Live data from Hacker News

The tech sec­tor might be evil

tbray.org

171–180 of 233 posts

Re: The tech sec­tor might be evil

#171
post #149

Earlier quoted context omitted.

why?

What positive value does it provide in your opinion?

Instant reports of witnesses about ongoing events and instant statements from those who are supposed to be in control of the ongoing events.

It's invaluable.

Re: The tech sec­tor might be evil

#172

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That’s a misreading of OP’s point: it’s not the employer that they have a problem with, it’s the morality of their employment.

Except that is literally what he said. As soon as they work for defense contractors they are no longer considered friends. Presumably no matter what they do, as long as they are associated they are guilty. Be it cleaning floors, writing software, testing hardware, or what have you.

It's not quite that abrupt. I used to work for a defense contractor. I started as a rather naive young engineer. I worked hard for many years on projects that were not weapons systems or even fielded systems, mostly R&D and advanced technology. It was very cool technology. But over the years I gradually became more and more aware of the kind of systems my employer was developing. And although I did not work directly on those systems I knew that some of the technology I was developing would eventually find its way into future versions of those systems. Colleagues would always say "We aren't building bombs so it's ok." But what we were building were key subsystems used for targeting. I eventually left for the non-defense world.

So it isn't that friends suddenly became ex's overnight. It is after coming to the realization that over time they either had sold out their ethics in order to make good money working on cool technology regardless of what it is used for, or that they really bought the indoctrination that what they were doing was important patriotic work. As for the latter, I heard that stuff a lot, and I always thought it was a bad sign that the boss had to kept telling you that you are doing important work. You weren't privy to much beyond your own compartmented subsystem but over time you could eventually piece together the bigger story. As for the former, that's similar to the non-defense world where a lot of smart engineers are developing shady stuff, except that it isn't resuling in thousands of people in far away lands being killed week in and week out as a result.

Re: The tech sec­tor might be evil

#173

Earlier quoted context omitted.

He's also 100% correct, Twitter should be de-listed and treated as a utility. It's too much of a public good to get gobbled up by Google or whoever.

What makes Twitter "too much of a public good" in your opinion?

It's very handy as a short message system for public announcements/information.

trying to turn it into anything else has kinda failed

Re: The tech sec­tor might be evil

#174

Data Science is evil :) There are a couple of big "tech-is-evil" forces that I think are responsible for a good chunk of this sentiment. The first is advertising. Ads are slightly evil anyway. You're going to make us watch an ad during intermission, and that'll make us buy your brand of washing powder? Sounds kind of evil. It never sat right with people, but it funded free news and entertainment so... we're used to t…

> So... data science is evil and the only way to stop it is a total ban numbers.

Nah. Banning collecting, storing, and exploiting data on people for any but a small set of very narrow purposes would do the trick.

Re: The tech sec­tor might be evil

#175
post #96

I'm really struggling to put into words how much this recent "moral" crusade against Facebook/Google/Amazon has begun to irritate me. My gut feeling is that unable to do anything about Trumps election victory all those enraged by his win are now turning their ire against companies that tangentially might have helped to get him elected.

I don't think those two things are related. This issue actually touches both sides. Steve Bannon was looking at anti-trust issues in the administration and Trump has raised similar issues about Amazon [1][2]. [1] https://theintercept.com/2017/07/27/steve-bannon-wants-faceb... [2] https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2017/08/steve...

I'd wager that has more to do with Bezos's ownership of the Washington Post rather than any anti-trust concerns the administration has about Amazon

Re: The tech sec­tor might be evil

#176
post #155

Data Science is evil :) There are a couple of big "tech-is-evil" forces that I think are responsible for a good chunk of this sentiment. The first is advertising. Ads are slightly evil anyway. You're going to make us watch an ad during intermission, and that'll make us buy your brand of washing powder? Sounds kind of evil. It never sat right with people, but it funded free news and entertainment so... we're used to t…

It's far more efficient I'm not sure we know this yet. They sell it like it is, and it seems like a good idea that makes sense, but at this point online ads perform in the same way as TV ads: They give us brand exposure. Most of the time I do an internet search I am not trying to purchase something, and I've never seen an ad that made me say as a result of that search "I need that" and make a purchase. When I'm doing…

[deleted]

Re: The tech sec­tor might be evil

#177

Curious how “There is grow­ing con­cern … about big­ness and size, and pow­er be­cause pow­er cor­rupts absolutely” among the growing fan club of a representative of the ultimate accumulation of bigness, size, and power: the government.

Governments, at least in the West, are elected and have a public mission compared to places like Google

Re: The tech sec­tor might be evil

#178

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Well, as a citizen of the UK who’s currently living in Sweden, I’ll provide the counterpoint that I refuse to work with any of our morally corrupt ‘defence’ industries and always bring it up as a red line with any company I interview at.

Which industry is not morally corupt then? I can see maybe single companies in given industries not behaving like total assholes, but on the whole I think all industries are rotten.

It’s a reasonable point; I stay away from tobacco, and am iffy about gambling and alcohol for the same reasons. But on the whole, the stuff I build is either generally beneficial for the user or at least inoffensive.

Buy hey, that’s just my opinion :) You do what you think’s best and I’ll do the same. My point was just that it’s not just the US who has people who are ‘out of touch’ (apparently).

Re: The tech sec­tor might be evil

#179
post #134

Most in the tech professions are progressive and liberal, is that so... Just because people might work in Silicon Valley doesn't mean they automatically align with that "way of thinking".

A company full of progressives and liberals is still profit-focused, and profit-centric decisions win out compared to the public good

Re: The tech sec­tor might be evil

#180

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I tend to be conservative, and I work in tech. It feels to me like a repressive atmosphere. Conservatives are muzzled or eliminated. It's not a healthy environment for anyone.

Calling yourself a conservative is meaningless. The US has shifted away from being a republic to being more of an oligarchy over the last 30 years. So if you are a supporter of oligarchs stand up and be counted. If you are a fiscal conservative you should be pissed that the republicans put the country farther in debt than the democrats do. If you are a social conservative, what the fuck is wrong with you? If you want…

[deleted]
Post reply on HN