A French p…

> This would remove one of the primary reasons subs need to surface , in order to GPS lock. Huh? Wouldn't it be enough to send some small thing connected by thin wires or wirelessly to the submarine (lasers, ultrasound, whatever) that could aquire location and communicate it? Given military budgets it could probably even be disposable. Leaving beacons in areas of interest also seems like a good idea. With good encryp…

[dead]

Re: Royal Navy says quantum navigation test a success

#196
post #24

A friend of mine got PTSD from piloting huge nuclear subs in subsea ravines with a clearing of only one inch on each side of the sub. One wrong move, and the entire crew is gone. He also had to do this in conditions similar to surface storms. Looks like autonomous or automatic systems may be developed for those kinds of manoeuvres now, if it is truly that precise. Seems like a huge leap in navigational systems.

Oh come on... "On 8 January 2005 at 02:43 GMT, San Francisco collided with an undersea mountain about 364 nautical miles (675 km) southeast of Guam while operating at flank (maximum) speed at a depth of 525 feet (160 m)." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/USS_San_Francisco_(SSN-711)

So, here's an anecdote of a sub that miraculously survived a head on collision. What's your point?

From the same article:

“The collision was so serious that the vessel was almost lost; accounts detail a desperate struggle for positive buoyancy to surface after the forward ballast tanks were ruptured.”

I doubt these are problems any submarine crew wants to deal with, even at slow speeds. Besides, one sharp edge at the sides will open her right up like a tin can.

Re: Royal Navy says quantum navigation test a success

#197
post #189

This is the most obvious practical application of my PhD topic. A Bose Einstein Condensate is an extremely sensitive detector of gravity- a nuclear submarine could use it to make an ultra-accurate map of the world based on variations in the gravitational constant g. This would remove one of the primary reasons subs need to surface , in order to GPS lock. It’s a naval chart that would not require surfacing. A French p…

It'd be interesting to see if they're sensitive enough to do the opposite detect the gravity anomaly that is the sub. There's a couple near future submarine warfare books where that's one of the devices used to attempt to find subs.

Would love to see a list of such books.

Re: Royal Navy says quantum navigation test a success

#198
post #143

This is the most obvious practical application of my PhD topic. A Bose Einstein Condensate is an extremely sensitive detector of gravity- a nuclear submarine could use it to make an ultra-accurate map of the world based on variations in the gravitational constant g. This would remove one of the primary reasons subs need to surface , in order to GPS lock. It’s a naval chart that would not require surfacing. A French p…

May I ask: how sensitive? Sensitive enough to, say, detect the movement of something moving at a known frequency on the other side of the planet? Are we on the edge of gravitation based communication channels?

It's apparently extremely sensitive. Check this out:

https://www.jpl.nasa.gov/missions/cold-atom-laboratory-cal

Re: Royal Navy says quantum navigation test a success

#199
post #197
post #189

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It'd be interesting to see if they're sensitive enough to do the opposite detect the gravity anomaly that is the sub. There's a couple near future submarine warfare books where that's one of the devices used to attempt to find subs.

Would love to see a list of such books.

The main one I've read is Joe Buff's Deep Sound Channel series, found it after a recommendation from someone else on HN even so glad to continue the chain. Fell off it a bit in book 4 but that might have been me burning out on them, I ripped through the first 3 and focused too hard on them.

Re: Royal Navy says quantum navigation test a success

#200
post #189

This is the most obvious practical application of my PhD topic. A Bose Einstein Condensate is an extremely sensitive detector of gravity- a nuclear submarine could use it to make an ultra-accurate map of the world based on variations in the gravitational constant g. This would remove one of the primary reasons subs need to surface , in order to GPS lock. It’s a naval chart that would not require surfacing. A French p…

It'd be interesting to see if they're sensitive enough to do the opposite detect the gravity anomaly that is the sub. There's a couple near future submarine warfare books where that's one of the devices used to attempt to find subs.

I suspect that may be what these satellites are doing... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GRACE_and_GRACE-FO#:~:text=As%....
Post reply on HN