> Leaders work every day to create a safer, more productive, higher performing, more diverse, and more just work environment. They lead with empathy, have fun at work, and make it easy for others to have fun. Leaders ask themselves: Are my fellow employees growing? Are they empowered? Are they ready for what’s next? Leaders have a vision for and commitment to their employees’ personal success, whether that be at Amazon or elsewhere.
Amazon doesn't 'employ' drivers, but hired firms to prevent them from unionizing
171–180 of 431 posts
Re: Amazon doesn't 'employ' drivers, but hired firms to prevent them from unionizing
#172Earlier quoted context omitted.
Humans are all humans. Irrespective of their income level. Not sure what minimum wage has to do with whether or not being polite and pleasant conversation is exchanged.
Politeness and respect is sadly a service in the world of consumer-facing business, which means the amount of it that you get is going to correspond with how much you pay and how much the server is willing to give away for free. If the argument is that politeness should be a free service, same as a bathroom and drinking water, then just be mindful of the quality of said bathroom and water relative to the amount the e…
Re: Amazon doesn't 'employ' drivers, but hired firms to prevent them from unionizing
#173Earlier quoted context omitted.
This sounds like just the opposite of a capitalist monopoly from the other side. Why would I want any party to control the way a market works? You'll get stagnation both ways. see many historical examples where both monopolies and unions refused change and were overturned, leading to failures. i.e. Detroit I want a functioning competitive market where workers and firms compete and have to adjust and innovate to fit w…
But the problem is that the labor "market" has many weird inefficiencies not found in the usual "buyer X selling widget Y" model of the free market. For example, the poorer you are the less elasticity you have in your labor "product"; by the mere necessity of paying rent and buying food you have to accept virtually any offer that comes your way. On the other hand, employers often negotiate from a position of substant…
So I agree that while exploitation by monopolies is possible (in the extreme, just via slavery or indentured servitude/debt peonage), I think we have mostly taken care of it via social support mechanisms. If that's true, then further intervention in markets doesn't seem necessary. Of course, I still would support health inspections, etc to root out local corruption since it's too hard for the public to monitor that themselves. In a sense, the fact that voters approve the FDA and other inspection-style measures is just them commissioning someone to do that for them, and that's okay.
But when it comes to California coming in and saying that Uber drivers shouldn't be allowed to voluntarily work as contractors, it seems really strange. Drivers like it and the company likes it, so what's the problem? Yet the state still wants to intervene in the relationship.
Re: Amazon doesn't 'employ' drivers, but hired firms to prevent them from unionizing
#174Earlier quoted context omitted.
Please don’t frame your personal disinterest in discussing subjective viewpoints that contradict your own, as though everyone at HN becomes disinterested in discussing subjective viewpoints once disagreement occurs. HN users regularly discuss conflicting subjective cultural norms and expectations: when discussing Linux window managers, emacs, tabs versus spaces, the expectations of junior engineers in a startup, how…
> as though everyone at HN becomes disinterested in discussing subjective viewpoints once disagreement occurs. Except you didn't present your viewpoint as subjective, did you? No, like many of the other folks participating in this thread, you delivered it as objective truth: > “Unsmiling” is not “unprofessional”. > Smiling isn’t about courtesy, respect, or professionalism Now in fairness, I'm not sure you even realiz…
All descriptions of cultural norms are opinion by definition. Cultural ‘norms’ are, themselves, vastly more complex and interesting than any single statement can declare. Editorial word choice is necessary to express and discuss those perceived norms, and care must be taken to not overstate a viewpoint. I appreciate your concern, however. Thank you for taking the time to express it.
Re: Amazon doesn't 'employ' drivers, but hired firms to prevent them from unionizing
#175I'm always amazed at the stark differences between UPS drivers, and Amazon drivers. UPS trucks are always clean. They follow the rules of the road. The drivers wear neat uniforms, they walk on the sidewalks, they're polite, they're just professionals held to a higher standard. Then there are Amazon drivers. They park blocking half the road, music blasting, the vans usually look like they haven't been washed in a mont…
Amazon trucks at least are smaller.
Re: Amazon doesn't 'employ' drivers, but hired firms to prevent them from unionizing
#176Earlier quoted context omitted.
> Is there something "weird" about that? No, absolutely not, and you can put down the superiority complex. There is something weird though. Getting service from those minimum wage workers is not enough: people also demand their fake pleasure to serve and sympathy.
Amazon delivery drivers make around $20/hr. that's well above the federal minimum (about 7.50) and above all state minimums. it won't make you rich, but it's not minimum. https://www.usatoday.com/story/money/careers/2022/10/24/how-... Also, expecting friendly service is reasonable. Expecting poor service because the pay is low is backwards. We should expect better pay.
Re: Amazon doesn't 'employ' drivers, but hired firms to prevent them from unionizing
#177I'm always amazed at the stark differences between UPS drivers, and Amazon drivers. UPS trucks are always clean. They follow the rules of the road. The drivers wear neat uniforms, they walk on the sidewalks, they're polite, they're just professionals held to a higher standard. Then there are Amazon drivers. They park blocking half the road, music blasting, the vans usually look like they haven't been washed in a mont…
When I've been outside and received the package directly, I never felt any disrespect in either direction.
How many other countries have Amazon drivers? Is it the same there?
Re: Amazon doesn't 'employ' drivers, but hired firms to prevent them from unionizing
#178I'm always confused by the framing of these articles. Are companies supposed to help unions form against them? If they supported unionization efforts, why not just save everyone the time and money and listen to employee demands without one? It's like, you can love your wife as much as anyone, but you are not expected to help her get her own divorce attorney. Yeah, companies are going to be against unionizing. That's…
Your analogy doesn't work even if you also include the fact that the husband has been abusing his wife as much as possible without getting caught. What they are doing is making an active effort to make sure the wife can't get to an attorney at all.
I truly don't understand how so many can side with this abstract concept of a profit-seeking machine over human needs.
Poor Amazon might have to reduce their profits by 0.00001% to allow workers to pee while driving!
Re: Amazon doesn't 'employ' drivers, but hired firms to prevent them from unionizing
#179I'm always amazed at the stark differences between UPS drivers, and Amazon drivers. UPS trucks are always clean. They follow the rules of the road. The drivers wear neat uniforms, they walk on the sidewalks, they're polite, they're just professionals held to a higher standard. Then there are Amazon drivers. They park blocking half the road, music blasting, the vans usually look like they haven't been washed in a mont…
"lazily toss a package on the porch and walk away" I tried to help an Amazon driver by taking the package from him at the edge of my driveway. He stopped me, told me he had to take a photo of it sitting on my property first. He was very serious about this. I doubt this behavior is from these contracted drivers unless the photo requirement is new and your experience is not.
My guess is this is just a difference in contracting companies and not anything specific to how Amazon contracts the work out in the first place.
Re: Amazon doesn't 'employ' drivers, but hired firms to prevent them from unionizing
#180Earlier quoted context omitted.
Wait, UPS fucking sucks though. Amazon drivers make a attempt to hide packages, UPS tosses it 10 feet over the gate and mark it delivered in person.
> Amazon drivers make a attempt to hide packages, UPS tosses it 10 feet over the gate and mark it delivered in person. The only driver I've actually caught throwing a fragile, expensive package was an Amazon driver, but I’m going to guess that the variation between different individual drivers and teams (and contracted firms, in Amazon’s case) is probably bigger than that between which big co they are delivering for…
I would hope this is obvious but clearly not based on this entire thread.