Live data from Hacker News

I Don't Have Spotify

github.com

171–180 of 391 posts

Re: I Don't Have Spotify

#171

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I find the user experience of Apple Music to be subpar, and keeps pushing young genres in which I have zero interest. I use Cider on my desktop but mobile is still a challenge.

On the other hand Spotify has literal porn on it along with Joe Rogan.

Then it's easy to see why Spotify is so popular in America these days...

Re: I Don't Have Spotify

#172

Huh, that looks very interesting. A friend of mine made a streaming service back in the day where you could paste in youtube links, they got downloaded, added to a playlist and then you could listen to that together with friends on multiple computers. I always wanted to rebuild that and adjust to my needs. Now this convert thing from the OP seems to be an interesting extension to that. Just paste in spotify links, gr…

The hoops to go through to have a ”legal” napster.

Also not sure yt-dlp is any more legal than just downloading mp3s.

Re: I Don't Have Spotify

#173

Huh, that looks very interesting. A friend of mine made a streaming service back in the day where you could paste in youtube links, they got downloaded, added to a playlist and then you could listen to that together with friends on multiple computers. I always wanted to rebuild that and adjust to my needs. Now this convert thing from the OP seems to be an interesting extension to that. Just paste in spotify links, gr…

The hoops to go through to have a ”legal” napster. Also not sure yt-dlp is any more legal than just downloading mp3s.

Obviously it's all just a dream in a fantasy world. And even in that fantasy world it would be for friends only, not anything commercial.

Edit: also we don't use mp3, we use free (tm) opus! (as in just yt-dlp -x )

Re: I Don't Have Spotify

#174
post #154

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Doesn't Spotify as well?

Not really. Spotify's "add your music" feature has always been an afterthought, it's clunky and inconvenient. It doesn't really store your files in Cloud, like Apple Music does; it just allows you to access local files per device.

>It doesn't really store your files in Cloud, like Apple Music does; it just allows you to access local files per device.

Perhaps things have changed, but 10 or so years ago I "uploaded" my music to Spotify and it didn't actually upload anything, nor did it play my local music.

Rather, spotify used whatever it had in its database with the same name/artist, which wasn't always the same recording or even the same song.

And then there were the ads. No thanks.

I have my own library of more than 22,000 tracks and use Winamp, Jellyfin and VLC to play them wherever I happen to be. No muss, no fuss, and most importantly, no ads.

Re: I Don't Have Spotify

#175

I know of a even more impressive website that will transfer playlists from Spotify (or 20 other platforms, including text files) to 20 other platforms or a text file. I will share the link, but don't hug it to death y'all. :) https://app.tunemymusic.com/transfer

I recently made a transition from Spotify to Tidal and found the suggested transfer service to do the job really clumsy. In my case I've transferred favorite artists and the service was just trying to match them by name which failed miserably when there was more than one with the same name - seemingly it picked one randomly. I wonder how this service would do.

Re: I Don't Have Spotify

#176

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Or this https://playlists.cloud/

Thanks for sharing! I didn't want to sign up for a monthly subscription to transfer my music...

I didn't even know TuneMyMusic had a premium service, but fwiw, it's free for the first 500 songs. I've only used it a few times and was pretty impressed at how many services it supports.

Re: I Don't Have Spotify

#177

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Anecdotally speaking, Spotify has become a sort of cultural default for a bunch of people. If you're in a DM or a group chat, you may not hear "You should listen to X by Y" but rather "Check this out: https://open.spotify.com/blah " At my current workplace and a previous one, both had Slack channels for sharing music and they were 99% Spotify links. Partly because of genuine Spotify usage but even not using Spotify a…

Spotify doesn't require you to create an account to hear a song from what I recall, so why wouldn't someone send you a link? That's what the web is for. That said once you have heard it on Spotify, yeah you might want it on your service provider of choice so as to add it to whatever equivalent of playlists there are.

You can just try any link in incognito mode to find out that is not true. Spotify is a walled garden

Re: I Don't Have Spotify

#178

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Apple Music = few users?? From what I could tell when choosing AM over Spotify, the latter has a lot of playlists for discovery and I would never use my streaming service for discovery as it encourages the service to promote music it is paid to promote. Of course AM is annoying too because 3 out of 5 navigation icons along the bottom of the UI are for discovery. But AM has Siri integration, which works some of the ti…

Apple Music also integrates with your own music library, which is the killer feature for me.

Beware of the full integration though. It deleted the files I had from my CDs and replaced it with the Apple Music version.

Some items now stay greyed out because they don’t have a license. And some versions got replaced (eg, to the remastered ones).

Re: I Don't Have Spotify

#179

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Apple Music = few users?? From what I could tell when choosing AM over Spotify, the latter has a lot of playlists for discovery and I would never use my streaming service for discovery as it encourages the service to promote music it is paid to promote. Of course AM is annoying too because 3 out of 5 navigation icons along the bottom of the UI are for discovery. But AM has Siri integration, which works some of the ti…

Apple Music has been utterly awful on desktop for years, with virtually zero positive progress. I made this angry video [1] 4 years ago, and have tried using Apple Music multiple times since then, and it never failed to disappoint. 1. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gE8ZikfrpFU

Oh my god you made this video? I have sent it to so many people to explain my feelings for it. Thank you so much for saying what I wanted to but so much better!

Re: I Don't Have Spotify

#180
post #132

This is a bit off-topic, but: am I just dim or could the README be a bit more informative? What it's for, who it's for, etc. (I'll give partial blame to me or github for the About section/link being there... it's offscreen by the start of the README, so I missed it) (I also... don't use spotify... so had less-than-average context to guess the purpose of this project with.)

the repository description sums it up already: Effortlessly convert Spotify links to your preferred streaming service

Honestly doesn't sum it up very well, given that it doesn't even mention that it's an extension.
Post reply on HN