Live data from Hacker News

Jacob Appelbaum’s response to accusations by the Tor community

twitlonger.com

191–192 of 192 posts

Re: Jacob Appelbaum’s response to accusations by the Tor community

#191

jacobappelbaum.net is a fake: https://twitter.com/ValbonneConsult/status/74046605073149952... https://twitter.com/ValbonneConsult/status/74046629719723212... Also whatever he might have done will now be drowned out by these false accusations. Mob mentality is as bad as whatever he might have done.

aren't you easily persuaded…

Re: Jacob Appelbaum’s response to accusations by the Tor community

#192
post #190

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> May I argue that it is uncomfortably low? You may; but it is certainly high enough to lend credence to those concerned about false accusations.

That doesn't matter. As espadrine says, if the number of false-positives is not similar to the number of false-negatives, you may be concerned by whichever of these numbers you find personally threatening, but you can't claim that to be "the problem". If in a community of cats and mice cat's kill 30% of mice, and mice kill 3% of cats, some cats may personally find that 3% to be uncomfortably high for their taste, but…

> That doesn't matter. As espadrine says, if the number of false-positives is not similar to the number of false-negatives, you may be concerned by whichever of these numbers you find personally threatening, but you can't claim that to be "the problem".

I don't know that anyone is claiming it to be "the problem"; but rather "a problem".

False accusations are, like corruption, something that makes the law look bad; and that makes cooperating with the law look bad. It's a problem not only for those falsely accused but also for those who have true accusations to bring!

> If in a community of cats and mice cat's kill 30% of mice, and mice kill 3% of cats, some cats may personally find that 3% to be uncomfortably high for their taste, but they can't say that this constitutes the worrying part of the violence problem in society.

"Now they have two problems."

Post reply on HN