Live data from Hacker News

The whole thing was a scam

garymarcus.substack.com

181–190 of 347 posts

Re: The whole thing was a scam

#181
post #104

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think it does matter and this quote is always flaunted like it's some deep insight but it intentionally ignored nuance. An amount you can comfortably retire on is way different than $5. We love to pretend humans have unflinching morals but they don't

On the other hand, immoral people would try to convince you that anybody would kill their own mother for the right price.

Sleeping with someone ≠ committing murder.

Re: The whole thing was a scam

#182

How disappointing it is to see how easily some leaders in our industry abandon their principles, and how cheaply they sell out their fellow man. The tech industry was never perfect. It was never a charity. But there was a time, several years ago now, when people were more driven to build things that delighted others.

That was always a lie. Gates became the richest pedo in the world building a monopoly of bad software and destroying other people's businesses. Since then things only got worse.

Re: The whole thing was a scam

#183

Yep. The political donation was the main thing. But let’s not forget AI Czar David Sacks has been crying about Anthropic being woke for a couple years. He has probably been trying to kill every single non right wing AI company. After years of whining about lawfare on the All In podcast, these people are all too happy to engage in the worst kind of lawfare. There is a cabal of extremists steering technology contracts…

> A future administration will need to purge all their companies

Good luck, democrats will put some of that easy money on their pockets and look the other way, like they always did.

Re: The whole thing was a scam

#184
post #155

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yeah, that's the thing. Even in the most optimistic of dreams, Democrats won't end up with supermajorities in both the House and Senate. They can pass whatever bills they want, but Trump doesn't have to sign them. Sure, there will be things that Trump wants to do that he might actually need Congress for, and maybe there's room to make deals to advance some kind of progressive/liberal policies here and there. But I do…

Indeed, that's why we have to vote maga out and start over. We can't get lost in what we think will happen, we have to vote and then pay closer attention. We have to vote in people to congress who know exactly what the people demand.

You can vote in whoever you want, they'll take billionaire money the same way. The problem is not voting, it's the system.

Re: The whole thing was a scam

#185
post #156
post #119

> In capitalism, the market decides. > In oligarchy, connections and donations decide. > but after Brockman had donated 25M to Trump’s PAC Sounds like they paid Trump and the government, can it get more capitalistic? Oligarchy and capitalism don’t contradict each other

Free market capitalism and corporatocracy are two opposite things. (Free markets don't exist without strong institutions and regulation)

They're both capitalism

Re: The whole thing was a scam

#186

> but after Brockman had donated 25M to Trump’s PAC > In capitalism, the market decides. > In oligarchy, connections and donations decide. Author is confused about what Capitalism is. It worked exactly as expected, Capital used itself to advance it's own needs - maximizing (own) growth. Capitalism is not about markets, it's about Capital. There is a reason why lobbying is an accepted practice in one of the most Capit…

Which prominent economist has argued that bribes are an essential part of Capitalism?

Which prominent priest has argued that god doesn't exist?

Re: The whole thing was a scam

#187
post #156
post #119

> In capitalism, the market decides. > In oligarchy, connections and donations decide. > but after Brockman had donated 25M to Trump’s PAC Sounds like they paid Trump and the government, can it get more capitalistic? Oligarchy and capitalism don’t contradict each other

Free market capitalism and corporatocracy are two opposite things. (Free markets don't exist without strong institutions and regulation)

Only in the minds of people who make capitalism a religion. It has always been like this, early capitalism was even worse with dirty money buying every politician they could get their hands on. Just read anything about the US in the end of the 19th century.

Re: The whole thing was a scam

#188

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It cuts deep when it becomes so personal. What the heck do you say to grandma when that happens? I can’t imagine what I would do. In the end I think to preserve democracy one has to become involved. Standing on the sideline at this point doesn’t cut it.

At least in my case, I have just cut off contact with her. My parents are pretty decent people so I still talk to them a lot, but I can't deal with my grandmother anymore. If she thinks my wife (who was evidently on a Green Card at the time she said that) doesn't deserve to be here, she's allowed to think that, but she's not entitled to me being nice to her. I weighed my options and it came down these three choices:…

My step-mother (who didn't come into my life until around the time I got married. She is actually a pretty nice person overall, she is just... shall we say, opinionated, and could be somewhat racist once the conversation turned to politics. I always stopped participating in the conversation when she made racist statements, but she never fully seemed to take the hint.

Then we had a child. Once our kid was old enough to start understanding what people were saying, I put my foot down at one point when we came to visit. To paraphrase: I said, look, you're free to think whatever you want about whoever you want but the racist shit has to end when my daughter is around. Otherwise we need to head back home.

After that, it never happened again and we still keep in touch with her to this day. Some people just need to be told exactly where the boundaries are and then they respect them. (But of course not all will.)

Re: The whole thing was a scam

#189

Earlier quoted context omitted.

One fictional character that I think is helpful to bring is Luke Skywalker. It’s not about politeness, but about genuinely knowing why people behave the way they are and then offering them alternative other than QAnon. Listening to QAnon is a desperate attempt to understand the world after every other mainstream figure of authority failed that person. What I am talking about is not politeness. Politeness is tone mana…

I don't think I disagree much with what you said, but frankly I think that is a task for other people. I am exceedingly impatient with this kind of stuff, from people that I think should know better. I try to avoid these arguments now entirely and live in my happy progressive NYC bubble. No doubt that diplomacy with this stuff is necessary but I don't think that that's something anyone should want me specifically for…

I think what you’ve said is thoughtful and honest and I disagree with the downvotes.

I’m one of the politically homeless, and not even a resident of the USA, so I suppose I have an easy out.

Life can be very hard, and I don’t fault anyone for prioritizing their life over a political situation that is so very hard to affect. I do appreciate those that dedicate themselves though, the ones that seem to be helping and not hurting, anyway.

Re: The whole thing was a scam

#190

Earlier quoted context omitted.

In actual functioning democracies political donations are capped severely. Say, a single donor can contribute a maximum of €6,000 per parliament candidate per election. Yes, that's a real limit.

Citizens United assured that will never happen in the US, and everything critics said about it 16 years ago has come into fruition and more.

Roberts will certainly go down as the most consequential Chief Justice in several generations… the havoc he’s wrought is just remarkable.
Post reply on HN