Live data from Hacker News

Dutch suicide prevention website shares data with tech companies without consent

nltimes.nl

171–180 of 195 posts

Re: Dutch suicide prevention website shares data with tech companies without consent

#171
post #162

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Existence, where you're just thrown out there to sink or swim and that's thats. If you're lucky you have parents and/or friends who can help you. If you're not, well... good luck!

Is that reaction to Dutch, German or French social support? Cause all three provide serious support and are the west.

I didn't think that in Netherlands, Germany or France you can live like a normal person if you are, say, depressed or addicted to drugs and don't want to or can't work.

Re: Dutch suicide prevention website shares data with tech companies without consent

#172
post #162

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Is that reaction to Dutch, German or French social support? Cause all three provide serious support and are the west.

I didn't think that in Netherlands, Germany or France you can live like a normal person if you are, say, depressed or addicted to drugs and don't want to or can't work.

You have no idea what you’re talking about.

Re: Dutch suicide prevention website shares data with tech companies without consent

#173
post #151

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What's the absolute worst thing Google could be doing with that analytics data?

Sell it to insurance companies, employers? Use it to target ads of snake oil to vulnerable people?

Sell what to insurance companies?

All they have is that there was a hit from an IP at a specific date and time. Any cookies they set will let them tell that the same browser came back an hour later - but won't let them join traffic together across multiple sites.

Re: Dutch suicide prevention website shares data with tech companies without consent

#174

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Involuntary commitment. Happened to a good friend of mine during a nasty divorce, the husband made up a suicidal story and my friend was committed without the court appointing her a lawyer to defend herself. She's struggling to get her rights back, it is apparently possible, but they're gone forever until you spend a lot of money on lawyers so it's true it's not strictly the case you can't get them back but they defa…

Just curious, but did this person have a history of emotional lability plus previous (voluntary) outpatient treatment?

This is just another form of stigma. Better to go without getting treated for mental health issues, or that very responsible decision to seek treatment will be used against you later.

See also the jump seat pilot who tried to pull the fire handles on a commercial flight.

Re: Dutch suicide prevention website shares data with tech companies without consent

#175

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I saw a LinkedIn thread just the other day that called it the "suicide prevention industrial complex," and that phrase will stick in my head like "orphan crushing machine" or "leopards eating faces"

What on earth is the "industrial complex" part about this? Outside of pharma pushing pills I'm not sure what other profit-seeking, recursive elements exist in the "suicide prevention industry". Legitimately curious about this - not sure how these words would apply.

I would much rather the suicide-prevention people become rich than the infinite-scroll advertising guys.

Re: Dutch suicide prevention website shares data with tech companies without consent

#176
post #115

"How many people came to our contact page, but left without calling the hotline?" "Don't know, boss. We'd need to add analytics." "Like what?" "Google Analytics? It's free and pretty much universal." "Ok, do it." It's just standard. Not great, and Google uses the data in all sorts of ways that they don't make obvious. But it's not a cabal of evil website owners selling data to tech giants. They're just trying to run…

At some point we have to get used to the idea that there are no such thing as free services. If you're not paying for something that clearly has a cost to the entity providing it, then value will be extracted from you in other ways.

> If you're not paying for something that clearly has a cost to the entity providing it, then value will be extracted from you in other ways.

Then we should get used to the idea that even when you're paying a lot of money for something the entity taking your money will still do everything and anything to extract even more value from you including collecting and selling your data, remotely disabling features of the thing you paid for so they can start charging you a monthly fee to get them back, aggressively infesting the product with ads, pushing updates that degrade the service to incentivize you to upgrade, etc.

The greed of companies and their shareholders will never be satisfied so ultimately what we need are real consumer protections in the form of powerful regulation and enforcement.

Re: Dutch suicide prevention website shares data with tech companies without consent

#177
post #73

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don't think that's the right way to consider your odds of involuntary committal. It really depends on what you say in the calls. The more immediate and serious the danger the more likely you are to be involuntary committed. The caller range is quite large.

So that means you have to watch what you say if you call such a line. That seems risky enough to discourage me from calling if I were in such a state.

Would you rather not try to help the people that obviously need help?

Re: Dutch suicide prevention website shares data with tech companies without consent

#178
post #115

Earlier quoted context omitted.

At some point we have to get used to the idea that there are no such thing as free services. If you're not paying for something that clearly has a cost to the entity providing it, then value will be extracted from you in other ways.

> If you're not paying for something that clearly has a cost to the entity providing it, then value will be extracted from you in other ways. Then we should get used to the idea that even when you're paying a lot of money for something the entity taking your money will still do everything and anything to extract even more value from you including collecting and selling your data, remotely disabling features of the th…

I agree. I'm not defending the current state of affairs by any means.

Re: Dutch suicide prevention website shares data with tech companies without consent

#179
post #47

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The hotline is isn't "selling" the data. The hotline installed analytics software to help them do their job. Do "non-Western culture have a better solution to suicidality?

A quick sweep of the lowest 20 countries in suicide and the most obvious thing that can be teased out is they're by vast majority extremely conservative societies where family and religion (mostly Islam) would likely dominate the goals of any person living there (with a couple exceptions). Only about half of the lowest 10 have any sort of functional welfare or state support programs. I wonder if having a pretty rigid…

What really happens is that nobody counts the suicides and they are reclassified as accidental deaths.

When the Netherlands was still Christian we did this too.

Re: Dutch suicide prevention website shares data with tech companies without consent

#180
post #177

Earlier quoted context omitted.

So that means you have to watch what you say if you call such a line. That seems risky enough to discourage me from calling if I were in such a state.

Would you rather not try to help the people that obviously need help?

What if the help they need is just to talk to someone without fear of consequences?

If they dispatch you to an institution you could lose your job just when you need money to pay for the bills you'll be sent.

With some careers, like being a pilot, you'd never be be to find another job.

You'd lose your ability to take out life insurance (even if it was a short temporary depression that you got over, like a side effect of a medication, the life insurance companies won't care.)

Or the institution's records could be hacked and you'll live in fear of your friends and family finding out.. which could cause rebound suicidal ideation...

There is no way I would ever call these hotlines unless it were 100% anonymous.

Post reply on HN