Live data from Hacker News

Daily driving a Linux phone, but why?

thefoggiest.dev

181–190 of 237 posts

Re: Daily driving a Linux phone, but why?

#181
post #159
post #135

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It is unclear to me what alternative you are proposing, apart from bending to Google and Apple?

There is no alternative. Unless you pay by cash and have verified that all of the utilities and services you consume are not laundering your data then you’re just wasting your time by putting up with a horrible phone OS experience.

Digital privacy is futile predicated on paying your electricity bill by credit card? Absolutist fatalism is not helpful.

Re: Daily driving a Linux phone, but why?

#182

I was daily driving Linux phones 15 years ago! It's crazy to think back on the journey. I have great nostalgia for the Nokia N900 but god damn Maemo/Meego was a piece of shit. When you can't even answer phone calls it's not daily driving anymore, it's beta testing. After that I tried Firefox OS but it was switfly replaced by Android, thank the gods for Android.

Oh, I'm sorry to hear that. My experience with the N900 (and the N9 later) was pretty decent. The N900 was way ahead of its time. I got it in 2010. popped in a 32G µSD-card and I had 64GB, which was already a lot. The UI was amazing. True multitasking on a phone. IIRC the iPhone at that time wasn't able to do that. usable HW keyboard, headphone jack, two cameras, proper two-stage camera button, a little stand to prop…

Both me and my brother had an N900 each and we both had an awful experience with them. My brother worked at Nokia at the time so he's lyrical about Nokia phones to this day.

Re: Daily driving a Linux phone, but why?

#183
post #60

But why, indeed. Years ago, I met someone (through another friend) who worked in CS, and was super into digital privacy. He was the first person I knew to run a Linux phone, for privacy reasons. He tried to pay for as much as possible by cash, and maintained his accounts manually on paper. The only way to contact him was by text message (intermittently, unreliably) or via a specific client using the Matrix protocol.…

Not using platforms in general and GAFAMs in particular goes beyond privacy issues though, especially outside USA.

Re: Daily driving a Linux phone, but why?

#184
post #2

I run an older Android phone without a Google account. All apps are from F-Droid. Google services are all turned off. Mail is Thunderbird, browser is Fennec. Is it still possible to initialize an Android phone without a Google account?

Easily ? I recently bought a Samsung Galaxy S21 as a backup and am posting from it right now (from Firefox). Never associated a Google account.

The issue is that it's just a stop-gap solution : we ought to strive to remove our dependence on Android/iOS(/Xiaomi) entirely.

Re: Daily driving a Linux phone, but why?

#185
post #173
post #56

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Try getting a patch into android vs getting a patch into a debian package and tell me how it's the same thing :D

GrapheneOS has contributed many past features to AOSP. Does that count?

So 1 external contributor that needs very well organised

Re: Daily driving a Linux phone, but why?

#186
post #175
post #130

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It cannot be compiled as it is, so it's nothing that runs on any phone.

GrapheneOS is completely open source and based on AOSP. As is LineageOS. What‘s your point?

It's self evident. Just stop refusing to see it.

Re: Daily driving a Linux phone, but why?

#187
post #172

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> it's already free software I'd just like to interject here for a moment. The word Free Software has a specific meaning that AOSP does not meet. The only component of AOSF that is Free Software is the Kernel, due to GPL, and aside from low-level Android-specific modules such as binder there's no secret sauce in Android kernels; even the vendor modifications are mostly gutted out in favour of Project Treble and GKI.…

Which one of the four freedoms is not met by AOSP? Don‘t Linux phones also rely on binary blobs?

My bad - I forgot that Free Software need not be copyleft. The point on Android still stands tho, and the freedoms on AOSP are decresing by the day as well.

Re: Daily driving a Linux phone, but why?

#188
post #123

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's an Android device with an old unsupported kernel that runs a hacked up Debian-ish userspace on top of Android layer. While that may be good enough for some, it's not what some of us want. I'll stay with my Librem 5, which is also totally usable, runs actual Debian, runs Waydroid too, and does not bring me Halium pain.

The lengths people go to for a horrible Ui/UX and app experience is bewildering. I guess they justify it by not caving into Google or Apple. Of course, all of their privacy concerns and safeguards go away when the credit cards, utilities and services they use all circumvent their precious Linux phone. But hey, at least you’re running Linux on your phone, right?

Can you provide more information on your claim? If I use a credit card in app A, what privacy-violating info can app B get?

Re: Daily driving a Linux phone, but why?

#189

same here, i daily drive linux on my phone, ditched the prioprietary OSs long ago

How are you dealing with companies that force you to use an Android app? There are so many services in daily life where people just expect me to have an Android/iPhone device. Those things are increasingly difficult to achieve in a different way.

Not the parent but I'll reply for myself. I have a Librem 5 as my personal phone which I take with me when I go places and use as my daily driver. I also have a Pixel running GrapheneOS with work and personal profiles for the few times I need to run an Android application but it more or less permanently stays at my desk. The Android applications I have on that phone are banking (required to use Zelle at my bank) and management applications for various devices (ex: managing settings on my bluetooth headphones). I don't need to use those often and when I do it can wait until I'm back at my desk where my GrapheneOS phone lives.
Post reply on HN