Live data from Hacker News

MeTube: Self-hosted YouTube downloader

github.com

171–173 of 173 posts

Re: MeTube: Self-hosted YouTube downloader

#171
post #147

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> inrerchangeable https://youryoure.com/?inrerchangeable

This is obviously a typo. Which can't be said about deliberately inserting an apostrophe into a word

You assume it is deliberate. It's more likely that it was a simple mistake.

Re: MeTube: Self-hosted YouTube downloader

#172

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This is obviously a typo. Which can't be said about deliberately inserting an apostrophe into a word

You assume it is deliberate. It's more likely that it was a simple mistake.

They keystroke that produced the apostrophe was deliberable. The keystroke that produced not the letter I wanted was not

Re: MeTube: Self-hosted YouTube downloader

#173

Earlier quoted context omitted.

yt-dlp is not even necessary. If just downloading videos from YouTube this can be done with much less code and complexity. I use a tiny C program to do it. Tiny shell scripts work just as well. What no one is discussing is that yt-dlp can no longer download itag 22 and itag 18 is now throttled.^1 This means yt-dlp has to download an audio file and a video file and use ffmpeg to merge the two. YouTube ad revenue just…

> yt-dlp is not even necessary. If just downloading videos from YouTube this can be done with much less code and complexity. I use a tiny C program to do it. Tiny shell scripts work just as well. yt-dlp is not necessary ... if you write a replacement? Ok. Besides I doubt simple shell scripts will be able to download all videos that yt-dlp can. YouTube does not use the same protections for all videos.

"Besides I doubt simple shell scripts will be able to download all videos that yt-dlp can."

You are free to doubt but the the truth is yes they can.

The only ones that are complicated are commercial videos.

Give me a list of videos you are downloading with yt-dlp and I will show you how to dowload the same videos without yt-dlp. I have been doing so for many years. Unless you are only downloading commercial videos, e.g., VEVO crap. Personally I am not interested in those videos.

I am actually liking this YouTube change getting rid of or throttling video with pre-muxed audio. Now I download only the audio. If I like it, then I download the video and mux. For many videos, there is no meaningful video; it is just slideshows of images or animations. For me, audio-only is faster and more space-efficient. I am avoiding downloading many videos because in many cases the audio is enough.

Post reply on HN