Live data from Hacker News

What Companies Mean by Culture Fit

triplebyte.com

191–200 of 233 posts

Re: What Companies Mean by Culture Fit

#191

We joke a lot about that after I was hired as a middle aged coder... during interview Boss: "so do you think you can fit in this culture?" Me: "You mean, do I wear skinny jeans and drink kale smoothies? Probably not, but if you want your work done, does culture fit matter when you have a mile long back log?" Boss: "good point, so... How does your schedule look for next week?" it was all history from there.

Over time, I've realize that this view of work/team dynamics is overly unsophisticated. People are all really unique and viewing them as simply work-accomplishing units misses a ton of the nuance in creating a successful team. On one team I worked in, we hired an older coder with bad knees and a couple of kids at home. Everyone in the team got along with him and generally liked him and he got his work done without to…

Sounds like your idea of "culture fit" means excluding married people or people with families. That's likely to run afoul of US EEOC guidelines.

https://www.eeoc.gov/laws/practices/inquiries_marital_status...

Re: What Companies Mean by Culture Fit

#192

We joke a lot about that after I was hired as a middle aged coder... during interview Boss: "so do you think you can fit in this culture?" Me: "You mean, do I wear skinny jeans and drink kale smoothies? Probably not, but if you want your work done, does culture fit matter when you have a mile long back log?" Boss: "good point, so... How does your schedule look for next week?" it was all history from there.

Over time, I've realize that this view of work/team dynamics is overly unsophisticated. People are all really unique and viewing them as simply work-accomplishing units misses a ton of the nuance in creating a successful team. On one team I worked in, we hired an older coder with bad knees and a couple of kids at home. Everyone in the team got along with him and generally liked him and he got his work done without to…

How pathetically sad your workplace must be. No wonder people bailed.

Re: What Companies Mean by Culture Fit

#193

We joke a lot about that after I was hired as a middle aged coder... during interview Boss: "so do you think you can fit in this culture?" Me: "You mean, do I wear skinny jeans and drink kale smoothies? Probably not, but if you want your work done, does culture fit matter when you have a mile long back log?" Boss: "good point, so... How does your schedule look for next week?" it was all history from there.

Over time, I've realize that this view of work/team dynamics is overly unsophisticated. People are all really unique and viewing them as simply work-accomplishing units misses a ton of the nuance in creating a successful team. On one team I worked in, we hired an older coder with bad knees and a couple of kids at home. Everyone in the team got along with him and generally liked him and he got his work done without to…

We don't even have to debate whether your reasoning makes sense, because we have laws against the hiring practices you advocate.

You're advocating age discrimination. Don't do it.

Re: What Companies Mean by Culture Fit

#194

Earlier quoted context omitted.

My experience about 'culture fit' was that it was a code word for ageism. I've experienced people figuring out my age when looking at my resume, then weirdly warping the questions while accusing me of Googling the answers in response. (Based only on hearing me type. I was scripting a Python script to give the answer.)

I don't know what the situation was, but maybe you should have let them know that you were going to write a python script?

We had agreed ahead of time that the interview was going to be conducted with Python. As a Smalltalker, I thought it would be quite natural in Python to just script the answer to a calculation question. My interviewers turned out to be a couple of "C++ bros." They were very bro-y in their disparagement and tones of voice.

Re: What Companies Mean by Culture Fit

#195

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Even a seasoned expert who literally writes card shuffling software would have a difficult time writing a well-explained solution on a whiteboard in 30 minutes. Most candidates we interview have a combination of CS degrees, statistics degrees or experience, and are prepped ahead of time with some materials about the general type of question we might ask, and around 90% of them are rejected for failing to solve this q…

Even a seasoned expert who literally writes card shuffling software would have a difficult time writing a well-explained solution on a whiteboard in 30 minutes. Sure. We used to give an hour, and HR reduced it to 45 minutes. I'd rather have more time. Also, you can dial up the stringency of this particular question to an expert level where hours could be used. Or, as you admit below, it can be dialed down considerabl…

I think you guys might be talking past each other a bit. A good candidate should be able to O(n log n) time pretty easily, but getting O(n) off the bat would suggest prior knowledge of the problem.

Re: What Companies Mean by Culture Fit

#196

We joke a lot about that after I was hired as a middle aged coder... during interview Boss: "so do you think you can fit in this culture?" Me: "You mean, do I wear skinny jeans and drink kale smoothies? Probably not, but if you want your work done, does culture fit matter when you have a mile long back log?" Boss: "good point, so... How does your schedule look for next week?" it was all history from there.

Over time, I've realize that this view of work/team dynamics is overly unsophisticated. People are all really unique and viewing them as simply work-accomplishing units misses a ton of the nuance in creating a successful team. On one team I worked in, we hired an older coder with bad knees and a couple of kids at home. Everyone in the team got along with him and generally liked him and he got his work done without to…

[deleted]

Re: What Companies Mean by Culture Fit

#197
post #58

Good culture fit is when we ask an employee to do something and they do it. A bad fit is someone who occasionally says no. A toxic employee occasionally says no and explains why they won't.

I've always thought being meek and obedient was part and parcel of working for someone else. But I think being a good culture fit is a bit more than that.

I'm working worth some folks now who want and appreciate severe critical feedback, and it's great.

Re: What Companies Mean by Culture Fit

#198

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yea knowing how to not acciddentally get an O(n^3) bottleneck is table stakes for development. It seems to me that a lot of younger folks want to lower the bar below that. If you're looking for devs to show that they understand the ideas, you'd be better off telling them the problem space ahead of time so that they can prepare for it, and then deeply questioning their knowledge in that space Perhaps combine that with…

Creativity comes from solitude not with a gun to your head.

We're not looking for creativity in our interview. It's more about evidence that you've had plenty of practice designing, implementing, and debugging actual running systems, in greater depth than just gluing libraries together and following online tutorials and guides.

Re: What Companies Mean by Culture Fit

#199

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Creativity comes from solitude not with a gun to your head.

We're not looking for creativity in our interview. It's more about evidence that you've had plenty of practice designing, implementing, and debugging actual running systems, in greater depth than just gluing libraries together and following online tutorials and guides.

Creativity is what you just described.

Re: What Companies Mean by Culture Fit

#200

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Even a seasoned expert who literally writes card shuffling software would have a difficult time writing a well-explained solution on a whiteboard in 30 minutes. Sure. We used to give an hour, and HR reduced it to 45 minutes. I'd rather have more time. Also, you can dial up the stringency of this particular question to an expert level where hours could be used. Or, as you admit below, it can be dialed down considerabl…

> understanding anything isn't required Things are truly understood in solitude not with a gun to your head. Also, what a developer knows this second has less bearing on what they could learn than often thought. No one knows everything.

No one knows everything.

You should at least know the basics and be able to apply them. I'm rather shocked by the number of 3.75, 4.0 students from good schools who can spout 1st principles, then utterly fail at applying them.

Post reply on HN