Live data from Hacker News

14-inch MacBook Pro review: A Mac Pro in your backpack

sixcolors.com

181–190 of 244 posts

Re: 14-inch MacBook Pro review: A Mac Pro in your backpack

#181
post #166

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It limits how many menus your apps can have or makes them draw around it. If you enable compatibility mode you'll be back to an even fatter bezel which looks like dog shit. Rationalize that away.

Understand you may be that 5-10% of the market that the notch impacts. The vast vast majority aren't running Photoshop and will spend 90% of their time on a browser which likely complies with notch.

You think pro users spend 90% of their time on a browser?

Re: 14-inch MacBook Pro review: A Mac Pro in your backpack

#182
post #96

I assumed that 10gbit ethernet was only quietly released as an option for the M1 Mac Mini some time after the initial announcement, because Apple didn't want to commit to components where supply constraints could limit their ability to scale up production in the case of high demand. Likewise, I wonder if there will be options for HDMI 2.1 (for 4K@120Hz), SD slot with UHS-III, and wifi 6E in the next few months for th…

I expect the lack of HDMI 2.1 is bandwidth related. Full-bandwidth HDMI 2.1 is 48Gbps but Thunderbolt 4 is "only" 40. I'm not sure if they still do, but at one point each pair of Thunderbolt ports shared a bus, so you could have something on the left running at 40Gbps and something on the right running at 40Gbps, but not two things on one side. If that's still the case, the SD card slot and the HDMI port are probably…

That's an interesting point. What interface do they use for the integrated display? It looks like there are multiple sets of chips involved in the physical ports for Thunderbolt or USB depending on what is connected.

Re: 14-inch MacBook Pro review: A Mac Pro in your backpack

#183
post #169

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I actually like the throwback, personally. I'm guessing they did that to differentiate it in the market. What I have trouble getting over is the flipping notch to the top. Just why. The bezel on my 2019 macbook looks the same, if not skinnier. Do people really not watch fullscreen videos anymore or something?

I’m wondering whether the notch was supposed to be for Face ID, but they couldn’t make it work due to current supply chain constraints, and that notched displays were already ordered.

It already had a front-facing camera, of course. Does a camera for Face ID require a bigger notch/bigger area? (Real question, I don't know!)

Re: 14-inch MacBook Pro review: A Mac Pro in your backpack

#184
post #178

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This is why you have a full product line, right? You can make one laptop that prioritises weight and thinness, and you can make another one that prioritises power, features, etc. The problem with the previous Macbook product line was that all products had the same compromises. Design purity, and thinness over everything else. There was no choice for a "pro" machine that had a different set of tradeoffs to achieve pro…

I'm just asking for a tapered edge :D The new bulbous rounded edges almost seem passive-aggressive from apple. Yes, prioritize power, and with whatever remaining ability to make things pretty that you have, utilize it. When you can but don't, that's unattractive. Is there a specific reason for the brick look? I'm not sure that we know there is.

I'd say that given no teardowns have yet been released, its also true that we know there isn't a specific reason for the brick look. They crammed a lot of battery in there, big, slow, quiet fans, six speakers, and the SoC is something like 4x larger than the base M1.

Re: 14-inch MacBook Pro review: A Mac Pro in your backpack

#185

Earlier quoted context omitted.

... All 4:3 videos are taller than 16:9 certainly, and there's a non-trivial number of those.

Absolutely. I run into this all the time with my phone's screen (likely a different ratio, but I almost never have it not cover video. If there's a program that will literally add black padding until the notch goes away I'd probably use it, at least when watching media.

Reports are the OS already does this for you when watching fullscreen media.

Apparently Apple still has some design sense after all.

Re: 14-inch MacBook Pro review: A Mac Pro in your backpack

#186
post #169

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I’m wondering whether the notch was supposed to be for Face ID, but they couldn’t make it work due to current supply chain constraints, and that notched displays were already ordered.

It already had a front-facing camera, of course. Does a camera for Face ID require a bigger notch/bigger area? (Real question, I don't know!)

Face ID has a separate IR camera and a 3d IR dot array, so can imagine it requires a bit more space than a regular webcam.

Re: 14-inch MacBook Pro review: A Mac Pro in your backpack

#187

If it was above board to download and run MacOS in VMWare as a guest under my linux host (slowdowns because of arc differences forgiven), I'd be way more willing dip a toe into the ecosystem and see how I like it...

Aside from going into an Apple store, probably the cheapest way to try out the M1 Macs is to rent one from Scaleway (€0,10/hour + tax, minimum 24h - https://www.scaleway.com/en/hello-m1/ ).

Re: 14-inch MacBook Pro review: A Mac Pro in your backpack

#188

> It will probably take a little while for Mac apps to be updated to support the ProMotion display. I found that some apps scrolled text in the same buttery-smooth way that apps do on my iPhone and iPad, but others didn’t. I was able to find a few Catalyst-based apps that have already been written to support 120Hz displays on iPad and iPhone, and they looked spectacular. It surprised me that an app would have to be u…

Anyone know the details, and nature of the update that has to be done?

I don’t know what is happening specifically with these apps (we’d have to look at their source code on a case by case basis) but to hypothesize:

Since 60hz has been a de facto standard on the Mac for decades I can imagine that a lot of apps may have a hard-coded 60hz timer for updating their window contents. This would completely negate the advantages of a 120hz on things like scrolling smoothness. These apps would need to be updated to not assume 60hz and instead update their window contents when requested to do so by the system. Furthermore, some applications which generate their window contents on demand (based on their internal data structures) may need new algorithms if they are too slow to update at 120hz. I know that many applications (including web browsers) I’ve used over the years can’t even keep up with 60hz updates when scrolling through a complicated document.

Re: 14-inch MacBook Pro review: A Mac Pro in your backpack

#189
> the Touch Bar. It was introduced in 2016 and… never really went anywhere. A more aggressive set of software updates from Apple might have turned it into something, but that never happened. > Now it’s gone, replaced instead by a very traditional row of function keys.

Well to be honest I liked the Touch Bar and I used it quite often. On the other hand I never used the "Function Keys".

Re: 14-inch MacBook Pro review: A Mac Pro in your backpack

#190
post #89

The body text of this is very hard to read on Windows (Firefox & Edge) since the text appears to be bolded. I would change to font-weight 300 or something like this.

indeed. All is wrapped into one huge tag which causes browsers to apply the bold font style.
Post reply on HN