Live data from Hacker News

Quit Social Media (2016)

calnewport.com

181–190 of 281 posts

Re: Quit Social Media (2016)

#181

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What makes Hacker News a social media website?

Not much since it’s moderated to the point of being a boring headline aggregator, with a heavily biased, toxic community of vain Americans ignoring anything outside the HN RDF May as well disable comments and treat it like a user updated RSS feed, discuss links elsewhere.

[deleted]

Re: Quit Social Media (2016)

#182

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Piracy is a service problem. A paywall literally says “you might like this but pay me first to see what it is.” Substack has a “let me read it first” button and I’ve never seen an archive link to that even though there are plenty of private articles. The concept of gift links exists, but these websites footaxe themselves by limiting their most viral content —- ostensibly the best and cheapest marketing they could get…

It doesn't matter how you rationalize your acts, the fact you're abusing IA's infrastructure doesn't change. To me, you burned a hospital bed to send a message that capitalism is bad. I don't care what your opinion is. You burned the bed.

What? I’m pretty sure people are talking about archive.is and not archive.org here.

Re: Quit Social Media (2016)

#183

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What makes Hacker News a social media website?

Not much since it’s moderated to the point of being a boring headline aggregator, with a heavily biased, toxic community of vain Americans ignoring anything outside the HN RDF May as well disable comments and treat it like a user updated RSS feed, discuss links elsewhere.

Yeah but I tried a Linux laptop for a week and just couldn’t make it work, Apple products are the best.

Re: Quit Social Media (2016)

#184

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Piracy is a service problem. A paywall literally says “you might like this but pay me first to see what it is.” Substack has a “let me read it first” button and I’ve never seen an archive link to that even though there are plenty of private articles. The concept of gift links exists, but these websites footaxe themselves by limiting their most viral content —- ostensibly the best and cheapest marketing they could get…

Substack's "let me read it first" is just a way to close the subscription popup, it has nothing to do with reading otherwise paywalled content. The thing is, having had some of my own content "go viral" before - it's not worth much. Most people will read it for a minute and move on. A tiny percentage will subscribe and an even tinier percentage will give you any money. So from the point of view of a creator, it makes…

> Substack's "let me read it first" is just a way to close the subscription popup, it has nothing to do with reading otherwise paywalled content.

It has everything to do with telegraphed intention of not having content be gratis. The fact that you cannot even mentally keep the idea of subscription gates in the same bucket as paywalls says a lot.

Re: Quit Social Media (2016)

#185

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Substack's "let me read it first" is just a way to close the subscription popup, it has nothing to do with reading otherwise paywalled content. The thing is, having had some of my own content "go viral" before - it's not worth much. Most people will read it for a minute and move on. A tiny percentage will subscribe and an even tinier percentage will give you any money. So from the point of view of a creator, it makes…

> Substack's "let me read it first" is just a way to close the subscription popup, it has nothing to do with reading otherwise paywalled content. It has everything to do with telegraphed intention of not having content be gratis. The fact that you cannot even mentally keep the idea of subscription gates in the same bucket as paywalls says a lot.

No, not really. It's mostly just a typical CTA for getting email subscribers. Plenty of completely free newsletters have popups like that.

PS: using a new green account to make snarky put-downs isn't welcome on HN. Make a point or don't make it, but do it without those.

Re: Quit Social Media (2016)

#186

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What makes Hacker News a social media website?

I would argue the defining factor of social media which separates it from blogs/forums/etc. is the ubiquitous feedback metrics, in the form of likes/downvotes/retweets/etc. Imagine attending party where whenever you finished a sentence, everyone who was listening immediately responded with a silent thumbs up / thumbs down in response. Pretty dystopian. The Onion did a sketch illustrating the problem a few years ago:…

HN is simply pre-Web 2.0 social media, a la Slashdot, Metafilter, the WELL, kuro5hin, etc.

Re: Quit Social Media (2016)

#187

> “I decided, after 15 years, to live in reality.” This is the crux of the matter. Social media isn’t real; it’s a type of video game for adults. The unreality fosters the growth of so many other things which are even less concerned with truth: fake news, engagement bait, daily outrages, chasing followers in a vain attempt to “build a personal brand.” The vacuousness of influencer culture has only accelerated these t…

> engagement bait, daily outrages, I have a pet theory as to why social media causes many people to feel like it's draining them, and why I avoid news on social media like the plague ... I also tend to mute or silence people that share political content (regardless of partisan affiliation). Social media, unless you are trying to build a business, is ultimately offering the service of entertainment. Even if you use Tw…

Even without considering all of the contentious topics, the infinite scroll of the home feed trains people to triage posts faster and faster, because there's always more content, and who knows what you've missed? Because the topics are flattened, you're context-switching on a second by second basis, and your mind is alert to something awful you might be about to see - cute cat, war crimes, Dan's birthday celebration, medical fundraiser, political campaign, sponsored ad... I'm really starting to see the value of legitimate boredom

Re: Quit Social Media (2016)

#188
I’m about 9 months off social media (not including Hackernews, if you consider that SM). I have no regrets whatsoever. I’m in my late 20’s so SM came into my sphere when I was around 16. I haven’t quite “grown up with it”, but it’s been an omnipresent force for most of my teenage and adult life.

> I am better at making time to catch up with the people I really care about, be that in-person or over WhatsApp. > When I do catch up with someone, I genuinely have no idea what’s been going on in their life and that makes the catch up a lot more enjoyable and engaging. I haven’t passively kept up to date on their every movement through Instagram stories or Tweets like some kind of ghostly stalker. The best example of this that I can give is that my partner and I got engaged to be married ~4 months ago. Nothing posted on SM, just WhatsApp messages to close friends and family. I get to keep reliving the joy of telling people and witnessing the ecstatic surprise and pure love on their faces each time I catch up with someone I haven’t seen for a while. > I am much more aware of just how much everyone uses their phones. Take a look around you. Sitting on the bus, waiting in a queue, riding an escalator, pissing at a urinal. Our minds are being constantly bombarbed with mostly useless, inane shite. Cat videos, stories of that person you went to school with 10 years ago doing stupid drunk things, misinformation from your scary uncle on Facebook etc. I let my mind wander more and it feels all the better for it.

Re: Quit Social Media (2016)

#189

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What makes Hacker News a social media website?

Not much since it’s moderated to the point of being a boring headline aggregator, with a heavily biased, toxic community of vain Americans ignoring anything outside the HN RDF May as well disable comments and treat it like a user updated RSS feed, discuss links elsewhere.

And yet here you are!

Re: Quit Social Media (2016)

#190

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What makes Hacker News a social media website?

Not much since it’s moderated to the point of being a boring headline aggregator, with a heavily biased, toxic community of vain Americans ignoring anything outside the HN RDF May as well disable comments and treat it like a user updated RSS feed, discuss links elsewhere.

You forgot antisocial.
Post reply on HN