Live data from Hacker News

Audacity 4.0

github.com

171–180 of 278 posts

Re: Audacity 4.0

#171
post #59

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Someone mentions it here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49549040 https://tenacityaudio.org Seem like they have a few commit every week. 32 Issues closed in a year: https://codeberg.org/tenacityteam/tenacity/activity/yearly Looks healthy?

I know it's not a proper metric to judge by, but Tenacity is 10k commits behind Audacity. That's quite a lot to get behind since the split. I'd be interested if Tenacity is actively developed or pretty much just maintaining the software from where they split.

If for your use case v3 or equivalent is essentially feature complete, just getting bug fixes is plenty sufficient.

Re: Audacity 4.0

#172
post #83

Earlier quoted context omitted.

He is pro age-verification with government IDs, what do you expect?

Did he state this in a video somewhere? I checked a couple biography pages but didn't see this specifically called out.

https://x.com/Tantacrul/status/2092817255205622121

https://archive.ph/LFfO1

Re: Audacity 4.0

#173

Earlier quoted context omitted.

He is pro age-verification with government IDs, what do you expect?

Please cite this if it's true. As far as I can tell they're updating the much dated UX from being stuck in the 90's and are making great strides on the app. I'm fine with them making money as they're investing into a utility I use.

See my other reply

Re: Audacity 4.0

#174
post #154

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The fundamental problem in music notation is that it was designed for an 8 note system and we use a 12 note system. It's.. fine I guess, they got those extra four notes in there and millions of people read music with no problems. But it does create a lot of confusion for novice readers who now think those 8 notes are somehow more important than the other 4 or that the sharps and flats are somehow half notes(they are…

To sum up: you don’t like the current notation system, terminology and piano keys but also don’t have anything else to add to the discussion other than “I don’t like it”.

It is sort of like english spelling, we all know spelling in english sucks(So pointlessly difficult we have contests centered around the skill), we also all know we can do nothing to fix it. Still gonna complain about it however.

Re: Audacity 4.0

#175
post #9

I highly recommend this video [1] by the Head of Software at Muse who had a big part in the development of Audacity 4.0. Some great insights and really fun to watch! [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QYM3TWf_G38

Yes, Tantacrul. Pretty weird story, a composer and programmer who absolutely roasted the UIs of well known sheet music dinosaurs Finale and Sibelius in hilarious diss videos on YouTube. Then he conceded a bit reluctantly that Musescore was the better of the lot, but still had plenty of opinions on how it could be better. So the guitar tabs website which had then recently acquired Musescore offered him a job. Not just…

MuseScore and Ultimate Guitar unfortunately both have some dark patterns around subscriptions and data collection. But yeah very weird situation

Re: Audacity 4.0

#177
post #9

I highly recommend this video [1] by the Head of Software at Muse who had a big part in the development of Audacity 4.0. Some great insights and really fun to watch! [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QYM3TWf_G38

I don't even need to watch that video to be reminded of the tagline - "Audacity says no!". Agreed this is a great watch for pretty much any developer.

Re: Audacity 4.0

#178
post #9

I highly recommend this video [1] by the Head of Software at Muse who had a big part in the development of Audacity 4.0. Some great insights and really fun to watch! [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QYM3TWf_G38

I don't even need to watch that video to be reminded of the tagline - "Audacity says no!". Agreed this is a great watch for pretty much any developer.

Quit Sibelius

Re: Audacity 4.0

#179
post #174

Earlier quoted context omitted.

To sum up: you don’t like the current notation system, terminology and piano keys but also don’t have anything else to add to the discussion other than “I don’t like it”.

It is sort of like english spelling, we all know spelling in english sucks(So pointlessly difficult we have contests centered around the skill), we also all know we can do nothing to fix it. Still gonna complain about it however.

Sorta, except the video has many examples where folks tried to improve, but they ended up with more shortcomings than solutions.

Ultimately standard notation is still the best we have.

Post reply on HN