Live data from Hacker News

GitHub is working on renaming default branch from “master”

twitter.com

171–180 of 280 posts

Re: GitHub is working on renaming default branch from “master”

#171
post #143

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Oh that's the same thing. That indicates mastery over the material you studied. Knowledge has become subservient to you.

What about the master copy of a recording? That's what git's master is anyways.

I completely agree. My prior comment was a joke.

Re: GitHub is working on renaming default branch from “master”

#172
post #113

Everybody knowing that is a replacement for the word "Master". After 50 years, `Main` === `Master`. Will it? `root` is better if you really want to make a change. Or rand() is your friend. Maybe I'm not a native English speaker. After knowing the history of Master/Slave. I still not linking them to the bad side. If they can, rename `Git` also. Acutally I have some complaints from my clients before.

Your clients complained about the name git? (As an aside, you know Linus named both his projects after himself? :)

Re: GitHub is working on renaming default branch from “master”

#174

I'm a strong supporter of social justice. I don't really object to people putting in work to change language like that if they think it's important. Especially when the work required is minimal. That said, this is slightly ridiculous. Have customers seriously complained about the term "master"? And my impression was that the usage was more similar to "master copy" than "master of the plantation". Honestly, it's frust…

I am right there with you. The whole idea of "master" is not really based on the idea of slavery focused master. Master represents the final version of a component or software which ends up in production. It is the same meaning as an audio master ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mastering_(audio) ) If the word master is considered evil, then what would happen to a Master Degree ? or Dojo Master ? Words have different…

This is the danger of simply declaring a word "bad". You get all sorts of edge cases like this. This is like an automotive web site trying to prevent people from talking about retarding your ignition timing to prevent detonation. Sometimes words simply mean different things in different contexts.

Re: GitHub is working on renaming default branch from “master”

#175

Earlier quoted context omitted.

go to the top of this thread chain

I reviewed your initial post https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23500764 and I was unable to parse out of your objections why you think that this change hurts others. Could you summarize?

Inconsistent naming standards hurts everyone. Now some repositories will have master branches while others will have them named something else, it makes things harder to work with. If every developer spends just a minute wondering where the main branch is before realizing the new naming standards, that is still a lifetimes worth of time lost due to this change.

Re: GitHub is working on renaming default branch from “master”

#176

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Looking forward to the 'mega-debtor' degree tier.

How dare you. People in debt should not be discriminated against you insensitive clod! Platinum degree is a far more neutral term! Wait... No, my PC adviser has just informed me it is unethical to discriminate on the inherent values of precious metal... Are you... Excuse me, I did not mean to discriminate as to suggest there is a tier of metals of a higher desirability or intrinsic value than any of the other metals.…

This joke ends with "comrade".

Re: GitHub is working on renaming default branch from “master”

#177

"main" does seem like an objectively better word to use. The definition fits better in almost every use case. May seem like a silly gesture to some, but imagine feeling an emotional trigger every time you had to use a basic tool for your job. That'd piss me off.

"Main" is already taken. It is the entry point to a binary.

Re: GitHub is working on renaming default branch from “master”

#178

Earlier quoted context omitted.

go to the top of this thread chain

I reviewed your initial post https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23500764 and I was unable to parse out of your objections why you think that this change hurts others. Could you summarize?

Ok, here is my objection. I'm saying that it won't help people at all. It is an indulgence to make Microsoft feel like they are doing something positive when it will not materially improve lives.

It would be fine if it just made them feel good as people's mental health is an important thing that too many ignore. But, this will suck attention away from people who are actually doing things that will help people. The world has only so much time to pay attention, and that time is valuable. Microsoft is just adding to the noise.

They are bringing homemade cupcakes to a food bank and making the national news.

Re: GitHub is working on renaming default branch from “master”

#179

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Looking forward to the 'mega-debtor' degree tier.

How dare you. People in debt should not be discriminated against you insensitive clod! Platinum degree is a far more neutral term! Wait... No, my PC adviser has just informed me it is unethical to discriminate on the inherent values of precious metal... Are you... Excuse me, I did not mean to discriminate as to suggest there is a tier of metals of a higher desirability or intrinsic value than any of the other metals.…

Yas! And, I find the littir bitwiin "d" and "f" to b sixist and racist. Lit's git a whol gang of fimynists togithir to mak iviryon chang thiir languag or loos thiir jobs.

Re: GitHub is working on renaming default branch from “master”

#180
post #176

Earlier quoted context omitted.

How dare you. People in debt should not be discriminated against you insensitive clod! Platinum degree is a far more neutral term! Wait... No, my PC adviser has just informed me it is unethical to discriminate on the inherent values of precious metal... Are you... Excuse me, I did not mean to discriminate as to suggest there is a tier of metals of a higher desirability or intrinsic value than any of the other metals.…

This joke ends with "comrade".

Nawh, it would be Landsmann, Landsmännin, or the more PC Landsmännix.
Post reply on HN