Live data from Hacker News

Mexican states are moving to ban the sale of junk food to children

washingtonpost.com

191–200 of 302 posts

Re: Mexican states are moving to ban the sale of junk food to children

#191

Can we ban sugary breakfasts too? Captain Crunch, Froot Loops & their ilk should be illegal.

Not if you are in the USA, maybe if you are in Mexico, although in Mexico the typical breakfast for kids is more like coffee with milk and chilaquiles (tortilla with tomato sauce) which might not be that healthy.

Re: Mexican states are moving to ban the sale of junk food to children

#192

17 years ago there was a candy or confection sold in Mexico containing lead. I know this because I briefly contracted to a California state agency charged with reducing lead poisoning among children. Apparently lead, like many metals, imparts a kind of sweet taste, which is why there was, and probably still is, a problem with children eating old flaking paint containing lead. I have not followed this situation since.…

The ancient Romans used lead acetate as an artificial sweetener. It's shocking to consider this practice in the modern era though.

That's interesting. Of all the years of making fun of the apartment lease addendum pages about lead paint, I had always just written it off to "dumb things people do". I had no idea there was any kind of rewarding behavior at all.

Re: Mexican states are moving to ban the sale of junk food to children

#193

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If we just didn't subsidize its production, that would be a start.

It's a tough situation. Much of the idea behind agriculture subsides is to protect against black-swan events.

We could direct the subsidies more toward ethanol or whatever other corn product, and still be able to get to the raw corn in an emergency.

Re: Mexican states are moving to ban the sale of junk food to children

#195
post #172

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The United States has done poorly because we are a country whose population hates each other. It’s a country comprised entirely of people whose ancestors said, “You know what? I hate you so much that I’d rather cross an ocean, face bears, wolves, and the elements than to spend another day with you.” That’s why we won’t wear masks.

I mean - Canada is in the same boat right? Canada might even be worse off since the country was originally french and then that entire population (along with first nations & Metis which are a more significant portion of the population up here) was second-classed when the English won a war that one time. Quebec secessionist is far more serious than any state in the US[1] and western Canada tends to begrudge the arbitr…

I have occasionally observed anti-Polish racism in the US. Perpetrated by generically “white” Americans against anyone with a Polish last name or Polish accent.

Re: Mexican states are moving to ban the sale of junk food to children

#196

It's interesting how quick people are to blame US corporations when it's the US government that subsidizes cheap carbs through the farm subsidy program (and on the flip-size in the US, subsidize the purchase of junk food via food stamps). Also, banning sales to children doesn't solve the real culprit - parents buying the junk food for their own children. At least in America, watch any parent fill up their carts and p…

Why not just cut to the quick and ban children without a license /s

Re: Mexican states are moving to ban the sale of junk food to children

#197

Earlier quoted context omitted.

*refined sugar, not all sugar. sugar in a whole fruit aren't bad, the fibers in the fruit help your body break down and absorb the sugar over a longer period of time. just don't eat refined food.

Any kind of concentrated sugar product is going to be unhealthy regardless of the process that got it there. Fresh squeezed orange juice and honey aren't refined, but they're still much too sweet to be consuming large quantities of.

If your concern is obesity and diabetes I encourage you to look up fruititarians. They consume 3000+ calories a day of fruit and loose dangerous amounts of weight. It's not healthy to consume such low fat and protein but it goes to show you can't gain weight on fruit juice.

Conjecture: it's sugar and polyunsaturated fats at the same time that cause issues.

Re: Mexican states are moving to ban the sale of junk food to children

#198

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Caving to marketing designed to make children nag their parents.

When I was a kid my parents only let me watch PBS. No saturday morning cartoons -> no sugary cereal commercials -> no desire/nagging for sugary cereal. Install adblockers on any computer your kids use. Cancel your cable television subscription. Deny these corporations the opportunity to pump their propaganda into your kids.

Saying 'no' and limiting your child's access to TV, etc., that's parenting, indeed.

But again it's easier to give up and let them watch TV than having to actually deal them.

Re: Mexican states are moving to ban the sale of junk food to children

#199

The title is a little misleading, this is happening in the state of Oaxaca only. I guess that if it works the government is going to try and implement it across the whole country.

Lots of US federal law started as California state law first. According to labeling, there are a few things in life that are known to cause cancer only in California.

Re: Mexican states are moving to ban the sale of junk food to children

#200

Covid shows that governments who fail to encourage nutritious diets will end up with higher healthcare costs.

It’s not just encourage. What we’re finding is that the government has to be authoritarian. China welded people into their homes to keep them from spreading COVID. They literally caged them like animals and threw them into trucks. Now Mexico is denying children potato chips. Think about universal healthcare and alcohol. How much money is spent on alcohol related issues? The best answer is to ban its sale. Same for to…

You are being downvoted (nice username btw haha) but you are onto something. My belief is that for certain things, the government MUST be authoritarian: Public Health, education and safety (police, firefighters, etc). That's why I think a more centralized government like the one in Mexico might find it easier to implement sensible policies and apply them "in an authoritative way" to the whole country without state resistance.

Now, if only the government was not as corrupt as it is in Mexico...

Post reply on HN