Live data from Hacker News

A circuit simulator that doesn't look like it was made in 2003

withdiode.com

181–190 of 270 posts

Re: A circuit simulator that doesn't look like it was made in 2003

#181
This is very cool, though as others have said it is fairly resource intensive.

I'd love to see a schematic exported or even shown as you press simulate (you clearly have it the components and links in memory somewhere to do the simulation). This would be great for debugging.

Re: A circuit simulator that doesn't look like it was made in 2003

#182
Perhaps peripheral (the original site has been hugged to death).

Both clashlang: https://clash-lang.org/

And Hardcaml: https://github.com/janestreet/hardcaml

have personally fueled my interest in hardware.

Dan Luu speaks eloquently and at length about how better options are needed for logic design. I would recommend both of the above to the enthusiastic novice.

Re: A circuit simulator that doesn't look like it was made in 2003

#183

This looks amazing and some of you really need to stop yelling at clouds. Not everything needs to be “boring and functional”, it’s ok for things to be just fun.

Maybe, but a circuit designer is pretty high up the list of things that need to be boring and functional.

Re: A circuit simulator that doesn't look like it was made in 2003

#184
post #178

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I recently came across a reference manual for an SoC that came in at over 24,000 pages - a new personal record. The tools for working with such large PDFs generally suck.

I'd be so happy with a 24,000 page PDF, cause then at least you know where too look, and you can the search tool. I programme Siemens hardware and the docs I need are spread out over many tens of PDFs (of 100-1500 pages). I haven't found a proper tool than can let me search and view all this documentation properly. Best I found is ripgrep with some PDF extension to search which document I need, and then use SumatraPD…

How about joining all the PDFs together and doing ctrl-F? Sounds like it could save you the grep step.

Re: A circuit simulator that doesn't look like it was made in 2003

#186

Schematics are for understanding what a circuit does. Breadboards are for prototyping small low-speed circuits. Veroboard is for prototyping larger medium-speed circuits. Gerbers & a PCB are for production and for prototyping large or high-speed circuits. If the tool could automatically make a 3D breadboard view from a schematic, it'd be pretty neat for beginners. If the tool warned you when the normal parasitic capa…

>Breadboards are for prototyping small low-speed circuits.

Reminds me: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yR9TweWf3w8 Sine oscillator (no ICs), 10K load, 24+GHz on a breadboard.

Re: A circuit simulator that doesn't look like it was made in 2003

#189
This illustrates a problem with many "modern" applications. My first impression: "Oh, that looks nice. Looks like in real life". Then I tried using it and found that it is clunky and slow to the point it is barely usable and I would much faster build the real circuit on a real breadboard instead.

Re: A circuit simulator that doesn't look like it was made in 2003

#190

This illustrates a problem with many "modern" applications. My first impression: "Oh, that looks nice. Looks like in real life". Then I tried using it and found that it is clunky and slow to the point it is barely usable and I would much faster build the real circuit on a real breadboard instead.

Exactly. I was seeing a friend the other day who was using an ancient version of mastercam, version 8 I think. I looked at it and thought wow I need to update him to a later version. However after watching him use it it just all made sense. There were a few areas that could be improved, but it was so simple and clear to use.
Post reply on HN