Live data from Hacker News

AI-generated “workslop” is destroying productivity?

hbr.org

171–180 of 184 posts

Re: AI-generated “workslop” is destroying productivity?

#171
post #52

Earlier quoted context omitted.

A pilot has ultimate authority of how a plane is flown, because it's their ass in the fire if the plane can't land. If you're a low-level office drone, you are not a pilot.

Embody a slave mindset

Or we’ll import people who will.

Re: AI-generated “workslop” is destroying productivity?

#172
post #169

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Duchamp played the status game of arbitrary signals as representations for high status. He's not a chaos agent. He's a relic of a generation trying to get into galleries and museums for status. It's not even close to meme-culture.

Ok, so Tyler Robinson is a sincere Dadaist in a way that the founders were not.

Flush out your headgear oldster. Dada was a status gain group in a hierarchical system. Meme-culture is 21st C non-linear chaos deep in horizontalization. Take your academic art history takes to plain English status seeing magazines.

Re: AI-generated “workslop” is destroying productivity?

#173
post #169

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Ok, so Tyler Robinson is a sincere Dadaist in a way that the founders were not.

Flush out your headgear oldster. Dada was a status gain group in a hierarchical system. Meme-culture is 21st C non-linear chaos deep in horizontalization. Take your academic art history takes to plain English status seeing magazines.

> Flush out your headgear oldster. Dada was a status gain group in a hierarchical system. Meme-culture is 21st C non-linear chaos deep in horizontalization. Take your academic art history takes to plain English status seeing magazines.

Just want to memorialize that. Calling it here.

Re: AI-generated “workslop” is destroying productivity?

#174
post #103

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It doesn't seem to even be about making metrics go up. It's about telling a narrative-reinforcing story: That AI is great. It's worth it. Leadership is right to be obsessed with it. I would have thought that in a fight between "fooling ourselves with a story" and "metrics go up" that the metrics would win, but it seems to not be the case.

Same thing happened to work from home. Meta straight up sabotaged the reason for it's own rebrand in service of it.

How do you mean?

Re: AI-generated “workslop” is destroying productivity?

#175
post #78

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Fair point, The thing about companies asking for slop is that a middle manager maintaining usual stream of vacuous text is a proxy for that person paying attention to a given set of problems and alerting others. AI becomes a problem because someone can maintain a vacuous text stream without that attention. So it's likely to become an arms-race.

> So it's likely to become an arms-race. And this is my real fear with the current crop of AI. That rather than improving the system to require less junk, we just use AI to generate junk and AI to parse AI-generated junk that another AI summarises ad infinitum… Like, instead of building a framework that reduces boilerplate code, we use an LLM to generate that boilerplate instead (in a more complex and confusing manne…

I think this may already be happening in job applications---companies using AI to parse them, applicants surely by now using AI to spew them out at increasing volume...

Re: AI-generated “workslop” is destroying productivity?

#176

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The nephew has no programming knowledge. He wants to build a website that will turn him into a bazillionaire. He asks AI how to solve problem X. AI provides direction, but he doesn't quite know how to ask the right questions. Still, the AI manages to give him a 70% solution. He will go to his grave before he learns enough programming to do the remaining 30% himself, or, understand the first 70%. Delegating to AI isn'…

Who is "the nephew"?

My nephew! :)

Re: AI-generated “workslop” is destroying productivity?

#177
My manager has Claude leave a two-page worthless comment on every single PR we submit, uses copilot to write 20-line "summaries" of 5-line changesets, and once sent my coworker and I a Claude-generated document that was so unclear in its purpose that we both replied "what even is this" after which the manager just ghosted the slack thread and pretended it never even happened.

I'm looking for a new job.

Re: AI-generated “workslop” is destroying productivity?

#178
post #174
post #103

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Same thing happened to work from home. Meta straight up sabotaged the reason for it's own rebrand in service of it.

How do you mean?

A return to the office mandate from a company that was not only selling augmented reality but specifically selling remote workplace themed augmented reality applications rather undermines the message.

Re: AI-generated “workslop” is destroying productivity?

#179
post #178
post #174

Earlier quoted context omitted.

How do you mean?

A return to the office mandate from a company that was not only selling augmented reality but specifically selling remote workplace themed augmented reality applications rather undermines the message.

Not really: Meta's overall brand was not in general about using AR headsets in the workplace, if you factor in IG and WA. Developing AR is not necessarily the same as using it for leisure let alone using it in the workplace, notwithstanding Meta's marketing claiming it could be used for that. (Are there any stats to show that business users in general ever believed Meta's marketing on AR? I'm not aware of any.)

Also, the RTO mandate can serve as a basis/pretext for layoffs and cost consolidation, although CXOs tend not to admit that directly.

Re: AI-generated “workslop” is destroying productivity?

#180

My manager has Claude leave a two-page worthless comment on every single PR we submit, uses copilot to write 20-line "summaries" of 5-line changesets, and once sent my coworker and I a Claude-generated document that was so unclear in its purpose that we both replied "what even is this" after which the manager just ghosted the slack thread and pretended it never even happened. I'm looking for a new job.

My manager is obsessed with AI agents. Thankfully he's leaving, so I don't have to look for a new job.
Post reply on HN