Live data from Hacker News

The Apple Watch

daringfireball.net

171–180 of 300 posts

Re: The Apple Watch

#171

"Without the Taptic Engine, Apple Watch is not a compelling device." This is why I value Gruber's reviews. He's unabashedly pro-Apple, but he's also critical and observant.

Is he really being that critical if he observes their product would fail without something it already has?

I know it's not a direct comparison, but you wouldn't call me insightfully critical if I noted that a car was not a compelling device without wheels.

Re: The Apple Watch

#172
post #34

It's interesting that even gruber's review isn't all that positive.

The Verge's review gives it 7/10 and says it often lags, emojis are creepy, etc.

But that's in a very over-produced review with a credits list of about 15 people!

Re: The Apple Watch

#173

Article aside for a moment, I find it fascinating that with this release so many people are discussing smart watches and their interfaces as something completely new with no established precedents. I've had my Pebble for almost 2 years now and my LG G watch for about 8 months. From my perspective this seems like a late-comer to a market that is already well under-way? I would expect more existing market comparison co…

I agree, I have had my Pebble for a year and it works perfectly. Tells me when I get an e-mail or text message. I also keep my phone on silent all the time since I can get the notifications directly and can decide if I need to reply or if I can ignore it for later. I can also check my stocks and there are tons of apps on the pebble appstore.

The battery life is also very nice and lasts a full week.

The SDK is also pretty nice, I've made some simple apps with it.

Re: The Apple Watch

#174

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The guy has probably never heard of the Seiko Spring Drive, where the hands are moved by a spring and regulated by a brake. Therefore they're completely smooth. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZsBTXgksr4s

It's a bummer that video plays at 30fps. This is a case where 60 (does YouTube do higher framerates?) would pay off.

See: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9344766 ... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c7ZmyWO-QU8

Re: The Apple Watch

#175
post #85

Honest questions: How people can write such long articles? How many hours they might have spent in writing? Does anyone read it from the top to bottom completely? Is it not possible to express the whole thing in a small article without losing the gist? EDIT 1: Gruber's articles have lot of useful information,analysis and insights but I feel, current article is too lengthy. EDIT 2: Anandtech's reviews are also detaile…

It's 11 pages long. You can't read that in one sitting?

Re: The Apple Watch

#176
He is wrong in this article: CDs did not suck. Compressed audio sucked, unless you had NIHL and love reduced dynamic range and poor attack transients.

I am glad CDs are still around to stop this MP3 slime from washing away all the uncompressed audio!

Re: The Apple Watch

#177
post #43

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I already have to charge (and bring cables and charger with sufficient ports for): Laptop iPhone USB Backup battery (many long travel days) Wifi hotspot Pretty much every day. By some counts, a watch doesn't really change that very much, by other counts it pushes my daily-shit-to-charge list over the limit. It's nitpicky when viewed in a vacuum, but not in relation to the overall technology charging burden. It seems…

i find it interesting that 5 is over the limit, but 4 is perfectly reasonable. Personally i have 1, my phone, and increasing it to 2 seems like no change at all personally.

Sorry, to be clear, I don't consider 4 "reasonable". It's more like it's crept up and I've set a pretty hard limit on more rechargeable tech.

Re: The Apple Watch

#178
post #21

Gruber's scenario with the two high school kids sending each other love taps, scribbles, and heartbeats was poignant. While the Apple Watch isn't for me, I can't begrudge those who decide to buy one. I think back to the late 90s and how I wouldn't have met my wife if not for IMing a screenname a mutual friend of ours passed along to me. The internet, a crappy eMachines desktop, and AIM made this possible. Technically…

Gruber's scenario with the two high school kids was probably the worst thing he's ever written. There needs to be an annual 500-word short story writing competition, for best story turning on the sentence "But you both wore an Apple Watch". I say this as someone who generally admires John Gruber's ability to sell me on 1000-2000 word blog posts on Apple minutia purely on the strength and clarity of his writing. This…

Perhaps we could have a competition here? Some childish teenagers likely flirted by nudging each other, pulling each other's hair to get attention or flicking elastic bands at each other.

Neither of them wore an Apple Watch.

Quite poignant.

(I didn't do these things btw).

Re: The Apple Watch

#179
post #21

Gruber's scenario with the two high school kids sending each other love taps, scribbles, and heartbeats was poignant. While the Apple Watch isn't for me, I can't begrudge those who decide to buy one. I think back to the late 90s and how I wouldn't have met my wife if not for IMing a screenname a mutual friend of ours passed along to me. The internet, a crappy eMachines desktop, and AIM made this possible. Technically…

That love taps scenario also required you to have your crush in your contacts. I think that part was kind of glossed over.

Yeah, and hopefully weren't using an Android device?
Post reply on HN