Live data from Hacker News

Xiaomi MiMo Reasoning Model

github.com

171–180 of 203 posts

Re: Xiaomi MiMo Reasoning Model

#171
post #152
post #143

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Thanks! I wonder where this discrepancy comes from

probably under-indexing of non-english sources by these crawlers. would be interesting if yandex opened some data sets!

And lots of people write on the web using English as a second language, which both reduces the presence of their native language and increases the presence of English.

Re: Xiaomi MiMo Reasoning Model

#172

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That's clearly a different question. It'd be possible for these models to be Mandarin-first while still supporting other languages, like American models are English-first while doing the same, but that's not what's happening.

> That's clearly a different question. It'd be possible for these models to be Mandarin-first while still supporting other languages What would a hypothetical "Mandarin-first" model look like to you? I challenge the notion that the current models are "English-first" - that is an unsubstantiated opinion not supported by fact. I bet, dollars to donuts, these models are SoTA in Mandarin as well. When framed that way, as…

> What would a hypothetical "Mandarin-first" model look like to you?

Given a language-agnostic prompt like "12 + 89", any explanatory text it outputs could be expected to be in Mandarin most of the time.

According to this test, Xiaomi's MiMo-7B-RL is an English-first model.

Re: Xiaomi MiMo Reasoning Model

#173
post #157

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> The most popular one, Baidu, is like garbage compared to Google search It must be very bad when you see the walking turd that Google search has become over the years…

It is. In Chinese speaking countries where there's google available, no one is using Baidu

Do any of those countries have a good relationship with China and/or countries from there?

Re: Xiaomi MiMo Reasoning Model

#174
post #155

The README says "RL" without specifying what kind of RL is used. Researchers: I know you are busy, and I know good writing takes time, but please don't skip this kind of detail.

I assume they mean "Reinforcement Learning", and it's been a decade since I studied AI in university, but isn't it perfectly valid to just say "RL"? What kind of specificity are you looking for, whether they used Q-Learning or some other algorithm?

Re: Xiaomi MiMo Reasoning Model

#176
post #71
post #65

Why are there so many English-first AI models from China? Are they not interested in serving their own population? Or is it that if they publish Chinese-first models it won't get publicity in the West?

All LLMs are trained on the same basic blob of data - mostly in English, mostly pirated books and stuff.

That's wrong.

Many LLMs are trained on synthetic data produced by other LLMs. (Indirectly, they may be trained on pirated books. Sure. But not directly.)

Re: Xiaomi MiMo Reasoning Model

#177
post #120
post #65

Why are there so many English-first AI models from China? Are they not interested in serving their own population? Or is it that if they publish Chinese-first models it won't get publicity in the West?

They are not "English-first". Deepseek-R1, for example, reasons in Chinese when you ask it a question in Chinese.

I've seen one of the ChatGPT models produce the occasional Chinese phrase even when otherwise reasoning in English about a problem given in English.

Re: Xiaomi MiMo Reasoning Model

#178
post #157

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It is. In Chinese speaking countries where there's google available, no one is using Baidu

Do any of those countries have a good relationship with China and/or countries from there?

Singapore has a pretty good relationship with China (with all Chinas, actually). And we have plenty of Chinese speakers, too. I'm not sure how prevalent Baidu is, however.

Re: Xiaomi MiMo Reasoning Model

#179
post #72
post #65

Why are there so many English-first AI models from China? Are they not interested in serving their own population? Or is it that if they publish Chinese-first models it won't get publicity in the West?

The mandarin language models obviously exist, but what would you do with them if they provided access to them? And what knowledge would be in them? What is the body of knowledge encoded in Mandarin? What does that look like? Sad reality is that not many outside of China have the facility with Mandarin to use those models. Even non-native Mandarin speakers who claim to be "fluent", are often messing up intended meanin…

> Even non-native Mandarin speakers who claim to be "fluent", are often messing up intended meaning in text. Or making literal translations that wind up making no sense.

Happens with English as well, but non-native speakers of English still benefit from these models.

Re: Xiaomi MiMo Reasoning Model

#180

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The pendulum already turned back. The current generation under 20 grew up with touchscreens. That obseletes input with pinyin; many don't care if the device has no keyboard.

> That obseletes input with pinyin Uh? Pinyin input is by far the most popular input technique in China. I rarely see anyone using handwriting input. That being said, it has nothing to do with English winning. It's just a Chinese input technique that uses the latin alphabet. English fluency in China is not very common, especially spoken English.

Just like German is written with almost the same alphabet as English, but that doesn't give you English fluency.
Post reply on HN