Live data from Hacker News

Launch HN: Modern Realty (YC S24) – AI Real Estate Agent for Home Buyers

news.ycombinator.com

171–180 of 310 posts

Re: Launch HN: Modern Realty (YC S24) – AI Real Estate Agent for Home Buyers

#171

I think it’s a bit misguided in the pitch by too boldly trying to replace all buyer agents. A lot of what realtors offer, especially to first time buyers (~1/3), is emotional support and confidence/security for making the biggest financial decision in their lives. I don't believe an AI isn’t going to be able to do that. But if you’re a second+ time buyer, then I think it makes more sense.

I actually do believe that AI can make someone feel more comfortable with their purchase. Let's break down the communications that realtors currently do to comfort buyers (mostly over text, which is also how we communicate): Tell you comparably priced properties - we do this. Remind you the steps in the process - we do this. Tell you basic stats about local transactions (such as telling dejected buyers that only 1/6…

> we do this

Everything you've described could be achieved with a basic web app.

Not seeing what AI brings to the table here other than being a fake human that gives inaccurate advice ~5-10% of the time. Which seems risky when I am making the biggest financial decision of my life.

Re: Launch HN: Modern Realty (YC S24) – AI Real Estate Agent for Home Buyers

#172

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yes that's what Redfin does actually. And I'm sure a bunch of others.

Redfin only charges 1% if you both buy and sell with them within a window of time (365 days if I recall from our Redfin broker). I've used them exactly once on both the buy side and sell side, and I was not impressed. I would not use them again, even with the 1% vs a more traditional 5% broker fee.

They're a bit sneaky on this one too. You pay full when you buy, but then they only charge 1% when you sell. So you only save on the sell, pay full price for the buy.

Re: Launch HN: Modern Realty (YC S24) – AI Real Estate Agent for Home Buyers

#173

I don't see anyone asking the question that to me is the elephant in the room: How are you preventing hallucinations and plainly false information being sent to buyers engaging in what's likely to be one of the largest financial decisions of their life? Beyond just leading to a bad UX, what's your legal exposure there? You mention providing comps, there's a LOT of local knowledge that goes into that. How are you auto…

Our goal is not to rewrite every property description, but rather just link you the properties that we think you would like. If a property is mis-listed on Zillow, then that would be the same issue if a Realtor would send you that property as a recommendation

Re: Launch HN: Modern Realty (YC S24) – AI Real Estate Agent for Home Buyers

#174

I personally know Raffi, he was my roommate in college. If ever there was a CEO you wanted to back (or someone to help you buy a home), he is it. Some highlights: - Not from a wealthy background, he got where he is due to hard work. -Paid his share of the rent by trading stocks. -He bought a used SUV off of Craigslist and negotiated the price down by almost 90%, afterwards the seller smiled and said something akin to…

:)

Re: Launch HN: Modern Realty (YC S24) – AI Real Estate Agent for Home Buyers

#175

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Our pricing is negotiable. What we're seeing so far is that >95% of homes are still offering full 2.4% buyer agent concessions in the bay area. Our main service is our texting service which you would text as if it was a normal realtor and it can get you market comparisons, schedule tours by texting agents, asking about if there's offers on homes, etc. Blockers for getting humans out of the loop is primarily just user…

> MVP has completed 1 escrow via text bot, we got paid 27k, another home went into escrow yesterday, 35 clients touring homes with us. We registered with our real estate brokerage in July. That's amazing traction! Congratulations! How much manual intervention did these first couple of sales take? Are you using your own local/hosted model and fine tuning or otherwise incrementally improving it?

For the escrow transaction, were you the buyer or sellers agent?

Re: Launch HN: Modern Realty (YC S24) – AI Real Estate Agent for Home Buyers

#177
post #142

It is important for some company to make home buying better. Even outside of the pain of unaffordability, it is an utterly broken process. Advent of LLMs do give hope that this process can be imporoved signifiantly. Fun fact: I met Raymond and Raffi a long time ago and discouraged from going into this area. But now, I am glad they did. Their conviction is inspiring. If Turbo tax can make it possible for a person to f…

> If Turbo tax can make it possible for a person to file taxes

Which is a 40 year old piece of software.

And during these decades we've had with NLP and basic rule engines the ability to answer questions about the buying process. So not sure what innovations LLMs are bringing to the table here.

Re: Launch HN: Modern Realty (YC S24) – AI Real Estate Agent for Home Buyers

#178

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If there was a serious opportunity to arbitrage under the 6% fee, you bet that someone would have done it already — and well before the AI era.

This is the thing, the NAR settlement didn’t really change anything, the fee was always negotiable and there always were agents who would offer under 6%. They were typically scummy agents who didn’t last long (they popped up when real estate was hot then disappeared after they burned enough clients and/or the market cooled off). As in all things you will get what you pay for. I’m not interested in fighting with anyon…

* All agents are not created equal

* A good agent is absolutely worth it

People aren't really arguing against these things. I don't get it, if the settlement didn't really change anything, why is everyone making such a fuss about it?

My other question is, is there a linear correlation between effort to sell a home and its price? Is a 3 million dollar home 3x the effort to sell over a 1 million dollar home? Because I pay 3x the money to sell it...or am I paying for the "connections"?

Re: Launch HN: Modern Realty (YC S24) – AI Real Estate Agent for Home Buyers

#179

I don't see anyone asking the question that to me is the elephant in the room: How are you preventing hallucinations and plainly false information being sent to buyers engaging in what's likely to be one of the largest financial decisions of their life? Beyond just leading to a bad UX, what's your legal exposure there? You mention providing comps, there's a LOT of local knowledge that goes into that. How are you auto…

Our goal is not to rewrite every property description, but rather just link you the properties that we think you would like. If a property is mis-listed on Zillow, then that would be the same issue if a Realtor would send you that property as a recommendation

> How are you preventing hallucinations and plainly false information being sent to buyers

You must have missed this part of the question.

Seems pretty important.

Re: Launch HN: Modern Realty (YC S24) – AI Real Estate Agent for Home Buyers

#180

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Appreciate the support. We aren't necessarily trying to uproot the industry, just want to deliver a better buying experience. People deserve agents who go out and do a lot of the work for them. Our goal is to do everything we think a real estate agent should do. Lots of value to be provided.

Aaah, but can it show you into a room with a toilet, sink, shower and bath in it and tell you "This is the bathroom"? If not, you'll never unseat the seasoned professionals of the UK real estate sector ;)

Neither can an AI.

The whole point of real estate agents is that as a seller I don't trust my house being open to any random buyer.

Post reply on HN