Live data from Hacker News

Audacity 4.0

github.com

181–190 of 278 posts

Re: Audacity 4.0

#181
post #155

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It should be illegal to announce a UI update and not include at least screenshots, so thanks for sharing.

The URL should probably be its landing page, which does a good job with the overview: https://www.audacityteam.org/audacity-4/

thanks

I think this may be the first time I've wanted to buy merch

https://merch.audacityteam.org/

Re: Audacity 4.0

#182
post #54
post #30

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I just started the appimage - it asks you to login to the "cloud" but also offers a prominent skip button, and then asks if you want a telemetry UUID or not.

So even after the intense backlash Tantacrul saw on the GH threads, they went ahead and stuffed it full of telemetry anyway. Incredible.

> So even after the intense backlash Tantacrul saw on the GH threads, they went ahead and stuffed it full of telemetry anyway. Incredible.

Here's an alternative for those unaware:

https://codeberg.org/tenacityteam/tenacity

Re: Audacity 4.0

#183

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yes, Tantacrul. Pretty weird story, a composer and programmer who absolutely roasted the UIs of well known sheet music dinosaurs Finale and Sibelius in hilarious diss videos on YouTube. Then he conceded a bit reluctantly that Musescore was the better of the lot, but still had plenty of opinions on how it could be better. So the guitar tabs website which had then recently acquired Musescore offered him a job. Not just…

MuseScore and Ultimate Guitar unfortunately both have some dark patterns around subscriptions and data collection. But yeah very weird situation

https://gprotab.net/

This site is a lot like how I remember ultimate guitar, being that you can look up tabs and access them. I hope people keep uploading more tabs because ultimate still has a larger volume

Re: Audacity 4.0

#184
post #4

in the age of 500MB apps (thanks to electron); it is refreshing to see a sub-50MB app again.

On MacOS is went from 189mb->128mb for v3->v4 which is nice

Re: Audacity 4.0

#185
post #154

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Notation is cool and just right, the more I learned the more I appreciated how great contemporary notation is. Yes it's challenging to read sometines but the subject is challenging too, surely you could try to simplify it for certain applications but you'd lose a lot of flexibility. Fighting notation is like fighting piano keyboard which is also extremely convenient thing to play compared to other stuff, even to grid…

The fundamental problem in music notation is that it was designed for an 8 note system and we use a 12 note system. It's.. fine I guess, they got those extra four notes in there and millions of people read music with no problems. But it does create a lot of confusion for novice readers who now think those 8 notes are somehow more important than the other 4 or that the sharps and flats are somehow half notes(they are…

> semitones? a fifth? a fifth of what? it is seven notes or 3/2's there is no 5.

I learned to read sheet music as a kid by my mom taking me to piano lessons. I cannot play the piano but I know where the notes are that correspond to the sheet music. I parlayed that into learning to play woodwinds when I got older. Even that was just enough to have fun. Nothing about it was me being serious about being a musician. So when other students would talk about 5ths and 3rds, I was totally lost. Then someone just said transpose the note up/down 5 notes (or 3 or whatever). They said it confidently, and they were first chair, so I went with it. I've never needed to know it, as I just play the notes as written on the sheet. I've never gigged where I had to play different keys.

But yeah, the fifth nomenclature confused the hell out of me too

Re: Audacity 4.0

#187
post #174

Earlier quoted context omitted.

To sum up: you don’t like the current notation system, terminology and piano keys but also don’t have anything else to add to the discussion other than “I don’t like it”.

It is sort of like english spelling, we all know spelling in english sucks(So pointlessly difficult we have contests centered around the skill), we also all know we can do nothing to fix it. Still gonna complain about it however.

To me it's worse because you have to know which version of English. Is it grey or gray, color or colour, shop or shoppe? At least boot is spelled boot even if it is the trunk.

Re: Audacity 4.0

#188

Earlier quoted context omitted.

He is pro age-verification with government IDs, what do you expect?

Please cite this if it's true. As far as I can tell they're updating the much dated UX from being stuck in the 90's and are making great strides on the app. I'm fine with them making money as they're investing into a utility I use.

telemetry != making money

Re: Audacity 4.0

#189
What I really hope for is searchable filters. With filter packs installed I simply cannot find them in slow scrolling menu list.

Re: Audacity 4.0

#190

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I can still use and develop GTK2 software in Debian out-of-the-box, but not Qt3 or even Qt4.

Yes, because GTK2 is so difficult to upgrade to new versions, whereas Qt4 to Qt5 usually only involved replacing a few identifiers (cannot speak to Qt6 since I don't do Qt anymore). That's why distros need to drag GTK2 along even though we are already at GTK4.

I work on the IUP fork, where I have and support the Qt driver, which works with both Qt5 and Qt6, and I only need a couple of checks to make it work on both. I often check if I broke the Qt5 build; nope, all good there, hard to break. For GTK3 and GTK4, those must be separate drivers; there's no way you can handle that with a couple of checks. Everything is different. That was possible to some extent and works with GTK2/GTK3 (single driver), but there are so many checks and workarounds there. Qt is so nice to work with.
Post reply on HN