Live data from Hacker News

Only real people can patent inventions – not AI, US Government says

cnn.com

181–183 of 183 posts

Re: Only real people can patent inventions – not AI, US Government says

#181

It is useful to look at every headline and ask: How is this going to lead us into a dystopian Hell? Imagine a new law passed to protect corporate IP where corporations and AIs are people, but humans are not.

Both of those already have more rights than actual people right now.

Re: Only real people can patent inventions – not AI, US Government says

#182

Earlier quoted context omitted.

No, the ruling is more than that it must be filed in the name of a human. It also says 'a real person must have made a “significant contribution”'.

> No, the ruling is more than that it must be filed in the name of a human. It also says 'a real person must have made a “significant contribution”'. This is so interesting... it sounds to me that operators can have AIs "inventing" things and publicly sharing these things. Creating so much stuff (like bitcoin but for AI) covering virtually everything - from science to music. And because no humans contributed to these…

It remains to be seen if AI can really invent significant things on its own. I don't think there's been any examples of it so far, and today's AI are really limited by what is in their corpus. Perhaps in 5 years? Isn't that what they say for every promising technology though?

Anyway if AI is capable of that, there will be bigger changes to society than intellectual property!

Re: Only real people can patent inventions – not AI, US Government says

#183
post #42
post #2

AI could, however, poison the well for human patents, by making inventions and putting them into public view. Let's have LLMs churn out millions of discoveries, stick them on a public web site, then use that as a resource to kill other patents.

Has anyone tried doing that without LLMs? Could you make a GitHub repo under MIT license and just let people add a list of ideas to serve as prior art?

Corporations have long had house journals where they publish inventions they didn't patent, just to ensure no one else patents them. I think AT&T in particular had one of these.
Post reply on HN