Live data from Hacker News

FBI Child ID App

fbi.gov

181–190 of 249 posts

Re: FBI Child ID App

#181

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Our irises are considerably more information-dense Someone should give you free cryptocurrency for a scan of your iris.

It’s already been done: https://www.cnbc.com/amp/2021/10/21/sam-altmans-worldcoin-wa...

(That was the joke.)

Re: FBI Child ID App

#183
post #8

Initially I thought that it would be satire, then I recognized the domain. I have a weird feeling about this, but can't put a finger on it.

Felt off to me too. My guess is that it's a makework project they put a batch of summer interns on to keep them out of trouble.

Re: FBI Child ID App

#185

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Isn't this fairly easy to investigate and find out? If the app never phones home then it really isn't an issue.

A future update of the app might start phoning home.

Installing any kind of channel back to the FBI on an Android device from who-knows-where with who-knows-what malware running on it feels like a disaster waiting to happen.

Re: FBI Child ID App

#186

It says a lot about the FBI that most people's initial reaction is "whats the trick here?". BOTH sides of the political aisle too.

I think a lot of people are put off by the fact that the FBI took the time to make this instead of doing more important duties. The app seems to have good intentions, but its execution needs work, so there's not much benefit.

It almost has to be a summer intern project.

Re: FBI Child ID App

#187

There's a television ad that stands out in my memory from when I was a kid (80s). The camera pans across patrons at a diner and the voiceover is about how a kidnapped child was recovered as the camera stops on a young girl (~8yo). The child is described, but the child the camera landed on has different features (hair dyed, cut, whatever). The explanation for how she was identified is that her fingerprints were on fil…

I remember this! I got finger printed at some event where police had a booth next to the fire dept (who were espousing bike helmets and teaching kids how to properly wear one etc, actually useful safety info). It wasn't until I was a teenager when my first car was broken into and the speakers stolen that I realized how useless that endeavor must be. The officer who responded (my first time calling the police, not run…

I suspect running fingerprints is much easier now, depending on how long it's been. It's very automated now.

Re: FBI Child ID App

#189
post #107

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yep, I remember getting fingerprinted at a mall. Thanks to my folks for preemptively snitching.

Happened to me as well. Now the FBI has my fingerprints on file even though I've never committed a crime. I had a discussion with my Mom a couple years about this and she admitted she screwed up. I can't blame her of course. Especially since at the time there was plenty of FBI propoganda about missing kids terrifying parents and claiming this was a solution.

> I can't blame her of course. Especially since at the time there was plenty of FBI propoganda about missing kids terrifying parents and claiming this was a solution.

So long as we keep giving people a pass for falling for this crap they have no incentive not to fall for this crap.

Re: FBI Child ID App

#190

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The FBI and other 3 letter agencies have been vacuuming up every communication between us, warrantless, for so many years it’s crazy. That unconstitutional overreach has been used to do what exactly? No I really want to know. It’s not keeping us safe, because someone who is basically a cartoon caricature of a school shooter can scare everyone they come in contact with, get a long gun and ammo, and execute a mass shoo…

> "That unconstitutional overreach has been used to do what exactly? No I really want to know. It’s not keeping us safe..." Unpopular opinion, but you know the old saying: No one hears about the times the FBI, CIA, etc has stopped a terrorist act, you only hear about the disasters that eventually played out. For every one sick person that went on to do something crazy, hundreds have been caught before anything happen…

>For every one sick person that went on to do something crazy, hundreds have been caught before anything happened.

If their dragnets had even a shred of utility for that purpose they'd be telling you about it at every opportunity.

Post reply on HN