Live data from Hacker News

Spanish legislation as a Git repo

github.com

181–190 of 246 posts

Re: Spanish legislation as a Git repo

#181
post #13

This is great. Compare it to British legislation which is frankly a mess of patches. Example picked fairly much at random, this law was originally passed in 1990 and has been "patched" regularly: https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1990/18/section/9 Laws being passed are these ludicrous sets of patches: https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2015/9/part/1

It's not messy. You have to take into account that every patch is voted separately - read Robert's Rules of Order for an enlightenment ;)

Re: Spanish legislation as a Git repo

#182

One idea behind the PoC Right to Privacy Act is having tests. A recurring theme with conservative Justices is clarity of legal text. Testing may not exhaust all scenarios but it is useful to see where loopholes may exist or whether a bill that sneaks in while you aren't paying attention is unfavorable to your values. https://github.com/righttoprivacyact/bill/blob/main/tests/te...

This is incredibly software engineer-brained. The law doesn't work like software. The only thing that matters is how the judiciary interprets the text, and if you try to use LLM "test" output to argue for a specific interpretation, you'll be laughed out of court.

Re: Spanish legislation as a Git repo

#183

Is there something like this for the US?

Even if there were, it wouldn't be very useful. In a "common law" system like the US, legal questions are rarely answered purely by the plain text of a law. You also need case law - that is, how the law is typically applied in practice by the courts.

Sure, then that with case law too?

Re: Spanish legislation as a Git repo

#184

Is there something like this for the US?

Even if there were, it wouldn't be very useful. In a "common law" system like the US, legal questions are rarely answered purely by the plain text of a law. You also need case law - that is, how the law is typically applied in practice by the courts.

The legislation seems more high-level requirements, that then implemented over in the Code of Federal Regs[1].

Using AI to plow through and make sense of all this would put us at risk of people knowing what the USG is getting up to.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Code_of_Federal_Regulations

Re: Spanish legislation as a Git repo

#186

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I come from a society that doesn't value compassion that much, so now when I live in Spain which has a lot of it, it's hard not to feel good about it. Wish it was the same in more places in the world, we're all human after all.

Cold-blooded murder ~= "compassion". Got it. Cool.

Helping someone avoid "nonrecoverable pain, forever" isn't "cold-blooded murder" in my mind, but I figure there is no point is arguing against someone who doesn't understand nuance.

Re: Spanish legislation as a Git repo

#187

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I come from a society that doesn't value compassion that much, so now when I live in Spain which has a lot of it, it's hard not to feel good about it. Wish it was the same in more places in the world, we're all human after all.

It shows.

Great, guess I've learnt sufficient English to be able to communicate my ideas and thoughts, thanks!

Re: Spanish legislation as a Git repo

#190
I did something very similar for some US state level laws. "Legit" legislative git.

Useful for alerts in our concern area, and monitoring proposed legislation iteration and flow through committees to keep ahead.

I can imagine quite a few other more civic interest uses as well!

Hoping to open source some later myself, seems an area ripe for some open civic citizen/hacker projects. Bet some fun startups could be made on top too, gl.

Post reply on HN