Live data from Hacker News

Google turned me into a serial killer

hristo-georgiev.com

191–200 of 313 posts

Re: Google turned me into a serial killer

#191
post #91

> It turns out that Google's knowledge graph algorithm somehow falsely associated my photo with the Wikipedia article about the serial killer. Which is also surprisingly strange because my name isn't special or unique at all; there are literally hundreds of other people with my name, and despite of all that, my personal photo ended up being associated with a serial killer. I can't really explain to myself how this ha…

That the explanation is simple doesn't make the result any less obscenely defamatory.

Re: Google turned me into a serial killer

#192
post #42

The info boxes sometimes contain surprising errors. I recently searched for Picasa and was informed that it was invented by Pablo Picasso in 2002! Google 'knows' Picasso died in the 1970s and it 'knows' he released a popular software program in 2002. That's an obvious contradiction requiring the simplest of rules to detect, but the system is just a dumb text extractor. (Interestingly, Google assistant gave the correc…

A few days ago, a person in an IRC channel I'm in was convinced AMD GPUs have CUDA cores, because they put "amd 5500rx cuda cores" into Google, saw the infobox entry that said "How many CUDA cores does a Rx 5700 have? 2,560 CUDA cores" and stubbornly refused to accept Google could be wrong. Amusingly that same infobox then has a table that states "2,560 stream processors" in the "Radeon RX 5700 XT" column. So one hal…

ML is not at fault - it's probably doing what it's trained to do. It's the marketing that makes people expect that if ML blackbox managed to do a couple of parlor tricks like distinguishing a cat from a banana and faking something resembling a human-written text, if you don't look too closely, then it's almost as good as a human brain. It's not. It's pretty much as dumb as a refrigerator (a very complex one, with many many buttons, but still a refrigerator). So you shouldn't expect too much from it, and then there's no reason to give it bad rep.

Re: Google turned me into a serial killer

#193

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's disturbing how often people infer that Google is impervious to the law.

That would req. showing that law was broken. I don't think in this case it was. More like a mistake.

Mistakes can be illegal. Intent only matters for small subset of laws.

Re: Google turned me into a serial killer

#194
If you search my first and last name, the first result is of two 18 year olds who burned a house down because one kid has my first name and the other has my last name. For me it goes:

github burned a house down twitter account I no longer have access to

Thanks google...

Re: Google turned me into a serial killer

#195
post #26

Earlier quoted context omitted.

He'll be lucky if they don't suspend his Google account outright for raising the issue.

This just seems like a bad faith comment. Is there ANY example of a user raising a legitimate concern like this and getting banned for it? This reads like cheap, low-effort bashing.

Google has cheap, low-effort customer support, so I'll allow it.

Re: Google turned me into a serial killer

#197
post #185

You should seriously consider suing for defamation if this isn't fixed within a few days. This is an egregious error, especially if it was done by an automated system (and this could be a systemic issue affecting many others). I think you have a decent chance of getting a five figure+ settlement from this. Talk to a lawyer about your options. EDIT: When I search "Hristo Georgiev" (from US IP) there is no longer an im…

>I think you have a decent chance of getting a five figure+ settlement from this.

Against Google? I am more inclined to think the dude is actually a serial killer than that he has a chance of winning a defamation suit.

Re: Google turned me into a serial killer

#199
post #8
post #2

I'm glad this guy has a sense of humor about this, but I really hope that Google does right by him and that he doesn't get stuck in their Byzantine customer service process.

Actually he should sue them. The damage to his reputation and prospects are real.

I just looked it up and google does have a workflow that allows you to send them a court order.

Let's start there first before issuing a lawsuit. You only sue if you can prove damages for defamation. Which, as tepid as most people are on here about patent trolls, I can't imaging taking on google. It's literally like taking on god at this point.

Re: Google turned me into a serial killer

#200
> The rampant spread of fake news and cancel culture has made literally everyone who's not anonymous vulnerable.

Google screwing up their knowledge graph is neither "fake news" nor "cancel culture". Misusing these terms makes them useless for actual discussion.

Post reply on HN