Live data from Hacker News

How Home Assistant is being used to protect from missile and drone attacks

denysdovhan.com

171–180 of 191 posts

Re: How Home Assistant is being used to protect from missile and drone attacks

#171
post #142

Earlier quoted context omitted.

US ships and aircraft stay in international waters and airspace near China, or in the territorial waters and airspace of allies who give it permission. That includes the Taiwan strait. Allowing China to prevent US or other aircraft to operate in such international waters or airspace would amount to giving them control over it, which is why it’s important to have regular freedom of navigation sailings and flights. Chi…

I see because the US border is near there? Not on the other side of the Pacific Ocean. Anyone familiar with history, recall that Mexico was bigger? Did the Chinese get involved in that conflict? I guess what we are saying is they should have to stop an aggressor annexing territory? Oh wait, but that was actual land, where as the annexing you are talking about is ocean… ocean that the US has filled with military bases…

So countries may only send their aircraft and ships along their own border now? Anyone is free to operate in international waters. And, yes, Chinese military ships do at times sail just outside US territorial waters to monitor naval exercises.

It’s quite telling that the examples you have to bring up of the US annexing territory are from over a century ago, before we had developed modern concepts of international law. We’re supposed to be past the era of annexation by force.

The area that China is annexing is not empty ocean, it’s a set of islands that belong to other nations, like the Philippines. Those are not theirs to take, and it’s a breach of international law, but their military power and UNSC veto means they can get away with it.

And, no, the conflict is not because of US activity. It’s because China, as it quite openly states in various forms including its doctrines, believes it has the right to regional hegemony over neighbouring countries. They, in turn, obviously don’t want that, so they’ve invited the US in as an ally. None of those are ‘aggressor’ moves toward China, because even the largest US military facilities in the area only have sufficient forces for defensive actions, not for an attack on mainland China.

The US didn’t invade Korea, it was part of a United Nations force protecting South Korea from attack by the north. It invaded Japan after being attacked first at Pearl Harbor. It was invited into South Vietnam, at the time under attack from North Vietnam. Laos I’ll give you, that was illegal and unacceptable. The US has never invaded China, it had a post-war force at the request of the then-government to disarm and repatriate the remainder of the Imperial Japanese Army from Manchuria. Similarly, it liberated the Philippines from the Japanese and immediately restored its pre-war democratic government. That’s not an ‘invasion’ as you cast it.

Of course of this is to say the US has always done good or is perfect. Far from it. But your whataboutism and insistence that China has done no wrong is ridiculous.

In the past two decades alone China has been in border disputes and land grabs with nearly all its neighbours, encroaching on territory in India, Bhutan, and the South China Sea. This should not be considered acceptable either.

Re: How Home Assistant is being used to protect from missile and drone attacks

#172

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This is a significant mistelling of the history of the German "Enigma" device. Significant usage of Enigma was done during the war in a manner that was secure enough to prohibit interception. Turing's methods are brilliant as are the contributions of numerous other cryptographers. They relied on numerous operational failures of some branches of the military to be possible. So it was not from "the Germans", but from s…

I'm not sure what you mean. They used daily weather reports to decrypt the enigma for that day, so I'm not sure how that is an operational failure. If you know part of the cleartext, it's possible to brute-force any encryption given enough time. https://www.accuweather.com/en/weather-news/how-british-cryp... gives a pretty decent summary.

You're mentioning one technique as if it was the comprehensive method of compromising the Enigma. It was not. The example you give would only work for the Kriegsmarine transmissions for example. The Luftwaffe had its own system with its own operational failings.

Re: How Home Assistant is being used to protect from missile and drone attacks

#173
post #76

Fascinating use of HomeAssistant. He mentioned uptime monitor in the next section - I wonder what he uses to ensure it stays online? I would guess some sort of UPS or battery backup.

Most of us have something in place since the winter of 2022 when the power outages were systematic due to russian strikes on civilians and infrastructure, amplified by lack of air defence. Most of us needed to work though so some got UPS, EcoFlows, generators, solar systems, even DIY batteries if the budget is low. This year it's more of the same.

What DIY batteries? Have you considered the new sodium/aluminum battery type? I am wondering if that battery could be easy to DIY because sodium and aluminum are cheap and available.

Re: How Home Assistant is being used to protect from missile and drone attacks

#174
post #159
post #154

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This is just military production. It's like the growth you have when a hurricane destroys a city and you have to rebuilt it. It doesn't accumulate, it's just a waste. BTW look up North Korean economy growth after the war :) North Korea was always the rich part. It was developing so fast after the war. And somehow now the South Korea has Samsung and Kia and Subaru, and North Korea has starvation. https://www.researchg…

North Korea was totally isolated from the world economy after the Soviet Union fell. The only economic bloc which cut Russia off was American allies and there's nothing Russia gets from them which can't be supplied elsewhere. Russia switched from buying German cars to buying Chinese cars and changed the logo on their McDonalds and Starbucks branches. They now have access to inferior imitation brie and french wine is…

USSR and China were sanctioned as well during the cold war. There was intentional difference in how they were sanctioned to cause them to split off.

Both of these things worked as intended, causing USSR and China to work against each other and ultimately causing USSR to collapse. USSR was growing faster than the west early on. By 80s its economy was barely working.

It just takes time. Russia is in much worse starting condition already than USSR was in 70s, it is more isolated, it has less allies, it's further behind in tech.

If you want to believe Russia is doing fine, go ahead, it's just a very weird take.

Re: How Home Assistant is being used to protect from missile and drone attacks

#175
post #76

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Most of us have something in place since the winter of 2022 when the power outages were systematic due to russian strikes on civilians and infrastructure, amplified by lack of air defence. Most of us needed to work though so some got UPS, EcoFlows, generators, solar systems, even DIY batteries if the budget is low. This year it's more of the same.

What DIY batteries? Have you considered the new sodium/aluminum battery type? I am wondering if that battery could be easy to DIY because sodium and aluminum are cheap and available.

DIY batteries here are usually battery banks assembled from Chinese LiFePo4 cells, plus a Chinese BMS.

Re: How Home Assistant is being used to protect from missile and drone attacks

#177
post #147

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Because UN approved it.

On false pretenses, such as the presence of WMD.

Presence of WMD was an excuse for Iraq war.

Intervention in Afghanistan was a response to 9/11.

Re: How Home Assistant is being used to protect from missile and drone attacks

#178
post #177

Earlier quoted context omitted.

On false pretenses, such as the presence of WMD.

Presence of WMD was an excuse for Iraq war. Intervention in Afghanistan was a response to 9/11.

Apologies, I was thinking of Iraq, not Afghanistan.

Re: How Home Assistant is being used to protect from missile and drone attacks

#179
post #166
post #140

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Taiwan is not building cities on the islands. China is. They’re also attacking Philippines vessels that come nearby

What's the difference? Do you mean that Taiwan's claim is purely on paper and they actually admit it's Philippines territory because they did nothing to vessels around? Also, according to Wikipedia page [1]: > The Republic of China (ROC), which ruled Mainland China before 1949 and has been confined to Taiwan since 1949, also claims all of the Spratly Islands. and under "Military occupations": > Occupied by Taiwan (RO…

Go away. We’re talking about actually being aggressive. Claiming territory is not equivalent to shooting vessels from other countries. Only China is.

Re: How Home Assistant is being used to protect from missile and drone attacks

#180

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don't think that would be stable. No war means losing the ability to fight which means eventually it'll be easy enough for just one small group to attack somebody much bigger but weaker. If war is solved by all attacked countries surrendering immediately so one aggressor rules the world, I'm sure factions would emerge within it who are competing for power again. Maybe a solution could come from some defensive techn…

The risk of war between sacramento and san fransisco is zero. I don’t see why we can’t make that true for the world over one day.

That's because there's a common government that's more powerful than both of them and will stop any such war. But that common government still has to maintain its power with an army that can function.

Obviously civil wars happen all the time in places where there isn't a single powerful enough government to keep them suppressed.

Maybe you want one world government or a military alliance that includes every country and they all fight against any local wars no matter what. But what happens if some big enough group feels (or is) oppressed by that government and tries to fight it? Oppression by the majority forever is better than independence for anyone?

Post reply on HN