Live data from Hacker News

Gen Z Netiquettes

manyonepercents.substack.com

181–190 of 269 posts

Re: Gen Z Netiquettes

#181
post #156

Every time some new generation starts to create its own identity, some proportion of the previous dominant generation reacts defensively by attacking it with wilful ignorance and disdain. It's a tragic way to age. Worse than a ponytail and a motorbike. If you find yourself finding smug, try looking at an old Reddit rage comic/4chan greentext/usenet flamewar, depending on your age.

Conversely, don’t expect the previous generations to quit using capitalization and periods. Your point is well taken, and thankfully I have neither a pony tail nor a motorcycle, but I am quite likely to observe 40 years of habit and driving in the guardrails of the language. Or, ya know, don’t read shit into the message that isn’t there.

Like Albus Dumbledore says in Harry Potter: If you are a young person it cannot be expected from you that you understand how old people feel. But if you are an old person and don't understand how young people feel, you are a fool, because you have been young once.

Re: Gen Z Netiquettes

#182
None of this is new to me. I can totally identify with most of the gotchats presented in the article. I am far from being a Gen Z. If you were actually active on irc or icq, msn, aol (which are even explecitly mentioned in the blog post!) you know all this.

Re: Gen Z Netiquettes

#183

Earlier quoted context omitted.

They're really not though, because they render differently on different devices. If I send a gun emoji, it may render as a squirt gun for you for instance. Very different meanings.

Also the way I feel about certain emojis is different from how you feel about them and thus carry different (if slightly) meaning. For example, I pretty much never use the clown emoji as I find it personally offensive. But I'm sure that pretty much everyone else doesn't feel the same about it.

The triumph emoji is a very good example of this.

Westerners use it to signify they're pissed while it actually means triumph in Asia I believe.

Re: Gen Z Netiquettes

#185

Earlier quoted context omitted.

My impression of people who write like that is that they're 9 years old and somehow made it on the big-boy Internet. Mostly because the content of messages written in that fashion gives that impression as well. It's sloppier than the average youtube comment.

What a bizarre take. Who do you work with? The majority of people I’ve worked with of all ages at various companies default to all-lowercase in casual communication, including some of the most intelligent and expressive people. As the other commenter said, it’s perceived as friendlier and more casual. Messages with capitalisation and completely correct grammar in these settings comes off as stilted and corporate.

Perceived as friendly and casual by idiots.

Re: Gen Z Netiquettes

#187

> 9. Capitalizing the first letter in a sentence will reveal where you are This one really surprises me, if someone contacted me without bothering to type a proper sentence I would just think they're an idiot. Everyone I know always starts a sentence with a capital letter, no matter the platform. They all know how to use the shift key. This isn't even gate keeping, people use slang all the time, it is basic English.…

Same with full stops for me.

Re: Gen Z Netiquettes

#188
post #120

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's from Aristophanes of Byzantium in the 3rd century BCE.

I knew it was older than texting:)

To close the loop on this, here is some greek texting! [1] :smiley:

[1] https://blogs.transparent.com/greek/texting-and-tweeting-in-...

Re: Gen Z Netiquettes

#189

Earlier quoted context omitted.

this doesn't really matter though, because you still now the meaning of the Emoji. Letters also render different, depending on the font, without their meaning changing

This is not true. The actual form has meaning too. Extreme example: if someone sends a romantic message, they typically don't want it rendered in a font typically used for the title on a horror DVD.

does that commonly happen though? emoji exist in unicode so meaning should remain consistent. in fact, here is how popular emoji render across platforms: https://unicode.org/emoji/charts/full-emoji-list.html

Re: Gen Z Netiquettes

#190
Prognostication over the presence or absence of a single punctuation point seems like a problem for the reader. It assumes the author has the same background and understanding of these fine points that the reader does. This is probably an unreasonable assumption. I used to look for these shibboleths and hidden implications from minor stylistic issues. It's a bad habit. It often does reveal much. But it also tends to apophenia - seeing patterns that are not there. And it's so fuzzy that preconception tends to dominate. (You only worry about the abruptness of 'K.' if you're already worried about what they think of you.)

As a writer, try to follow the style your audience expects. That advice applies to informal personal communications. But don't engage heavily in this practice as a reader. It can be counterproductive to communication.

Post reply on HN