Live data from Hacker News

Twitter Shadow Bans Turkish Presidential Candidate

utkusen.substack.com

181–190 of 209 posts

Re: Twitter Shadow Bans Turkish Presidential Candidate

#181

Elon has bragged about shadow banning posts in the interview with don lemon. Apparently twitter has been the most important public town square… to manipulate. Thank you.

Counterpoint: shadow banning will always be necessary in any public square until mental illness is solved.

Re: Twitter Shadow Bans Turkish Presidential Candidate

#182
post #89

The problem here is primarily Erdogan and secondarily Musk.

The world might have people like Erdogan hold less powerful positions if large social platforms like Twitter didn't enable populism and suppression so easily.

Poverty and lack of education empower folks like Erdogan.

Re: Twitter Shadow Bans Turkish Presidential Candidate

#183

Earlier quoted context omitted.

As many have begun to realize, the parent comment to yours is a large reason why the Democrats lost the 2024 election, and yet so many seem all too willing to double down on this rhetoric regardless of whether people are seeking a more balanced conversation.

Most democrats I listen to said they would rather lose than change their ideals.

Applying the term "fascism" and "eugenics" to capture everything they disagree with is not a strong ideal though. I wish they'd find something more convincing.

Re: Twitter Shadow Bans Turkish Presidential Candidate

#184

Earlier quoted context omitted.

>Elon fights UK, Brazil, Australia, Germany, and other democracies Care to share the sources that Elon fought those countries? Because the Wikipedia list of Twitter censorship shows that X complied with the majority requests from those countries.

https://x.com/elonmusk/status/1811783320839008381 """ The European Commission offered an illegal secret deal: if we quietly censored speech without telling anyone, they would not fine us. The other platforms accepted that deal. X did not. """

So the EC are the bad guys masquerading as free speech loving democracy?

Re: Twitter Shadow Bans Turkish Presidential Candidate

#185

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> but let's also remember that the world in 2013 doesn't exist anymore Yep. In 2013 the social networks all found out that they can sell censorship to governments all over the world and their users wouldn't even notice it.

That is not what happened. The world has changed for the worse and the social networks are the products of their time.

Egg and chicken ?

Anyway, that doesn't matter, what matters is that the people that are still using platforms are effectively collaborating with totalitarian extremists and should be shunned.

Re: Twitter Shadow Bans Turkish Presidential Candidate

#186

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> (see Twitter Files) Can you clarify where in the Twitter Files it says that things were run by “legal and moral busybodies”? From what I recall the “Twitter Files” were just big dumps of innocuous records that rarely (if ever) contained any sort of narrative. The “story” of what they meant was entirely constructed by folks that pretty transparently set out with the intention of making Musk look good (eg Matt Taibbi…

[flagged]

> Do you recall ever reading them...

Do you? Honest question.

Because there haven't actually been a release of "the Twitter Files". What was done was that Musk provided Matt Taibbi (among others) select internal emails and documents, and coordinated to selectively publicize some of those in editorialized twitter threads.

And yet I've never actually seen anything resembling a smoking gun or whatever it was they were aiming for.

Re: Twitter Shadow Bans Turkish Presidential Candidate

#187

[flagged]

By the way, one of his primary political goals these days is white nationalism. He does not try to hide it anymore: https://bsky.app/profile/harikunzru.bsky.social/post/3lxrqzm...

(In case anyone is not familiar: “Remigration is a far-right European concept of ethnic cleansing via the mass deportation of non-white immigrants and their descendants, sometimes including those born in Europe, to their place of racial ancestry.”)

I am gobsmacked that this is rarely mentioned whenever there’s news about Twitter. It’s just so stunningly grotesque.

Re: Twitter Shadow Bans Turkish Presidential Candidate

#188

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The idea that a large company has ever "leaned left" in any real sense is a bit ridiculous.

What is left? Your definition might be very different than the majority.

You should be wary in going there, unless you want to be beholden to the opinions of China + India.

Re: Twitter Shadow Bans Turkish Presidential Candidate

#189

[flagged]

> Elon will continue to mess with the algorithm until he gets his political goals. Twitter/X has open sourced their algorithm ( https://github.com/twitter/the-algorithm ). So what do you mean by “mess with the algorithm”? And how do you characterize the extreme moderation (AKA censorship) practiced by old Twitter? For example when they banned a sitting president on the flimsiest reasoning, that even their own blog po…

Here you go :

https://acoup.blog/2024/10/25/new-acquisitions-1933-and-the-...

And Elon has forfeited the charitable assumption that he wasn't a fascist when he made the fascist salute at the inauguration. Twice.

At such a public event, it doesn't even matter whether he believes it himself : symbols have power.

Post reply on HN