Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: What makes you optimistic about the future?

news.ycombinator.com

191–200 of 221 posts

Re: Ask HN: What makes you optimistic about the future?

#191

https://upgrader.gapminder.org/ A quick test to see how up to date you are on some important trends in the world. I was surprisingly out of date with how well things have become.

14/18. Yes, a lot of the world has improved a lot from a very low base. That does not infuse me with optimism, though, particularly for Europe and the US.

Re: Ask HN: What makes you optimistic about the future?

#192
post #69

I'm a PhD student in physics and I am really, really optimistic about how the field will be developing going forward. People are well aware of the glamorous fields of physics: cosmology and particle physics. These are the disciplines that concern the frontiers of the very large and the very small respectively. I don't care so much about those. The frontier that I'm most interested in is the most abstract one: complex…

If you were an optimistic science fiction writer, any ways in which this may change ordinary lives for the better?

Re: Ask HN: What makes you optimistic about the future?

#193
post #35

I can go to historic archives of any time period that left a written record and find someone with a pessimistic take like your. Obviously the details are different, but there are always many bad signs for someone to point out. In the end life isn't perfect, but it generally has gotten better

True, but one could also easily find someone with an optimistic take. Tons of utopian science fiction from the 60s, say. Not so much today. That's why I made this thread.

Re: Ask HN: What makes you optimistic about the future?

#194
post #32

Honestly? I try not to think about the future because doing so brings wave upon wave of existential dread. Things aren't looking good, and it might be a bit of a hedonistic maxim but if thinking about it just makes me feel worse why should I? Let me work away at achieving my "local optimum" since that's all I can realistically do.

That has been my tactic too. Basically, think the XXs were great? Well, you have all the technology to emulate that in your own life - just need to find a few people that would be on board with you. E.g. think that social media is making life miserable? Find your social circle that are technology minimalists, only call each other on the landline (or equivalent) and actually knock on each others' doors instead of texting when they want to talk, and think that taking selfies should not be normalized.

Re: Ask HN: What makes you optimistic about the future?

#195

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Energy is a major direct and indirect input into the price of pretty much everything. The other major factor, of course, being land. While I don't expect many major economies to implement a Land Value Tax in the near term, to balance out these costs more fairly among citizens and corporations, it's worth noting that we are about to see peak population being reached in China [2025] and the EU [2026], which may have…

Land is a very minor component of the price of anything. In much of the country you can buy a square mile for a few million. Labor is the other big component.

> In much of the country you can buy a square mile for a few million.

Yet in other parts of the country people pay that for 1000 square feet.

The fact that people aren't building skyscrapers or gold mines in "much of the country" doesn't mean that there isn't high demand for housing or precious metals.

I would be interested to know, for example, how much energy would cost if there were unlimited free space (with good weather and topography) for installing solar panels within easy transmission distance from all energy consumers.

In that sense, energy prices are dependent on land prices.

Re: Ask HN: What makes you optimistic about the future?

#196
post #47

There's many things to be optimistic about, but the complex nature of society means progress will likely look like a slow crawl towards the right direction, but we'll eventually get there. One place to look at are teenagers. They grew up with the internet and open access to information. If you sit down and speak with any of them, they are more aware of the areas that need improvement and are not afraid to speak out a…

I don't hang out with a lot of teenagers, but what I see of them paints a sorry picture. Rampant mental health issues, many infants I see glued to junk on iPads that would make children's TV of the 90s the height of intellectualism, etc.

Do you really think there are reasons to be optimistic about the new generations? What little of them there will be, given the drops in fertility rates.

Re: Ask HN: What makes you optimistic about the future?

#197
post #51

Earlier quoted context omitted.

sex robots to look like your favorite celebrity On the face of it that sounds like "wahey, sexy fun!", but if you consider it for a second you're actually suggesting a life without a real relationship with another person which is beyond depressing. If that tech becomes mainstream humanity has a major problem.

I see what youre saying, but then again, think of those who are unfortunately disabled, maimed, disfigured, socially inept, etc who have never/may never have a fair shot at a relationship. For them, sex robots/robotic companions could be a fantastic thing given that theyd accept them unconditionally. It could have the ability to fill an emotional and/or physical void for them.

It will make things worse for a lot more people though, just like the likes of 'dating apps' and pornography did. I wouldn't be optimistic about that; the only hope is that we develop a culture to regard it as we now regard smoking, and try to revive normal human contact.

Re: Ask HN: What makes you optimistic about the future?

#198
post #121

For one, there's the fact we seem to be contaminated by pessimism but it's hard to find an intelligent explanation for it. The arguments are so bad that they include absurdities like our civilization being unable to overcome an actively manufactured political division.

The collapse of the Roman Empire lasted for a few hundred years. Imagine living during those times. It is not inconceivable that we are living through that right now.

Re: Ask HN: What makes you optimistic about the future?

#199
China lifted billions of people out of poverty. India has been improving as well in that front. That means billions of people will go to bed without an empty stomach and wake up with much more hope than in the previous decades.

The world order is changing rapidly and moving towards a multi-polar world. That means the US and the west cannot impose their will on countries that doesn't suit their interests. Regime change operations and other tactics used by the US will be much costly in the coming decades because there will be other powers to counter that.

That means millions of people will live peacefully with less violence. Without their life disrupted suddenly because someone thousands of kilometers away decided to change things over in their country.

However, there is looming threat to this prospect, how the US will handle it's internal politics. The more failed it becomes internally the more external power projection will be needed to maintain it's dominance. Most of the troubles happening around the world right now can be traced back to the US efforts to contain China's growth. If you look at holistically, this shouldn't be this way, if the US spent most of the defense budget in public education and health care, it doesn't need to worry about China. It can keep it's dominance while there is a wealthier China existing on the other side.

However, as history has repeatedly shown, the pendulum always swings back. Empires crumples and new powers replaces it.

There is a glorious future awaits for those living in China, India and other rapidly developing countries.

Re: Ask HN: What makes you optimistic about the future?

#200

In the short term, all the fundamentals of the economy are doing well -- unemployment rate, corporate profits, wages are up, et cetera. Sure the stock market is doing poorly. The stock market isn't the economy.

Yet it used to be possible to buy a house and support a family with children on a single income, and now you would struggle to do it on two incomes. That does not sound like a big success for the economy to me.

Perhaps a reason to be optimistic is that this trend will reverse, but it is hard to see a road to that. In the medium term, we are looking at a large population of retirees to be supported by a dwindling working population, that are also faced with servicing a massive debt that the older generation accumulated; at the same time faced by a rising challenger nation. That sounds like it could be dreadful, actually.

Post reply on HN