Live data from Hacker News

Coinbase outages

coinbase.com

171–180 of 310 posts

Re: Coinbase outages

#171
post #98

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Or acquire it the same way you presumably acquire USD: work and get paid in it. Kinda weird you left that out but mentioned stealing, although I suppose ransomware is top of mind these days.

> acquire USD Are you saying Bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies are inherently gold-backed like the USD?

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gold_standard covers its abandonment, including by USD

Re: Coinbase outages

#172

I was shocked the other day on the Ethereum PoS announcement by the energy consumption per transaction metrics. It threw the whole crypto market into a new light for me. BTC is using over a megawatt hour PER transaction! That's almost 5000 miles in a Tesla model 3. BTC is using about 2/3 of the power of every data center on the planet! Many, many people have been imprisoned or executed for creating less societal harm…

I'm glad people are starting to realize this. I have been bashing bitcoin for this reason for ages only to be ridiculed.

Do you take a stance on hyperinflation events throughout history and it's victims?

Do you take a stance on security of untested POS coins gambling with people's money?

A senior Engineer once told me, "anyone can poke holes in an idea, we will make a change if they have a solution."

Re: Coinbase outages

#173

Earlier quoted context omitted.

>> Except Crypto isn’t regulated like stocks, Except that most of the time that means nothing in practice. Just look at the GME saga and you have customers liquidated, customers not being able to buy, some not even able to sell. And on top of that the CEO of Interactive Brokers setting a target price for the stock. All this so that few highly leveraged hedge funds can get away from the short squeeze cheaper along wit…

Except it doesn’t mean nothing because there are a bunch of lawsuits against Robinhood, because the law provides a remedy for the bullshit they pulled.

Like all the people who went to jail for the 2008 crisis?

Re: Coinbase outages

#174

I was shocked the other day on the Ethereum PoS announcement by the energy consumption per transaction metrics. It threw the whole crypto market into a new light for me. BTC is using over a megawatt hour PER transaction! That's almost 5000 miles in a Tesla model 3. BTC is using about 2/3 of the power of every data center on the planet! Many, many people have been imprisoned or executed for creating less societal harm…

Did you include the energy cost of building the car?

Re: Coinbase outages

#175
post #44

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Can you please point me a source where Bitcoin is "desired" as a payment method? It's seen more of a store of value, not used for paying for everyday things.

The "store of value" thing was made up to keep the speculation bubble inflating when it became clear Bitcoin had no practical use.

Isn't the revisionist history amazing? All of the other use cases (e.g. smart contracts) are proven failures and now the original use case (payment method) is also clearly a failure, so the narrative shifts to "it was never intended to be a payment method, only a store of value". A store of value that can drop 40% in days, BTW, another failed use case.

Re: Coinbase outages

#176

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Then you'll need to moralize air conditioning and entertainment and everything else too. These use cases aren't the problem, dirty energy is the problem. Fix the source of energy. We need to do that anyway. Bitcoin and the Nakamoto Consensus is a breakthrough that provides a secure, global, uncensorable, decentralized store of value. With defined rules that can't be changed on the whims of a central actor. The energy…

Military and banks do more than what PoW blockchain does. I don't buy in the energy argument myself, but trying to justify the way you do sounds a little too kool-aid-y.

Military is worse than POW.

Re: Coinbase outages

#177
This is not good - likely a shit ton of people withdrawing due to panic and Coinbase is having trouble covering. Only way to stop the bleeding is to hide behind "server troubles". It can't be a coincidence that all crypto currencies are on a downward spiral and Coinbase is down

Re: Coinbase outages

#178
post #96
post #66

Shaaaaady. The NYGA report on Tether is due today. Tether is completely insolvent, and once the rug is pulled, all of the exchanges are going to realize that all of their "stable" reserves are worthless and they can't pay out what they're storing for customers, and the price will tumble all the way down as there's a run on the pseudo-banks that can't payout. Or not, what do I know.

You do know that Coinbase has a $50k a day withdrawal limit? A lot of doomsday scenarios leave out this important detail when talking about a hypothetical bank run.

> You do know that Coinbase has a $50k a day withdrawal limit?

On the day you might think that limit matters, it's not really gonna matter.

Re: Coinbase outages

#180

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> BTC is using over a megawatt hour PER transaction! A transaction meaning transferring money from one wallet to another?

Nope - the author is incorrectly using total energy / total transactions to get this number. Which, is understandable. However, if there were 2x the transactions, the total energy would stay very close to the same. So no. There's a lot of energy to secure the network, but the actual energy usage per transaction itself is a small fraction of that misquoted number.

You are correct, but for the wrong reason. Bitcoin's energy consumption[1] does not track with the number of transactions[2]; energy consumption has significantly increased while the number of transactions has not. What the energy consumption does track is the price[3]: mining creates coins, so higher price means more mining. The current ~4% inflation rate will not significantly decrease incentives for decades.

In a sane world, the energy use and price would be tied to the actual usefulness of the currency. They are not. In roughly 100 years the energy use will be set by transaction fees and the number of transactions, but currently it's only proportional to speculative will.

When transaction fees incentivize mining, the incentive to mine will certainly be much lower. Arguably more secure, too- the block reward creates a separate incentive for large players to dominate mining, which lowers the diversity of miners. It's not at all clear that the absolute energy consumption will be lower than it currently is.

[1]: https://digiconomist.net/bitcoin-energy-consumption/ [2]: https://ycharts.com/indicators/bitcoin_transactions_per_day [3]: https://www.coindesk.com/price/bitcoin

Post reply on HN