Live data from Hacker News

Apple lacks strategic vision

unherd.com

181–190 of 200 posts

Re: Apple lacks strategic vision

#181

Earlier quoted context omitted.

1.5 billion active users worldwide and the most affluent user base is not “that many”?

Think a little about the meaning of the phrase "Apple doesn't have that many customers, but has a lot of followers".

You don’t consider a quarter of the world’s population to be “that many”?

Re: Apple lacks strategic vision

#183

There are a few hiccups, but everyone'e acting like Apple Silicon wasn't one of the most wildly successful overnight improvements in laptops in the last 50 years and that airpods aren't so popular that even Android phone users buy them.

Apple Silicon was only an improvement in battery life. AMD and Intel still made more powerful processors coupled with Nvidia and AMD GPUs that blew Apple Silicon out of the water. Also depends what you consider successful since Macbooks are still a small fraction of the laptop market. Airpods being dominant is something from many years ago. Sony, Bose, even Samsung caught up quickly and offer much better integration…

> Apple Silicon was only an improvement in battery life.

For a company selling huge quantities of mobile computing devices, that's paramount.

Re: Apple lacks strategic vision

#184

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Oh great, where can I buy a non-Mac with the same performance, battery life, thermals, weight, premium materials, and a trackpad that doesn’t feel like styrofoam coated in oil? Since you say the competition has caught up, I assume it’ll be easy to send an Amazon link to the evidence.

Not OP but that's the thing right, you've talked a lot about feels which means there will never be an answer that overcomes the emotion built in your head. I wonder what it would take to win you over, and i don't mean the rational you, which i'm sure you can justify, i mean the irrational 'i'm in love with the product' you.

"A lot" being in one of six items, specifically about an element that you touch and quality is generally judged by how it feels

Re: Apple lacks strategic vision

#185

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Cook isn’t a visionary, he is an ops & logistics guy. He has a major problem with failing at AI and lying last year about “Apple Intelligence”. He needs some fresh blood in software as well. He should just buy something like Claude and lock them in with stock and very high salaries. He should also stop scrimping on integrated memory on the M series. Overpriced memory is a huge issue. And do something about the GPU as…

Buying competency and hoping for the best sounds exactly what an economist would do. They will probably leave as soon as their manager becomes just the run of the mill babysitter manager with charisma.

So true. That was Meta's all too generic strategy for the Metaverse, throw tons of money and people at the problem. And it worked as poorly as one would expect.

Now Meta is doing it again for AI.

Apple won't throw money down a hole like that, but they definitely need a more original and opinionated strategy than just an increased talent count.

The lack of love they gave Siri and AI in general, since they bought the original Siri tech in 2010, just keeps looking like a worse and worse oversight.

Re: Apple lacks strategic vision

#186

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The main innovation was buying all 3nm production from TSMC. Snapdragon chips on the same node perform as well.

The biggest stunt Apple pulled was making people think this is Apples new CPU designs that created the performance gap and not just buying all the production capacity for next gen fabs. We used to get that same performance gain every few years just from regular process improvements, but this time Apple made it seem like it was Apple that made the gain and not the general world.

Your argument would be much stronger with one single Amazon link to a non-Apple product that is competitive on price, perf, and thermals.

Re: Apple lacks strategic vision

#187

Earlier quoted context omitted.

They did have usable file system search decades ahead of Windows.

I mean.. Does window have it now? Debatable at best..

Everything (the program for Windows) gives Windows very good search, and it's not really doing any magic. It's just taking the NTFS journal and putting a decent GUI around it. File content search is optional and much slower, and indexing of other file systems is done the manual way (by actually searching through the entire file system). The fact that Windows hasn't done what Everything has already done goes to show it's not that Microsoft can't, but rather that they don't want to, unless every single Win32 developer over there has either kicked the bucket or moved on to better pastures.

Re: Apple lacks strategic vision

#188

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Not OP but that's the thing right, you've talked a lot about feels which means there will never be an answer that overcomes the emotion built in your head. I wonder what it would take to win you over, and i don't mean the rational you, which i'm sure you can justify, i mean the irrational 'i'm in love with the product' you.

It’d take these very objective things: - 7+ hour battery life while running a bunch of Docker containers and IDEs, at the same screen brightness nits I run my MacBook at. - Those things run not-perceptively-slower than on my Apple hardware - No perceptible fan noise while doing the above - The chassis does not creak when I pick it up from one corner - Does not weigh more than double my MacBook I’ll even relax the tra…

This is a much more definable list, no feels there. (I don't know.. as am not hunting for a similar option, although I probably will be in the future).

> - The chassis does not creak when I pick it up from one corner

This would be an INSTANT 'nope' from me.

Re: Apple lacks strategic vision

#189

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The article addresses Apple's historical late mover advantage strategy, and suggests that Tim Cook doesn't have the same vision that Jobs had to pull those moves off.

Ah yes, Jobs famously could solve the LLMs being shit problem overnight. By convincing users they want hallucinating, gas lighting imps in their pockets 24/7 to reinforce their thoughts. And he would have been all over it given his own alt-medicine beliefs.

He is dead, we cannot be certain.

Re: Apple lacks strategic vision

#190
post #23

There are a few hiccups, but everyone'e acting like Apple Silicon wasn't one of the most wildly successful overnight improvements in laptops in the last 50 years and that airpods aren't so popular that even Android phone users buy them.

Facts. I switched to Mac primarily because of the CPU. Look at the state of Intel...

I will never buy Intel, I will be good with AMD. How and when, I do not know, as I do not have the financial means to get a new rig. My PC is considered ancient at this point and unfortunately to my medical conditions, I highly doubt it will happen anytime soon, if ever, unless someone helps me out with enough money, oh welp.
Post reply on HN