Live data from Hacker News

KDE Plasma 5.20

kde.org

171–180 of 205 posts

Re: KDE Plasma 5.20

#171
post #23
post #17

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Apart from the clock I think its not too bad.

This is awful: https://i.imgur.com/gTf25am.png

I've just upgraded to 5.20 and the icons are slightly bigger than in the image. It doesn't look as harmonious as the Windows 10 sidebar, but the slight size increase makes a difference. All in all, it's an improvement over the previous list-style panel, because the information is easier to read.

Re: KDE Plasma 5.20

#172
post #41

I has been a decade since I used KDE. It was eating too much memory of slow computer. I always missed a desktop environment for power users, instead of one aiming for the average user. Kde always the best one with this objective

> I always missed a desktop environment for power users, instead of one aiming for the average user. What types of things make a big difference for you? When I sit at my computer, it's to do something in an application. The desktop environment doesn't do much for me once I've launched the program that I'm actually there to use, does it? I'm generally pretty happy in Ubuntu or Windows or macOS or iPadOS.

You're lucky to have a workflow that depends in just one application and one window, then.

Re: KDE Plasma 5.20

#173
Looking forward to try out the new tiling features of KWin when it gets released to Manjaro.

I've been trying to simulate the use of i3wm inside KDE for a while now, most of the online tutorials end up failing as some floating toolbar from KDE ends up grabbing focus and breaks the i3wm workflow. If anyone has gotten this to work with the latest builds, I'd be happy to try out their configs.

I've also tried out the alternatives of krohnkite (hi esjeon!) but what really breaks KDE is that you can't assign a workspace to each monitor. I have 3 monitors and I can independently assign each workspace to each monitor in i3wm and you can switch between them really easily. Its a massive productivity boost which keeps me sticking to i3wm even though KDE is more fully featured (blue-tooth, OSD etc...)

Re: KDE Plasma 5.20

#174

A line-up of comments from a frequent reviewer: "The Year of the Linux dissatisfaction" https://www.dedoimedo.com/computers/linux-year-of-dissatisfa...

That reviewer will be forever unsatisfied until Linux manages to cover all main and niche markets. That won't happen because there's no market drive for it. There's no company with a huge budget trying to develop a consumer-tailored Linux-based OS: the other two companies that develop consumer OSs do it just to sell additional hardware (Apple) or services (Microsoft). And expecting a community of people, each with their own interests, to just work for a goal that's not their own is but a fool's dream.

Re: KDE Plasma 5.20

#175
post #152
post #142

Serious question: I enabled a Plasma option to make windows transparent when I hover over their corresponding 'application rectangle' (sorry, not sure what to call it) in the panel. It drives me mad but I just can't figure out how I everenabled it. Ditto with transparent menus. Can anyone advise? In general I'm very happy with Plasma but it does expose UI options that can really harm the experience.

Configure Task Manager (get there by right-clicking on the task manager panel that you're talking about). Appearance (tab) -- and deselect 'Highlight Windows when hovering over tasks'.

THANK YOU SO MUCH!!

Re: KDE Plasma 5.20

#176

Good job, as expected by the Plasma team. I really feel like this is a big step in the right direction. A personal wish however would be that we got a more modern look to more desktop environments. Both Gnome, Plasma and Pantheon (default in Elementary OS) are talked about as the best looking desktop environments, but I'd be lying if I said that any of them looked awesome. There's just something about them that make…

Default GNOME theming has been quite atrocious (to me), but I've been using Arc-Dark with Papirus icons and Noto Sans fonts (usually already packaged in Debian-based distributions). I couldn't be more satisfied, and they play well with Nord (from Arctic Ice Studio) color themes.

Re: KDE Plasma 5.20

#177

Good job, as expected by the Plasma team. I really feel like this is a big step in the right direction. A personal wish however would be that we got a more modern look to more desktop environments. Both Gnome, Plasma and Pantheon (default in Elementary OS) are talked about as the best looking desktop environments, but I'd be lying if I said that any of them looked awesome. There's just something about them that make…

Default GNOME theming has been quite atrocious (to me), but I've been using Arc-Dark with Papirus icons and Noto Sans fonts (usually already packaged in Debian-based distributions). I couldn't be more satisfied, and they play well with Nord (from Arctic Ice Studio) color themes.

One of the most important design principles is consistency. Unfortunately that's an objective which is difficult for open source to fulfill. It would be great if the desktop environments themselves took the task of providing a couple of unified themes out of the box, where the colors, icons, fonts and everything else fit together.

Re: KDE Plasma 5.20

#178
post #50

I’ve been using Plasma for years, but after this release talking so much about the wayland improvements, the actual result is more than disappointing. First, to explain my setup: I've got a Dell UP2718Q in landscape, 3840x2160, 10-bit in DCI-P3 colorspace at 1.5x scale at 60Hz, side-by-side with a Fujitsu Siemens P17-2 in portrait, 1024x1280, 8-bit in sRGB colorspace at 1x scale at 75Hz 10-bit support isn’t there yet…

> Overall it’s a good start, but still not quite there yet. If you mean Wayland, both the linked article and the video within the article acknowledge this, calling Wayland a work-in-progress. I too am looking forward to the day they get there.

Sadly neither X11 nor Wayland is working well yet, and that’s before talking about stuff like 10-bit, colorspace or HDR support.

It’s getting better, but no linux distro is currently on a similar level as windows or mac in this regard

Re: KDE Plasma 5.20

#179
post #82

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Because having extra screenspace to keep docs/chat/... on is nice and an old screen is good enough for that?

Is it? It apparently is not good enough for the main screen. The thing is that scaling works just fine if all your displays use the same one. Two 4k screens -> awesome. Two fhd screen -> works just fine. It is only the combination of one hires and one lowres screen that is problematic. So my maybe naive take away is that if you care that your main screen is 4k, then no your old screen is not good enough. And if you t…

As I answered earlier: Different screens can be used for different purposes, and different purposes may have different requirements :)

Even if money was no issue and I could have two screens of the same quality, I’d still keep the old screen as a third screen.

For most people, more screens = better, but for me there’s also the fact that to actually design content, you need to be able to verify what this content is going to look like on the devices the users are going to use.

Re: KDE Plasma 5.20

#180

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> I always missed a desktop environment for power users, instead of one aiming for the average user. What types of things make a big difference for you? When I sit at my computer, it's to do something in an application. The desktop environment doesn't do much for me once I've launched the program that I'm actually there to use, does it? I'm generally pretty happy in Ubuntu or Windows or macOS or iPadOS.

You're lucky to have a workflow that depends in just one application and one window, then.

Multiple windows isn't a power user feature and it isn't a differentiator for KDE.
Post reply on HN